5 ms·
One way to think about it is in terms of economic theory. Negotiations are fairest when both sides have equal power. But you have approximately one job, and a c
by wpietri 8y ago
One way to think about it is in terms of economic theory. Negotiations are fairest when both sides have equal power. But you have approximately one job, and a company typically has way more employees. It's more painful to lose a job than to have 1 employee quit. So the negotiation is fundamentally unfair.
So when it comes time to negotiate your annual raise, it's not you alone dueling with your boss (and the whole corporate hierarchy backing him up). Instead it's you and all your colleagues getting together, sending in some representatives, and saying, "Profits are way up this year, so we all deserve decent raises. Let's talk numbers."
(This is less interesting to tech workers, in that we already have a ton of salary negotiating power due to supply/demand differences. But personally I'd still like to see more collective action to deal with other issues. A good example is the way employees recently forced Google to get out of military contracting. Or imagine how different Uber might have treated employees if they'd had a union that helped keep awful managers in check.)
- rayiner 8y agoIs there economic theory supporting unions? Asymmetric negotiating leverage is not generally recognized as something that undermines market outcomes.
- pron 8y agoBut you don't care about market outcomes, but about your own personal outcome (and I assume the economic theory alluded to wasn't macroeconomic but micro). The market can converge to fair non-union wages, or it can converge to fair union wages, which would be higher. Capitalists claim that unions reduce overall profit and harm the market, but workers shouldn't care about that (i.e. lower stock performance and higher wages are better for workers, at least in practice, given actual wealth distribution).
- slavik81 8y agoYou are forgetting about customers. I own no companies and work for one company, but I am a customer of many. A personal cost/benefit analysis like the one you're describing would have to take that into account.
- pron 8y agoThe way it works is that management involves the union in its decisions, and they reach compromises. After all, it is also in the union's interest that the company stays viable. If all the increase in wages gets is paid for by an increase in prices, and management isn't willing to cut profits, then that's unlikely to be acceptable to the union. The goal is to keep the company performing well, but to even the playing field when negotiating the distribution of profit among management, shareholders and employees. This is called co-determination: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Co-determination https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Co-determination
- harryh 8y agoIndividuals might prioritize personal outcomes over market outcomes, but societies and governments should prioritize the latter.
- pron 8y ago> but societies and governments should prioritize the latter Societies should prioritize according to their values. I don't think that maximizing GDP is a universal value.
- wpietri 8y agoYeah. The consumer optimum is heavily exploited workers, as that drives labor costs down as much as possible. We're looking for a reasonable balance, so the value created by labor is shared between consumer, producer, and the many other people in the value chain.
- Phrodo_00 8y agoI'm not an economist, but, free market theory favors lots of competitors, fully informed customers, and low barriers of entry which can be thought of as trying to keep consumer and supplier with a balanced amount of leverage (too much leverage on the supplier's side creates monopolies, for example). Also, it's not really about positive market outcome in general (optimized market), but about positive outcomes for the employees.
- chimeracoder 8y ago> I'm not an economist, but, free market theory favors lots of competitors, fully informed customers, and low barriers of entry which can be thought of as trying to keep consumer and supplier with a balanced amount of leverage (too much leverage on the supplier's side creates monopolies, for example). That's a pretty strong argument against unions in the US, then, since (unlike in other countries) there's no competition between unions at an employer, there's almost no ability to deauthorize a union in practice (ie, choose a different union), and very high barriers to entry (very difficult to authorize a different union for representation in place of an existing one).
- Phrodo_00 8y agoBut the problem is that employers also have high barriers of entry (it's not easy to switch jobs, especially if you have to relocate), and there's usually low competition for blue collar work, since there's higher demand, which makes employers have overwhelming leverage. There are industries where that doesn't apply as much, and you can see that workers can get better compensation and benefits in those. Unions can equalize that leverage. I do think that unions could also have too much leverage, but I think that finding a happy medium is a worthy legislative goal.
- EthanHeilman 8y agoAsymmetric negotiating leverage is a key element of Marx's theory with regard to profit.
- overton 8y agoTo the extent that it's difficult or impossible for the workers to get another job, the employer has buyer's market power (in the extreme, a monopsony). It's a well-recognized phenomenon in economics literature. https://www.investopedia.com/terms/m/monopsony.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/m/monopsony.asp https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monopsony https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monopsony Like a monopolistic market, a monopsonistic market is inefficient compared to a competitive one. Employers gain "utility" at the expense of workers, but less than the workers lose compared to a competitive market. Unions can remedy this by becoming a monopolistic (or near monopolistic) supplier of labour, by negotiating a higher wage (price floor), bringing the wage closer to it would be in a competitive market. Long story short: if you're pro competitive markets, you need to recognize the benefits of unions. They're not an ideal solution, but the alternative is not a competitive market outcome. Edit: this seems like a pretty good explanation: http://www.economicsonline.co.uk/Business_economics/Monopsony.html http://www.economicsonline.co.uk/Business_economics/Monopson...
