3 ms·
> Any formalization of the integers won't be "the" integers, the totality of which perhaps isn't even a reasonable idea. "The integers" is whatever formal mode
by naasking 8y ago
> Any formalization of the integers won't be "the" integers, the totality of which perhaps isn't even a reasonable idea.
"The integers" is whatever formal model we all agree has the properties we want of the integers. This is a language game, it's merely a label for a set of properties.
> Mathematics is a part of the world and does not stand apart from it.
If you mean that mathematics follows from naturalism, this is at best a conjecture. We could very well live in a mathematical universe (ala Platonism), in which case our world is itself a particular mathematical structure. This is actually a far less problematic view of mathematics, philosophically.
> There is no reason why such a "best" model should exist
There are many reasons why a "best" model of reality should exist. For one, as I mentioned above, mathematical monism is a less problematic philosophy of mathematics. It then immediately follows that positing a separate physical world is multiplying entities unnecessarily, ergo, considering the universe to be mathematical is the most parsimonious theory.
But even going a different route, as I said many posts up, denying an accurate and precise mathematical of reality entails some irreconcilable inconsistency in reality, which so far has completely failed to manifest itself. We very well could be a brief island of stability in a random output generator, but ordering my hypotheses by likelihood, this would necessarily be dead last (because its incompressible ala Solomonoff induction).