3 ms·
My email client has full access to the contents of my email but the author of said client has none. Although my client has credentials these are stored locally
by michaelmrose 8y ago
My email client has full access to the contents of my email but the author of said client has none. Although my client has credentials these are stored locally and like my email never communicated to the creator of my client.
If the device makers applications merely fetched data on behalf of users and displayed it on their machine it would be no more of a problem than my email client.
In the first place it looks the apis provided access to data the users had opted not to share in the second place the times article seems to state that partners partook of that data themselves rather than merely acting as a client example
"Facebook acknowledged that some partners did store users’ data — including friends’ data — on their own servers. A Facebook official said that regardless of where the data was kept, it was governed by strict agreements between the companies."
Before deciding if facebook's response was reasonable did you even bother reading the times article?
- makomk 8y agoThe APIs provided access to data that had been shared with the person who was logged into the device, but not with random Facebook apps like Farmville. The New York Times' argument is essentially that the flag which stopped Cambridge Analytica and Zynga getting access to your data should also have stopped your actual friends from viewing it except through installing Facebook's official app. It's hard to see any way in which making users choose between sharing their info with every dodgy quiz their friends use and forcing their friends to install the Facebook app and let it get its tendrils into their devices in order to interact with them would've been good for privacy, but this is exactly what the NYT is insisting Facebook should've done.
- mic47 8y ago> "Facebook acknowledged that some partners did store users’ data — including friends’ data — on their own servers." This statement from the article is meaningless, as many legit things might mean "third party storing data" as: 1.) Storing and editing contact imports, if user wants. This is technically friends data, but it's my contact list. 2.) Proxy-ing and caching: we are talking about shitty phones mostly before android and ios were mainstream, so "store on their servers" could be as simple as an artefact of implementation of non-html facebook client app on that shitty phone. Example of such artefacts: custom notifications channels, caching, downscaling of images. I think that blackberry did proxy all of their communications through their servers (not 100% sure), so if Facebook was available, they probably also had to store something on their servers. The journalist didn't even attempted to distinguish between "my device is calling this api" and "company is doing requests" and resort to conflating those two and ambiguous "some partners did store users". This is example of journalist trying to create a story instead of getting to truth. If they would dig deeper, and try to figure out which companies stored data, what type of data (was it contact import, caching, or did they download full graph?), and what was purpose, it would be valuable article.