4 ms·
"Tesla minority shareholder launches stillborn bid to take out the chairman of the company" I'm not sure if this attempt is just a pathological need to show of
by raverbashing 8y ago
"Tesla minority shareholder launches stillborn bid to take out the chairman of the company"
I'm not sure if this attempt is just a pathological need to show off or just some MBAtitis.
Activist investors are an annoyance of public companies.
- jakobegger 8y agoI don’t understand this. If you don’t want other people to have a say in your company, why would you make it public? If you own shares of a company, you have certain rights, and I don’t see anything wrong with making use of them.
- yreg 8y ago>why would you make it public? $$$
- kelnos 8y agoIf making use of those rights ends up being a distraction to the company that hurts it more than leaving well enough alone, then you're only losing money for yourself. Just because a shareholder has decided to exercise shareholder rights, it doesn't mean it's actually a good idea. Sometimes activist investors have the right idea. Often they don't. > * If you don’t want other people to have a say in your company, why would you make it public?* It's a trade-off. You get money in return for greater public transparency and oversight. You don't have to like it to see the need to go for it.
- walshemj 8y agoNot if you have the multiple share classes with wildly different voting rights - though in the UK that will get you kicked out of the FTSE index if you take the piss that way.
- txsh 8y agoInvestors are owners. They own the company. You're saying the owners of the company are annoying to the people working for the company.
- raverbashing 8y agoYes, but it's different Say you buy a car with someone, you'll use it for 80% of the time, and the other person would use it for the remaining 20% Would you agree if the other owner would spend his 20% driving recklessly, redlining the engine just because the car is his? And in public companies you don't even get to pick who is buying that minor percentage
- function_seven 8y agoNow look at it from the other side. You're the 20% owner of that car and you begin to realize the primary owner is neglecting oil changes and abusing the engine. Just because you use it on weekends doesn't mean your complaints are unreasonable. Activist investors aren't always wrong. It may have lead to Ballmer's ouster at MS for example. Or earning Dell shareholders more money when Mr. Dell took it private. https://www.forbes.com/sites/nathanvardi/2013/09/03/valueact-hedge-funds-huge-microsoft-victory/#8d9fe8318ae4 https://www.forbes.com/sites/nathanvardi/2013/09/03/valueact...
- lefstathiou 8y agoI am a little conflicted on this. This a complex topic so I won’t fully develop the point but I can see a rational basis for CEOs to not treat their companies as a “shared” resource and I would argue that when an investment is made in a company there is an implicit understanding that you are being invited to participate in the economic opportunity but not so much in the control. To work off your analogy, it is akin to “going along for the ride” as opposed to sharing the car. Yes, you own 20% of the car but you agreed that someone else would do the driving and chart the course. If you don’t like the way they are driving, get out and hop into another car. I think it is a bit much to be a minority investor and expect the entire operation to retool when that is a significantly more expensive proposition for the company than it is for you to simply exit the position and buy someone else’s stock. Again, I am not totally confident in this view...
- jernfrost 8y agoWhen we hear the word "owner" we associate that with full ownership, as if you own a car, house or whatever and take care of it and use it. This kind of ownership is much closer to lending money to someone. While they are technically owners, emotionally speaking the arrangement is much more as if Elon Musk owns the company and the "owners" lent him money. Elon Musk is the person who has built the company and spent a considerable amount of time working in it, putting his heart and soul into the company. An investor can jump in at any time and become an "owner". Does not mean an investor has the same emotional attachment to the company. Say you build a house with lots of efforts over many years and live there for decades. To pay the bills you sell ownership shared in the house to investors. What happens to that house is going to matter a lot more to you than the investor. It is not without reason that family run companies often outperform stock owned companies. When you have an attachment to a company beyond mere short term profit, that is a stronger bond.
- alter_eco123 8y ago> I'm not sure if this attempt is just a pathological need to show off or just some MBAtitis. Most likely, the guy is just highly concerned about what's going on with the company. He may be in danger of losing a lot of money. Bubblicious times can end suddenly, any moment now. Yes, you may have seen people saying that for several years. That doesn't mean it's not true.
- jacquesm 8y agoActivist investors, however annoying they may be, are still investors. If you don't want to deal with investors / shareholders don't go public.
- compcoffee 8y ago>Activist investors are an annoyance of public companies. Silicon Valley mentality, right there.