- epicureanideal 8y agoI think we should all be less confident in this idea that software engineers have tons of bargaining power. The salary is relatively high compared to the US average, but it's not obscene compared to say, product managers, high performing salespeople, etc. On occasion I've tried to pick up side jobs for 10-20 hours per week for a second company, and I've always been refused, not because I wasn't technically qualified but because they just weren't interested in considering non-standard work arrangements. If there were TRULY such a huge gulf in supply/demand, I would've been able to get a side job at 60-70% of my normal hourly-equivalent rate, for 10-20 hours per week, is my thinking. I've also observed a lot of stubbornness in salary bands and so on. By the way, I speak as a person who has previously made in excess of $200,000 per year in non-stock compensation.
- knuththetruth 8y agoExactly. We should also keep in mind that developers have already seen their wages depressed by collusion between the big tech firms (which was punished with a slap on the wrist). And that's just the case we found out about.
- wpietri 8y agoSure. I mentioned we have decent salary negotiating power because for many other industries that's the #1 reason to unionize, but I don't think many tech workers would find it compelling. Also, I'm not entirely sure your case is proof that there isn't a big supply/demand difference. I would be very unlikely to hire a developer 10 hours per week because software is collaborative intellectual work, and I'd have a hard time using somebody who wasn't around for much of the thinking and constantly needed to be brought up to date. Their efficiency (in terms of hours of actual coding versus hours of communication and keeping up with codebase changes) would be low, but their cost in terms of time spent by other workers would be at least the same. Occasionally I'll see small units of work that could safely be done by part-time contractors working on something solo. I definitely looked for this at my last startup, as my cofounder was correctly eager to accelerate things. But it was pretty rare that I found things where the cost/benefit ratio was at all decent.
- conanbatt 8y ago> One way to think about it is in terms of economic theory. Negotiations are fairest when both sides have equal power. But you have approximately one job, and a company typically has way more employees. It's more painful to lose a job than to have 1 employee quit. So the negotiation is fundamentally unfair. This is not correct. The company competes with all other companies for the same job. Not only that, but companies go bankrupt more often than people do. Businesses are the frail side of the equation, if you make any. > o when it comes time to negotiate your annual raise, it's not you alone dueling with your boss (and the whole corporate hierarchy backing him up). Instead it's you and all your colleagues getting together, sending in some representatives, and saying, "Profits are way up this year, so we all deserve decent raises. Let's talk numbers." Now let me answer with actual economic theory: microeconomics. The fundamental way to make something get a higher price is to increase its utility or to decrease its supply. Unions can increase salaries if they increase productivity (which they dont, in fact they do the exact opposite in the majority of cases, worker health being the best exception to this rule) and decrease supply (not allowing to hire other workers).
- UweSchmidt 8y agoSuggesting businesses are the frail side of the equation is absurd. If you ever talk to anyone stressed out by being unemployed, by applying for jobs, by worrying about leaving a terrible job but staying because of risk and transaction costs, this would be quite obvious. So strong is the business side, that business in many industries can afford to be quite terrible to their workers for a long long time. Regarding your other point, unions can also increase salaries by getting workers a larger piece of the pie. Not sure why you left out this obvious aspect of any negotiation?
- conanbatt 8y agoThats because you are looking at the businesses that survive, not the ones that die off. 8/10 businesses fail in 5~10 year range. The fact that you havent seen people stressed out for their business running into the ground is entirely due to not talking to people that have businesses that can be run into the ground. > Regarding your other point, unions can also increase salaries by getting workers a larger piece of the pie. Not sure why you left out this obvious aspect of any negotiation? Because that is a labor theory of value proposition. The pie does not work that way: the moment a businesses loses its competitive returns due to higher demands, it will stop investing capital unto itself and remain stagnant, while the capital goes to areas where it does not have such restrictions. Companies compete with each other fiercely, and a company that has workers that cant unionize will very much welcome such problems on their competitors!
- slavik81 8y agoThe power of unions is not just negotiating on behalf of a large group of employees. Imagine if instead of forming a union, the employees formed a worker's cooperative to contract out their labour. The two companies could then negotiate as equals. However, that cooperative would still not have nearly as much power as unions can have, because it would not be guaranteed an exclusive contract.