3 ms·
This is a very specific and recent interpretation of the first amendment. Your theory that no nuance is possible does not match how the constitution is applied
by wpietri 8y ago
This is a very specific and recent interpretation of the first amendment. Your theory that no nuance is possible does not match how the constitution is applied in general, or even how that amendment is dealt with specifically, both historically and currently. For example, defamation is still illegal, even if you do it to influence an election. Campaign finance limits have been weakened, but still exist and are enforced. It also doesn't wipe out other speech crimes, like fraud, conspiracy, and obstruction of justice, even if they're part of a campaign.
It's not a particularly tough spot except from the perspective of very strong textual literalism.