8 ms·
On the other side of the coin, targeted advertising is a way to get viewers of high-quality content to view your ads without paying a premiums to the people and
by hedora 8y ago
On the other side of the coin, targeted advertising is a way to get viewers of high-quality content to view your ads without paying a premiums to the people and institutions that produced the premium content.
This saves money for the advertisers, by transferring wealth away from content creators.
It boggles my mind that publishers still favor this model over display ads (targeted to articles, not readers).
- SN76477 8y agoDepth of targetting is the easy button for the modern marketer.
- ucaetano 8y ago> This saves money for the advertisers, by transferring wealth away from content creators. Not really. It actually increases the pool of money available to content creators. Everybody wins. > It boggles my mind that publishers still favor this model over display ads (targeted to articles, not readers). Because they generate more revenue, I'd guess. Mind-boggling, I know.
- kstrauser 8y ago> Everybody wins. Well, except for the people being targeted, and the ones being served malware, and the ones having their cross-Internet activities being tracked, logged, and analyzed. It's not such a win for them.
- ucaetano 8y ago> Well, except for the people being targeted They win too. They get content without having to hand over cash. Everybody wins because the value of what they are giving is, for them, less than they are receiving. And the value of what they are giving, for others, is more than what others are giving. Going back to non-targeted ads would significantly reduce monetization, reducing the pile of money available to content creators, and driving many (if not most) of them out of business. You can always not access any ad-funded content or service, the option is yours. Take it.
- repolfx 8y agoI wish more people understood this. We're in the middle of an unsubstantiated moral panic, like the old "video games will make kids into killers" panic that turned out to be totally false. MySpace used to have animated DoubleClick style untargeted ads. It sucked. Facebook crushed them partly because it's a much cleaner experience and Facebook ads are so much higher quality. The problem with all the people claiming this sort of move is great is it doesn't ring true, they sound almost in physical pain over "tracking" (a scary word for very primitive and broad-brush techniques, by and large). But where are the people who have actually suffered concrete, quantifiable harm? Some real, unarguable case where someone suffered because of ad targeting? If there were a real harm here, given the enormous scale of the internet, there should be millions of such stories but the only one I can think of was years ago, about a supermarket that discovered that women who buy X, Y and Z things together are very likely to be pregnant. They caused a minor family drama by sending a teenager adverts for baby stuff when her parents didn't know. Arguably this is a hole the teenager dug for themselves, but even so, it wasn't even internet based stuff from what I recall. And as far as harm goes, that's about it. I've never been harmed by ads. I've never met anyone else who has been either. But I remember a LOT of people complaining back in the bad old days about the barrel-scraping punch the monkey inventory that typified the web experience.
- u90g4u8904 8y agoHere's someone who was harmed: http://gawker.com/5671582/how-facebooks-targeted-ads-revealed-one-users-sexuality http://gawker.com/5671582/how-facebooks-targeted-ads-reveale...
- repolfx 8y agoInteresting research but no actual harm was done - the researcher experimented on a friend whom she already knew was gay, and Facebook made changes to close that glitch. Being able to do such things is certainly not an intentional part of their ad system. I only skimmed parts of the paper but I also question the premise. It seems the attack is entirely dependent on you being 100% sure your ad is so carefully targeted it'll only show to a single person. If there's any doubt at all that it might match even two people, the attack doesn't work. Seems rather hard to pull off in anything other than lab conditions.
- cuckcuckspruce 8y agoDidn't you get the silly valley memo? The sheep that use our products aren't people. They're wallets with intent, and it's our job to program that intent.
- ethbro 8y agoImho, targeted advertising is the black box / CDO of advertising revenue. Eyeball time is a commodity. Microtargeting by "smart people" is what enables you to sell $1 worth of eyeballs for $10. It's going to hurt. But in favor of Google and Facebook is that maybe they have enough last mile and market share that they can just charge the same thing for commodity advertising.