4 ms·
Is anyone else getting tired of everyone playing editor on HN? In some cases its nice when clickbait headlines are reduced to their original content. However
by chapium 8y ago
Is anyone else getting tired of everyone playing editor on HN? In some cases its nice when clickbait headlines are reduced to their original content. However threads like this are drowning out the conversation about the subject matter.
- CamelCaseName 8y agoIt would be nice if such comments were hidden or filtered (with no karma penalty of course) once reviewed by a moderator. Or at least, given a substantial visibility penalty.
- chapium 8y agoSeems pretty fair.
- lakechfoma 8y agoI wouldn't bother clicking on this link if I knew it was the state. So no, I'm not tired of everyone playing editor because it benefits me in the end. I also don't agree that such threads drown the conversation. Often they're buried. Sometimes they are a healthy part of the conversation itself. Sometimes there's a passive aggressive argument about whether or not the conversation is healthy and hey maybe even that's healthy!
- chapium 8y agoI seem to be in the minority, carry on.
- notReallyNope 8y agoNo. Sometimes reading the headline is enough, if the headline is correct. Those of use that really want to know more, will read the article on its own merit, because we’re interested, not because we’re being manipulated into a deeper curiosity than warranted. Meanwhile, complaining about aggressive journalistic tactics is not forum sliding. Keep in mind, beyond linguistic syntax, semantics and other trivial technical matters, much of HN doesn’t qualify as experts on non-technology-oriented stories, and political tripe. Some articles aren’t colored up very much by HN peanut galleries and bike shedding. This is might be one such instance. Anyway, when we notice deceptive practices we complain about them.