5 ms·
How much of it is choice though? I suspect the vast majority of super commuting isn’t by choice - especially if you include people who want to have any money le
by olliej 8y ago
How much of it is choice though? I suspect the vast majority of super commuting isn’t by choice - especially if you include people who want to have any money left over after baseline expenses.
If you work in Mountain View for example there is nothing on the market less than 1 million, so you would have to be at the high end of earners at google to get a house there (I recall a person on twitter saying that they were unable to afford Mountain View or Palo Alto even though both she and her husband worked at google).
I commute for 3 hours a day, and that required a 200k down payment.
I can’t imagine someone making a even twice median wage getting much closer than that, even renting.
- indemnity 8y agoHow large a percentage of post tax income are people comfortable paying into mortgage in the US? 1 million is a lot, but that’s the average house price in my area as well, and we are certainly not getting SV level salaries here, so it seems quite conservative that two Google employees can’t make payments on a $1 million house. I mean, 150k is what, roughly 8k a month take home? (Don’t know CA tax). Two people making that can easily afford 7-8k a month on the mortgage. Most people here are paying 50-60% of household income as mortgage payment. Myself included, but that’s because wife no longer works. It was 30% when she was still working, and I’m intentionally overpaying to derisk for the next recession, as well as being on a shorter term (10 years). Crazy though, interest rates just have to go to 7% and most I know will lose their house.
- smt88 8y ago> How large a percentage of post tax income are people comfortable paying into mortgage in the US? Isn't a substantial portion of a monthly mortgage payment deductible? > it seems quite conservative that two Google employees can’t make payments on a $1 million house. With 20% down, that comes out to ~$5,000/mo in principal, interest, taxes, and insurance. That's $30k/year/person, which is certainly a lot, but it's also within reach of someone making ~$100k+. I think the most unlikely part of that scenario is the $200k down payment. Maybe people are borrowing more to get a huge mortgage, in which case I'm sure you're right. > interest rates just have to go to 7% and most I know will lose their house. Because they didn't get fixed rates? Or just hypothetically, they wouldn't be able to afford their house today?
- supertrope 8y agoOnly the interest was deductible with several caveats. It was only about 25% of the interest, there is a max mortgage amount, and there is an income phase out. The new tax law limits state and local tax deduction to $10K.
- indemnity 8y ago> Isn’t a substantial portion of a monthly mortgage payment deductible? Wow, mortgage payment deductions on owner occupied properties exist in the US? Makes sense why people talk about pre-tax income when calculating affordability there then. Here nothing about a mortgage payment is tax deductible for the property you live in, only the interest of a mortgage payment on investment properties, and that rule is not long for this world. > I think the most unlikely part of that scenario is the 200k down payment The down payment requirement is steep, but here it is 20% which isn’t nothing, and we saved that in three years on slightly above average incomes for the area. Granted, living in house sharing arrangement so we could actually save. > Because they didn’t get fixed rates? We generally can’t fix mortgages for terms longer than 5 years here, so interest rate risk exists until you have a decent amount of equity. Most people fix for 2, because for the past decade rates have only been going down, but I imagine that pendulum has swung and people are carefully watching what’s happening in the US.
- olliej 8y agoJust to clarify - 1 million is low balling. The area I live now - Palo Alto/Mountain View/etc I would be surprised if you got below 2 million. The real problem though is that if you’re getting a mortgage you end up having to pay a further premium on the cost in order to compete with people making cash offers. As far as mortgage write offs on taxes I think it’s just interest component of your payments, and the new tax bill removes most of those for individuals -
- dev_north_east 8y ago> I commute for 3 hours a day Do you think it's worth it? I can't imagine putting in the amount of hours you do, so wondering do you enjoy it? Is the work worth it? And is it because there's no alternative? My own situation is UK, non-London based. I've been offered jobs there but the commute and house prices just wouldn't do it for me. Right now I have a nice job, nowhere near London salaries but very good for the area, and a nice twenty minute walk to and from work in the morning. If it's raining I just take a 5 minute metro train. Not saying I'm better or worse, just interested in hearing from someone with a very different day to day experience.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]