I've had the same experience with Arcanist. I think it might be a good solution if the team is not very experienced with Git, as it provides a straightforward w

I've had the same experience with Arcanist. I think it might be a good solution if the team is not very experienced with Git, as it provides a straightforward workflow. However, using some more "advanced" features myself, I felt crippled. My main pain point was about squashing all PR commits automatically (i.e. enforcing the Squash Merge strategy). Again, this might be a good idea for junior developers, but I'd rather decide myself how to separate my commits. I also remember having some issues with Arcanist on Windows.