2 ms·
If guerilla chefs can set up trucks, so can Starbucks[1]. How would we feel about Starbucks launching a fleet of cafe trucks and parking them right near indepen
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
If guerilla chefs can set up trucks, so can Starbucks[1]. How would we feel about Starbucks launching a fleet of cafe trucks and parking them right near independent coffee houses?...But I don't want every neighborhood restaurant in the South Loop replaced by Potbelly's, Jimmy Johns, and Dunkin' Donuts, which is exactly what will happen if food trucks make the margins on brick-and-mortar restaurants untenable for independent operators.
I'd like to ban bikes which are not sold by specialty bike shops, because I'm worried that competition from walmart (and their $35 bikes) might put Trek and my local bike shop out of business. How do the people who don't want to spend $300 on a bike feel about this? Screw them, their desires are irrelevant.
And don't get me started on automobiles! I don't want every neighborhood buggy whip maker replaced by a Ford dealership, which is exactly what would happen if automobiles make the margins on buggy whip manufacturers untenable.
- tptacek 16y agoI'm having trouble connecting your analogy to my analogy, which is the trouble with analogies. In this case, we're not talking about "old" vs. "new"; we're talking about one group of merchants who rent retail space and pay taxes, and another group which does neither, offers a substitutable good, and uses public space to do it. Like I said, I like the food trucks, but the city is already pricing out independent restaurant operators without effectively subsidizing another class of competitors.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoIn your post, you advocated protectionism - regulating food trucks since you were concerned they might drive less efficient business into bankruptcy. I advocated protectionism for buggy whip manufacturers and high end bike sellers. As for the new rationalizations you came up with in this post, I agree with you. We should charge market rates for parking, both for food trucks and for commuters. Food trucks should (and do) pay sales tax and property tax on their vehicles. And we should charge them based on externalities they create (e.g., crowds, litter). The fact that they don't pay property tax on land is irrelevant - they don't own land. Similarly, taxi drivers don't pay the Stable Tax or Horse Food Tax (assuming such taxes existed in the days of horse drawn carriages). Why should they pay taxes on such goods? I'm all in favor of properly regulating food trucks. But I'm not in favor of protectionism, which is what you were advocating.
- tptacek 16y agoI'm not sure I'm in favor of protectionism either, Chris! I - like - the - food - trucks! They are awesome. I wish Chicago had more of them. What I am saying is that I think this is an interesting example of how political absolutes fail. If you're going to zone for retail activity, then the word for "transient retail businesses" isn't "efficient", it's "unlawful". Maybe we shouldn't zone? There are predictable (but maybe acceptable) poor outcomes from that move too. So what's interesting to me is that the only reasonable way forward is to balance interests, devise policies, and iterate over time; in other words, the community has to shape the development of the market, not just the invisible hand.