3 ms·
I've been seeing a bunch of "redesigns" of HN over the last few days, and none of them seem to acknowledge/realise that HN has pretty much nailed it's core purp
by Andrenid 16y ago
I've been seeing a bunch of "redesigns" of HN over the last few days, and none of them seem to acknowledge/realise that HN has pretty much nailed it's core purpose in the current design. Sure it's not "shiny" or "pretty" but the accentuations are on the right thing... the content.
Most of the redesigns try and accentuate the people's profile links, post times, and other metadata, whereas I think HN's biggest design strength is that the front page is an easily-readable list of post titles, with all other metadata small and hidden. Also, when actually reading a post page, the post text itself is the prominent readable part, with metadata once again small and out of the way. We come here to read the articles, and click the links. The when/who of each post is really just a post-script and shouldn't be any more noticeable than it is already.
I haven't seen a single redesign (all of which claim to be "easier to read") that is actually easier to read, or better laid out than the current HN. Then again, that's just my personal opinion on it all.
Short answer: No. It doesn't need changing. If anything, it just needs people to be more focussed on voting up the relevant content, and less of the "fluff".
- vladocar 16y agoI also love the HN minimalism. I will never change that. My problems are: I go to google in order to search HN. I can't find my bookmarks on Delicios some valuable HN tips articles. I waned to build one HN api and I want some official HN API for that. I think that HN can work to improve the readability, it happens to me that I need to search sometimes more than 10 seconds to find some article that I now is there. I'm not talking about changing everything I'm talking about changing the small things.
- benologist 16y agoThe biggest thing that irritates me is no thread collapsing ala reddit's.