3 ms·
If Samsung secretly runs a keylogger on all their phones and then steals your data that way, that's a Samsung problem and you should be angry. That is not what
by vorpalhex 8y ago
If Samsung secretly runs a keylogger on all their phones and then steals your data that way, that's a Samsung problem and you should be angry. That is not what happened here.
Facebook officially blessed other platforms, allowed them to say you were signing into Facebook, and then allowed those platforms to have access not only to your data, but your friends exhaustive data. Facebook was aware of this, explicitly allowed this, and their only safeguard was vaguely worded policies with their partners.
Even if the partners haven't stolen any data or broken their policies, Facebook intentionally and knowingly gave my data to a third party without my consent. Presumably now all 66 of these device partners have my full data, and I did not sign in on their device or otherwise authorize it.
- prepend 8y ago“and then allowed those platforms to have access not only to your data, but your friends exhaustive data.” Only for purposes of allowing the user to interact with Facebook. The platforms themselves couldn’t use the data for anything other than supporting user actions. This is perfectly reasonable and is why APIs exist. The issue, which has not been repeated, would be if those platforms retained data without user consent and used the data for other purposes. That would violate the contract they signed with Facebook and be bad for use privacy. To a non technology person, these two very different things sound similar (Facebook let Microsoft access use data). But this is meaningless without more context.
- esrauch 8y agoFacebook officially sends arbitrary friends data through the Android/Samung APIs in the normal course of operating the official FB app. It likely also locally caches a lot of data in a format and on-device storage that Samsung could arbitrarily access. The only thing stopping Samsung from stealing all of your friends data is legal and social, not technical. Is there any evidence that the API was actually used to arbitrarily request and exfiltrate other users profiles? If not, this is strictly only "Facebook allowed other developers to write Facebook apps": there is no way that could possible work without offering an API with this level off access to the app.