4 ms·
>> Citizens of liberal democracies do not expect to be frisked without good cause, or have their homes searched without a warrant. Lol. What world does this a
by sandworm101 8y ago
>> Citizens of liberal democracies do not expect to be frisked without good cause, or have their homes searched without a warrant.
Lol. What world does this author live in? I expect to be frisked every time I go to an airport or football game. I expect to have to turn my pockets out every time I cross the US-canada boarder. I'm not a minority, but I assume some who are will want to add to this train of thought re being frisked by cops.
And a warrant to search my home? Warrants are pieces of paper. Cops drive tanks and carry machine guns. Whether they bothered to phone a magistrate for permission before hand is the least of my concerns as they break down my door. Warrants only matter if they are going to charge me with something and want evidence admitted in court. Even then, there are so many exceptions. The evidence gets in. My concern isn't about paperwork, it's that I'll be swatted one night and they will shoot my dog.
Also, the "warrant requirement" is an American construct. It isn't a thing in places like Canada, which most would consider a very liberal democracy. Canadian cops can use evidence even if seized illegally. Nor do they have to stop questioning you if you demand a lawyer. Nor do you get a jury trial. Don't assume that all western democracies use the American legal system.
- mywittyname 8y agoI'm curious as to why you've been down-voted with no dissenting remarks. You're basically correct in my experience too (I've not been SWATed, but I've several former neighbors that have).
- sandworm101 8y agoPeople hate posts that strike to close to home. I've haven't had any neighbours swatted, but I have had friends online targeted. It is something that can haunt you for years.
- HillaryBriss 8y agoyour comment touches on something i often wonder about: the differences between US civil rights and the civil rights in our liberal democratic allies (e.g. Canada, the UK, France, et al). i had no idea that in Canada of all places "cops can use evidence even if seized illegally." i do know, however, that government censorship of the media is permissible in the UK. there's no single definition of "democracy" across the world. it's interesting that some in the US seem to think that, if an individual right is ever modified or restricted in the US, it means we're at "the end of democracy." while, at the same time, these very same rights are routinely restricted in other countries but we still consider those countries to be "democracies."
- gruez 8y ago>i had no idea that in Canada of all places "cops can use evidence even if seized illegally." according to [1], it's not a blanket yes or no. it's a balance of whichever choice would make the justice system look worse. ie. turning someone's home up-side down to find 1g of weed vs a serial murderer getting away with murder because the judge didn't fill out the paperwork properly. [1] https://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Canadian_Criminal_Procedure_and_Practice/Search_and_Seizure/Print_version#General_Principles_9 https://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Canadian_Criminal_Procedure_an...
- rikkus 8y agoThat's quite a cynical way of explaining this. Is it possible to interpret this as it being allowed to use evidence seized illegally if, on balance, justice would be better served?
- sandworm101 8y agoThe rule in Canada is that the evidence is admitted unless its admission will "bring the administration of justice into disrepute". So where the cops act like total jerks and break into someone's house for no good reason, the court can throw out the evidence. But the court isn't going to let a drug dealer go free because the cops didn't get a warrant before searching the trunk of his car. The perception of rights goes both ways. Canadians sometimes laugh at the US legal system. Canadians see crimes like felony-murder or misdemeanor-manslaughter as ridiculous. So too with the American tradition of supernatural punishment (ie "life plus twenty"). And the duel-sovereign thing, the risk of being tried in state and then again federal court, is very strange outside the US. The biggest cultural difference has to be the levels of incarceration. As the US increased punishment in recent years, Canada did the opposite. Have a look at their military prison. It is more often than not empty. https://globalnews.ca/news/4097208/military-prison-edmonton-empty/ https://globalnews.ca/news/4097208/military-prison-edmonton-...
- cgriswald 8y ago> So too with the American tradition of supernatural punishment (ie "life plus twenty"). This isn't "supernatural punishment". It's sentencing for more than one crime. Life, probably for murder, plus 20 for (say) armed robbery. It's not meaningless to tack on those 20 years. If the murder conviction is overturned, so is the life sentence, but not those 20 years, unless those convictions are also overturned.
- jellicle 8y ago> Also, the "warrant requirement" is an American construct. It isn't a thing in places like Canada, which most would consider a very liberal democracy. Canadian cops can use evidence even if seized illegally. Nor do they have to stop questioning you if you demand a lawyer. Nor do you get a jury trial. Don't assume that all western democracies use the American legal system. While Canada's justice system is noticeably different than the US's, it isn't generally worse at protecting the rights of the public. Yes, there are search warrants, and in fact Canada is more protective of an individual's home than the US is. Yes, you have the right to a jury trial for serious crimes. Yes, you have the right to remain silent (though it is somewhat different). Both the US and Canada can often use evidence seized illegally - the judges in both places have the ability, but not the obligation, to throw out such evidence.
- sandworm101 8y agoBut try taking to an american about the concepts of summary, indictable and hybrid offensives. The idea that crown prosecutors can decide how to try a case is very alien to their clear-cut system of felonies and misdemeanors. >> Both the US and Canada can often use evidence seized illegally - the judges in both places have the ability, but not the obligation, to throw out such evidence. Look that one up. The US is very big on the exclusionary rule. If evidence was seized improperly, unconstitutionally, it is out. The most famous US criminal cases (think Miranda) involve excluding evidence for such reasons, even if that means an admitted criminal is to be set free. The concept so permeates US legal culture that courts take is as a necessary implication whenever discussing evidence.
- jellicle 8y agoUS cop-TV shows often treat it as a given, but US courts allow in bad evidence more often than not. US supreme court decisions are generally against the exclusionary rule, and it's likely to mostly disappear in the US in the near future, except for very rich defendants. Here's the most recent one: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hudson_v._Michigan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hudson_v._Michigan where everyone involved says the evidence was seized improperly, unconstitutionally, but the evidence is very much in and the defendants are in prison today.
- zucan 8y agoIn a European country with restricted access to guns most likely, where the police doesn't need tanks and machine guns to keep a situation under control. Also most people travel by train or car so they only get searched when they go on vacation.