4 ms·
What’s the text version of a birthday cake? More challenging: what’s the text version of a singing, eye-rolling T-Rex? It’s fine to not care about emoji, but
by macintux 8y ago
What’s the text version of a birthday cake?
More challenging: what’s the text version of a singing, eye-rolling T-Rex?
It’s fine to not care about emoji, but you can’t logically dismiss them as prettier smilies.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y ago> What’s the text version of a birthday cake? "Happy birthday!" > More challenging: what’s the text version of a singing, eye-rolling T-Rex? Ok, you got me there, because I have no idea what concept is even meant to be communicated by such an absurd thing.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> I have no idea what concept is even meant to be communicated by such an absurd thing Depends on context. If we were discussing someone, it might signal criticism or a desire to party. The fact that it cannot compress losslessly into words is the whole point.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoIf it is contextual and subjective, then we could just use any word or phrase in the same manner to the same effect. Written language itself is just contextual line patterns.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> we could just use any word or phrase in the same manner to the same effect. Written language itself is just contextual line patterns No, we can't. There is an inherent visual component to emojis. A picture worth a thousand words, et cetera. It's not an abstract idea mapping to an arbitrary icon; without prior explanation, many emojis make sense (within a certain cultural context). Kind of like how we can't replace the essence of giving a friend a gift or a lover a flower with words or an arbitrary icon. Apple understands this in a way few technology companies do.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y ago> It's not an abstract idea mapping to an arbitrary icon; without prior explanation, many emojis make sense (within a certain cultural context). What a coincidence, the exact same thing is true about written words. >Kind of like how we can't replace the essence of giving a friend a gift or a lover a flower with words or an arbitrary icon. Apple understands this in a way few technology companies do. I feel like you're one of those people who would have been way into flaming guitar gifs and midi on your geocities page in the 90s. I mean, seriously? You're literally saying that sending a gif conveys so much more meaning meaning it is similar to giving a gift or a flower than sending a text. Maybe you're right: https://tinyurl.com/y7xeu7dc https://tinyurl.com/y7xeu7dc
- Fnoord 8y agoHow many languages do you speak well? Very likely less than the amount of different native language speakers who understand the vast majority of your emoticons/emojis. I suppose you don't care cause you just speak your native language with other people who are native speakers. But a universal language on top of that has huge benefits in international circles. And, my 3 month old understands the :) smile. One of the very first abilities a newborn learns is recognizing faces. That's when they cannot even see a meter far!
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoSo let me get this straight: emoji is both highly contextual and simultaneously universal? I find that difficult to believe. On the other hand, given enough time and global interaction in that medium, it could develop a stable enough meaning across a large enough conceptual space to have a situation no worse than exists between any "standard" language and its various dialects. That'd be interesting, but I'm not holding my breath.
- Fnoord 8y ago> So let me get this straight: emoji is both highly contextual and simultaneously universal? Well, not always universal. Some are generally well understood. They're easy to learn (you might wanna also look into where to start if you're interested in learning many languages; I understood its best to start with an Asian language such as Japanese/Korean/Chinese), and on top of that even allow to learn languages easily (see Memrise and Duolingo who use SVG art to teach languages. They use the same SVG art in different languages!). Even on school when children learn their first words (which are in Dutch: boom/roos/vis/vuur, English meaning: tree/rose/fish/fire) this is done via pictures! Emoticons and emoji are contextual, yes. If I say: That's fun ;) :) That has a different meaning than: That is fun :) or That is fun ;) Different context, yet a wink or smile is universal. And if I'd write: Dat is leuk :) You wouldn't understand it because you don't speak Dutch. But you would understand the smiley. Without using any translator. The emoticon & emoji always describes the text around it, like an adjective (though it could also describe other smileys). As such, it is descriptive. True, sometimes the emoticons (and especially emoji) explanation must be explained. Once it is explained, it can be used in combination with any language. For example, the kappa emoji [1] which originates from Twitch can be used on an English stream, but also on a Spanish or Japanese one. Its generally understood within the gamer community, but if you'd start using it within your local hockey club they'd first need to understand the meaning. [1] https://www.twitchemotes.com/emotes/25 https://www.twitchemotes.com/emotes/25
- EpicEng 8y ago> it might signal criticism or a desire to party I'd like to see examples of both of these. Specifically how the T-Rex plays a role because, if you take the T-Rex out, we're back to something I can easily convey in ascii.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> if you take the T-Rex out, we're back to something I can easily convey in ascii May I ask if you read fiction in more than one language? There are constructions even in those close to English which I find impossible to accurately translate in a way that preserves the delight of the interaction between their phrasing and underlying meaning. For T-Rex, two examples: "I drank too much at the Christmas party. Not as much as Bob. He puked in the restaurant sink before appetizers were served. [Dancing eye-rolling T-Rex]" --or-- "Let's go. Where? BarBar. BarBar? Happy hour pricing until midnight. [Dancing eyes-rolled-back T-Rex]" In the former, the emoji communicates derision. In the latter, playfulness. Depending on the style of animation and context, the emoji could further communicate cuteness versus tactile incompetence, letting go versus a loss of control, subject versus object. The process of decoding an emoji is analogous to a simplified form of interpreting art. Why is that there? Am I supposed to interpret it using the positive or negative connotation? In some cases, less ambiguity is desired. But in others, the ambiguity itself carries information of a sort impossible to parse into words.
- EpicEng 8y ago>"I drank too much at the Christmas party. >Not as much as Bob. He puked in the restaurant sink before appetizers were served. >[Dancing eye-rolling T-Rex]" Ummmm... Points for trying I guess? You lost me at "person who drank too much == T-Rex"
- macintux 8y agoLet me put it another way: what’s the point of these newfangled moving pictures when we already have books?
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoThat's a better argument, but it still doesn't really explain what qualities make emoji a better medium of expression, or why we need 2000 of them.
- macintux 8y agoThe fact that they’re wildly popular should provide some indication that the qualities exist. Communication is rife with ambiguities, emotion, shortcuts, and mistakes. And between people who share friendship or more personal relationships, those “flaws” are often features, not bugs. The concept of emoji, I feel, embraces those flaws. (And personally speaking on the subject of emoji vs common text shorthand, if I never see “lol” again it’ll be too soon.)
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoMany popular things are not quality things. > (And personally speaking on the subject of emoji vs common text shorthand, if I never see “lol” again it’ll be too soon.) Funny, I feel the same way about emoji. I dunno, maybe I'm too autistic to get it, but when people use emoji it makes me feel like I'm talking to a child who hasn't learned express themselves like an adult yet.
- EpicEng 8y ago> The fact that they’re wildly popular should provide some indication that the qualities exist. Really? Pet rocks were wildly popular. Unhealthy foods are wildly popular. Cocaine is wildly popular (well maybe that's a stretch). I think there's a correlation problem here. However, I think you're missing the point again; _what can I convey via an emoji that I cannot convey in ascii_? I have yet to see a single example, and that's what started the entire debate.
- EpicEng 8y ago> What’s the text version of a birthday cake? Is that a serious question? > More challenging: what’s the text version of a singing, eye-rolling T-Rex? Who cares because that's dumb? Can you tell me what deep emotional state is being conveyed by a T-rex rolling its eyes? I think you lost track of the premise we're debating.