4 ms·
"This, I suspect, is one of those truths so horrible that you can't talk about it in public. This is something that reporters must not write about, when they v
by pitt1980 8y ago
"This, I suspect, is one of those truths so horrible that you can't talk about it in public. This is something that reporters must not write about, when they visit gatherings of the power elite.
Because the last news your readers want to hear, is that this person who is wealthier than you, is also smarter, happier, and not a bad person morally. Your reader would much rather read about how these folks are overworked to the bone or suffering from existential ennui. Failing that, your readers want to hear how the upper echelons got there by cheating, or at least smarming their way to the top. If you said anything as hideous as, "They seem more alive," you'd get lynched.
But I am an independent scholar, not much beholden. I should be able to say it out loud if anyone can. I'm talking about this topic... for more than one reason; but it is the truth as I see it, and an important truth which others don't talk about (in writing?). It is something that led me down wrong pathways when I was young and inexperienced.
I used to think—not from experience, but from the general memetic atmosphere I grew up in—that executives were just people who, by dint of superior charisma and butt-kissing, had managed to work their way to the top positions at the corporate hog trough.
No, that was just a more comfortable meme, at least when it comes to what people put down in writing and pass around. The story of the horrible boss gets passed around more than the story of the boss who is, not just competent, but more competent than you."
https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/CKpByWmsZ8WmpHtYa/competent-elites https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/CKpByWmsZ8WmpHtYa/competent-...
----
I'm not sure I buy this model of the world wholesale, but I think its important to at least have this model as a competing hypothesis as to how the world is organized
- cryoshon 8y agoi think it's important to leave the door open for the perspective you quoted here. there's no guarantee of even distribution of traits. on average, traits are somewhat evenly distributed, however. without both understandings it's easy to get the wrong idea about the world.
- sejtnjir 8y agoI do think traits are somewhat evenly distributed, but some traits are multiplicative towards a person's net competence in a certain role. I imagine the distribution is a fat-tailed one.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Terr_ 8y agoThe correlation could also be reversed. We certainly know that scarcity and deprivation encourage negative feelings and behaviors.
- ricardobeat 8y agoGreat writing there, though I can't really get past the repetition of 'sparkling with life force' as the most apt description for extraordinary people. Surely there's more to be observed?