4 ms·
> Really, the whole piece is about how few people are going into this trade, and I can't see how people can't be brought into it if the demand's there. Becaus
by vkou 8y ago
> Really, the whole piece is about how few people are going into this trade, and I can't see how people can't be brought into it if the demand's there.
Because you may spend years getting a degree in making lab glassware, only to find yourself put out a job because someone invents a glassblowing machine... Or trains up a few thousand people in China to do it for one tenth your wages.
Not exactly motivating me to drop everything, move to Salem, and spend the next few years becoming a glassblower.
> Fellow chemists are relieved Caltech will keep a glass blower on campus. For them, it's more convenient than ordering from a catalog and preserves the intimacy researchers should have with the experiments they design.
Let me get right ahead on staking my livelyhood on a university's budget indulging the 'intimacy' between its chemistry lab and their resident glassblower. Who do you think will be canned when Caltech will need to scrounge up some cash to build a swanky new dorm? "Sorry, Doctor Weinberg, you're going to have to get your glass on Amazon, like everyone else."
- msla 8y agoThe piece is about these people doing very small-batch custom runs, precisely the kind of thing you don't go to China for, and it's hard to fully automate skilled trades.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- vkou 8y agoToday, you can already get small-batch custom runs of PCBs shipped straight from Shenzhen. Nobody keeps a local PCB lithographer on staff, when you can order a batch of 20 for $50. I'd be surprised if, in a decade, you couldn't do the same for glassware.
- HarryHirsch 8y agoWith custom-built mechanical equipment it absolutely doesn't work that way. Doubtless, someone in China will build you your piece from drawings, and six weeks later it arrives, and you find that it needs modifications to work as intended. Wash, repeat. The slow feedback loop is the biggest problem with outsoucing. It already doesn't work particularly well with custom synthesis.
- magduf 8y agoAlso, when you order PCBs from China, you're doing all the CAD work yourself, and they're building those parts exactly according to the engineering drawings (called "gerbers"). With glassware, the chemist isn't using AutoCAD to create detailed engineering drawings of what he wants. The glassblower is taking on much of the design role. I suppose you could just get the university to hire a mechanical engineer to do the CAD work, and send CAD drawings to China to manufacture the glassware according to spec, but that's not going to be cheap.
- j7ake 8y agoYou can make the same argument with software development. You can get people overseas to do it at cheaper price.
- vkou 8y agoIf software problems were as well-defined as lab glassware specs, that argument would hold some merit. Also, millions of engineer hours have been put into making the software equivalent of a glassblowing machine. No CS department employs an in-house 'Kernel writer' or 'TCP/IP Implementer'.
- jrochkind1 8y agoThe actual OP article suggests that lab glassware specs aren't as well-defined as you imply at all. > "You need a person who has some idea about the scientific process and how to translate what a student wants to do into a piece of apparatus that really works," said Bob Grubbs, a 2005 Nobel laureate in chemistry and professor at Caltech. "How do you get from a couple scratches on a piece of paper, to something you actually go use in a lab that you trust and is not going to blow acid in your face?" Doesn't mean those who hold the purse strings will pay for it. (Doesn't mean they'll pay for custom software either).