6 ms·

In terms of poverty, is there a difference between getting more wealth vs everything becoming cheaper? I don't think there is - your life has improved just the

In terms of poverty, is there a difference between getting more wealth vs everything becoming cheaper? I don't think there is - your life has improved just the same either way. Fixating on silly numbers that ultimately mean nothing doesn't seem like a good way to make the world better. We should look at concrete things - and how often you can eat an orange is the kind of concrete thing that really matters.

BrainInAJar 8y ago
> In terms of poverty, is there a difference between getting more wealth vs everything becoming cheaper? Yes. The delta between the richest and poorest indicates a lot of things about a society.
- RyanZAG 8y ago
  What does it indicate? You can go to a place like Mauritius where the delta is enormous, but everyone is pretty happy and the rich and poor mingle freely. Or you can have a place like France where the delta is far smaller, but the rich and poor detest each other and very rarely mingle.
  - adamsea 8y ago
    In 2014 The Gini coefficient for Mauritas was 30 and for France it was 40. The top 1% in France has about 20% of the total income as of 2014. For Mauritas no suitable data was found for wealth inequality or dispersion of earnings. The lack of good data for Mauritas makes a comparison between the two questionable. Plus even after looking at the numbers for these countries I would want to check out money laundering - if I recall, based on the Panama papers, a nontrivial amount of the 1% (probably more like the 0.1%s) wealth is laundered/hidden/dark. I don’t know if the studies here attempt to account for that or not. I would imagine money laundering is prevalent in France (or any major economy for that matter), possibly in Mauritas https://www.chartbookofeconomicinequality.com/inequality-by-country/mauritius/ https://www.chartbookofeconomicinequality.com/inequality-by-... https://www.chartbookofeconomicinequality.com/inequality-by-country/france/ https://www.chartbookofeconomicinequality.com/inequality-by-... Information on data sources here - https://www.chartbookofeconomicinequality.com/about/ https://www.chartbookofeconomicinequality.com/about/ As of 2018 the population of Mauritas is 1.26 million (via google search). The 2018 population of France is 65.23 million (via google search). The 2014 population probably was not radically different. I wonder if the size of the society in question matters here - is comparing a country to one 65 times larger than it useful? I did not look for data to validate the hypothesis that everyone is pretty happy in Mauritas as opposed to France.
  - pschon 8y ago
    Back in the 90's I saw the same thing when living in Brazil. A friend in his 70's who owned real estate in Rio owned a Rolls recently returned from NYC. He said he was shocked at seeing the hatred in the eyes of people in NYC. He countered how he could stop for a coffee or beer or anything else and just talk to anyone who was there regardless of the socio-economic status. I had to agree. I always wondered why there was not more discontent.
paublyrne 8y ago
Oranges may have become cheaper in relative terms, but property sure hasn't. In many parts of the world property is more inaccessible than ever before for similar social economic groups.
- RyanZAG 8y ago
  That's just artificial scarcity, right? Rural property out in the woods is just as cheap as its ever been, in my experience. Cities just have a lot of laws preventing a lot of things, but I think most people who choose to live in cities prefer it like that.
  - petra 8y ago
    Maybe.But Germany has cities but they created a political system(after ww2) optimized for cheap real-estate , and they do have fine cities, while their real-estate prices has Rose neglibly over the last few decades.
    - stealthmodeclan 8y ago
      German manufacturers are not limited to few cities. There are factories in villages too.
    - maxxxxx 8y ago
      "while their real-estate prices has Rose neglibly over the last few decades." Those days are over. Germany has a huge real estate problem right now.
  - paublyrne 8y ago
    I'm not sure the relevance of it being artificial or not is here. The reality is that many people in their 20s and 30s can't buy a house, while their parents could, even if their parents were less affluent by many measures, say in orange purchasing power.
    - prewett 8y ago
awat 8y ago
This is really the question that throw’s people for loops in my experience. Not contextually what you were addressing but in comparison to my parents in the US. Many things are much more inexpensive jeans, shoes (functional not trendiest), entry-level tools, computers, media, etc. Whats not more inexpensive and what imho really actually matters are things like education, housing, and the barrier to entry to careers (require licensing, certfications etc.)

