I disagree with you there. "Modus ponens" implies sound reasoning on the implication part, not ad-hoc claims and hyperbole. As a thought experiment: Replace "M

I disagree with you there. "Modus ponens" implies sound reasoning on the implication part, not ad-hoc claims and hyperbole. As a thought experiment: Replace "Microsoft" with your favorite open source project and see if the argumentation still holds.