5 ms·
I... get the idea, and support it. I don't understand the implementation. What is the point of creating an onion address and then publicizing it? Why not jus
by ajross 8y ago
I... get the idea, and support it. I don't understand the implementation.
What is the point of creating an onion address and then publicizing it? Why not just use Tor to get to 1.1.1.1 in the first place? Onion URLs are for services that don't want to reveal themselves.
Basically, what does this enable that generic Tor does not?
- megous 8y agoYour circuit presumably terminates at CloudFlare infrastructure and not at a random exit node where the packets need to be routed again over the open internet to CloudFlare. I wonder if latency is better.
- superkuh 8y agoJust because they're called hidden services doesn't mean they have to be hidden. Tor hidden services offer a lot that the clear web and normal domain system does not. For one, you own your domain rather than lease it on the whims of some institution that can be easily pressured to kick you off (like cloudflare and registrars did against stormfront, for example). And of course going completely within Tor is a great speed-bump for preventing massive surveillance. I run all of my clear web sites as tor hidden services too and publish the domains for both publicly on both. But I wouldn't trust Cloudflare to not censor anything controversial. They're already proven themselves an enemy of free speech and an enemy of tor by their behavior. Words mean little.
- deno 8y ago> But I wouldn't trust Cloudflare to not censor anything controversial. They're already proven themselves an enemy of free speech and an enemy of tor by their behavior. Words mean little. Preferably you wouldn’t have to trust any single provider at all, regardless if you deem them trustworthy. Why can’t we have Alt-Svc for DNS that points to blockchain?
- Operyl 8y ago“The blockchain” is slow, clunky, and not the magical unicorn everybody tries to make it out to be.
- deno 8y agoIt’s perfectly suited for a name directory however. In fact it would be faster because every resolver would have the global view of the entire name space. Anyway, DNS propagation is not exactly instant, either; so it’s not like you can make a worse system very easily.
- nly 8y ago> Basically, what does this enable that generic Tor does not? End-to-end encryption. If you query 1.1.1.1 over Tor then exit nodes can diddle with your traffic.
- AstralStorm 8y agoIf you're using DNSSEC then they can't mess with your DNS either. However, it is very readable by the exit node - just like Host header in HTTP or server_name in TLS.
- tptacek 8y agoSure they can. Virtually nothing is DNSSEC-signed. And if you're using someone else's DNSSEC server, and not running your own server on your own machine, the link between you and your DNS server is completely unprotected.
- ajross 8y agoBut DNS over TLS already provides that even without Tor.
- rmc 8y agoIn order to use this, you no longer need to go via the regular internet, and use an exit node. Many people don't like running exit nodes, but would run a relay nodew.