BrainInAJar 8y ago

> In terms of poverty, is there a difference between getting more wealth vs everything becoming cheaper? Yes. The delta between the richest and poorest indicates a lot of things about a society.

RyanZAG 8y ago
What does it indicate? You can go to a place like Mauritius where the delta is enormous, but everyone is pretty happy and the rich and poor mingle freely. Or you can have a place like France where the delta is far smaller, but the rich and poor detest each other and very rarely mingle.
- adamsea 8y ago
  In 2014 The Gini coefficient for Mauritas was 30 and for France it was 40. The top 1% in France has about 20% of the total income as of 2014. For Mauritas no suitable data was found for wealth inequality or dispersion of earnings. The lack of good data for Mauritas makes a comparison between the two questionable. Plus even after looking at the numbers for these countries I would want to check out money laundering - if I recall, based on the Panama papers, a nontrivial amount of the 1% (probably more like the 0.1%s) wealth is laundered/hidden/dark. I don’t know if the studies here attempt to account for that or not. I would imagine money laundering is prevalent in France (or any major economy for that matter), possibly in Mauritas https://www.chartbookofeconomicinequality.com/inequality-by-country/mauritius/ https://www.chartbookofeconomicinequality.com/inequality-by-... https://www.chartbookofeconomicinequality.com/inequality-by-country/france/ https://www.chartbookofeconomicinequality.com/inequality-by-... Information on data sources here - https://www.chartbookofeconomicinequality.com/about/ https://www.chartbookofeconomicinequality.com/about/ As of 2018 the population of Mauritas is 1.26 million (via google search). The 2018 population of France is 65.23 million (via google search). The 2014 population probably was not radically different. I wonder if the size of the society in question matters here - is comparing a country to one 65 times larger than it useful? I did not look for data to validate the hypothesis that everyone is pretty happy in Mauritas as opposed to France.
- pschon 8y ago
  Back in the 90's I saw the same thing when living in Brazil. A friend in his 70's who owned real estate in Rio owned a Rolls recently returned from NYC. He said he was shocked at seeing the hatred in the eyes of people in NYC. He countered how he could stop for a coffee or beer or anything else and just talk to anyone who was there regardless of the socio-economic status. I had to agree. I always wondered why there was not more discontent.

paublyrne 8y ago

Oranges may have become cheaper in relative terms, but property sure hasn't. In many parts of the world property is more inaccessible than ever before for similar social economic groups.

RyanZAG 8y ago
That's just artificial scarcity, right? Rural property out in the woods is just as cheap as its ever been, in my experience. Cities just have a lot of laws preventing a lot of things, but I think most people who choose to live in cities prefer it like that.
- petra 8y ago
  Maybe.But Germany has cities but they created a political system(after ww2) optimized for cheap real-estate , and they do have fine cities, while their real-estate prices has Rose neglibly over the last few decades.
  - stealthmodeclan 8y ago
    German manufacturers are not limited to few cities. There are factories in villages too.
  - maxxxxx 8y ago
    "while their real-estate prices has Rose neglibly over the last few decades." Those days are over. Germany has a huge real estate problem right now.
- paublyrne 8y ago
  I'm not sure the relevance of it being artificial or not is here. The reality is that many people in their 20s and 30s can't buy a house, while their parents could, even if their parents were less affluent by many measures, say in orange purchasing power.
  - prewett 8y ago

awat 8y ago

This is really the question that throw’s people for loops in my experience. Not contextually what you were addressing but in comparison to my parents in the US. Many things are much more inexpensive jeans, shoes (functional not trendiest), entry-level tools, computers, media, etc. Whats not more inexpensive and what imho really actually matters are things like education, housing, and the barrier to entry to careers (require licensing, certfications etc.)