3 ms·
Being a woman, being African American or being transgendered aren't political ideologies, nor are they mutually opposed to conservative beliefs.
by krapp 8y ago
Being a woman, being African American or being transgendered aren't political ideologies, nor are they mutually opposed to conservative beliefs.
- PKop 8y agoPolitical demographics data would dispute that statement. Those groups you listed, especially in combination, are highly correlated with liberal voting. Is that something we should ignore? If white males correlate highly with conservative voting, relative to these other groups.. then, oh look, now we have hiring quotas that, in practice, divides strongly along political ideology whether you look at that way or not. Why do you think they call it "identity politics"? Because effectively aligning groups you've defined towards a political side, then applying all sorts of rules and policies in terms of those groups leads to... political power.
- toasterlovin 8y agoI don't think the person you were responding to was saying that those categories are political ideologies.
- krapp 8y agoI mean, I don't think they accidentally implied a spectrum of "political diversity" with 'conservatives' on one side and minorities on the other. The implication, clearly, is that the presence of these in the workplace is primarily the result of liberal political bias.
- toasterlovin 8y agoI think they were trying to make the point that there isn't any discrimination along the lines of race or sexual orientation at Google, but instead along the lines of political affiliation, so that's where Google should focus it's diversity efforts.
- tux1968 8y agoThat's not the point. The point is there is an identifiable group that is underrepresented within Google. It doesn't matter why, it doesn't matter who, it doesn't matter if it's "political". All that matters is that it is clearly discriminatory.
- wavefunction 8y agoWell before we take care of "conservatives" we should definitely take care of the quotas for the anarchists, socialists, georgists, monarchists, and nihilists who are far too under represented at Google. We'll get around to the conservatives some time in never.
- tux1968 8y agoIndeed. The entire effort is so transparently biased and agenda laden it should be scrapped.
- lern_too_spel 8y agoPeople with low IQs? People who are antagonistic?
- tux1968 8y agoDo you honestly think that all conservatives have low IQ's? This kind of argument seems so counterproductive. For whatever it's worth, i've met a lot of highly intelligent people who happen to have different political beliefs than mine. They shouldn't have reduced opportunity, just because they are conservative.
- lern_too_spel 8y agoThere certainly are conservatives with high IQs, but if you draw the distribution of IQs among conservatives and compare it with the distribution of IQs for people who are not, you will find a far larger mass in the distribution of non-conservatives with high IQs to the right of 120. This will lead to the underrepresentation of conservatives in companies whose hiring practices prefer high IQ candidates. Damore conveniently made a plot for illustration.
- sheepmullet 8y ago> Being a woman, being African American or being transgendered aren't political ideologies, nor are they mutually opposed to conservative beliefs. That's true and a great point - the top tech companies discriminate against African American conservatives, transgender conservatives, and female conservatives too! Perhaps even more so!