6 ms·
idk, this seems fair. It goes both ways though; if I ask a gay baker to make clitoris cakes I don't think he should have to do that either, we all have the rig
by dijit 8y ago
idk, this seems fair.
It goes both ways though; if I ask a gay baker to make clitoris cakes I don't think he should have to do that either, we all have the right to refuse to work on things we oppose; surely.
There is such a thing as decency, I wouldn't expect my local baker to make sexually suggestive cookies for me, she would not be comfortable making them and it would be arrogant of me to force her.
EDIT: for those likening the service to race, it's not quite the same, unless you were talking about a white person being unable to buy a racist cake from a black baker. Which I'm sure we all agree is a fair thing to refuse service for. We have control of what we put into the world. Tolerance means being tolerant, it does not extend so far as to deny my right to refuse to create something I do not support (matter of what you should support or not is not the topic here), otherwise anyone can ask anyone to make racist/sexist shit and they have no recourse.
- samueldavid 8y agoagree
- codezero 8y agoThey were buying a wedding cake, and were denied before any design was discussed.
- dijit 8y agoThat's not what the case details say; I am rereading now in case I misread. From what I read they only found out that it was a gay couple _at_ the design phase because it was a same sex supporting cake, which went against the morality (however wrong) the bakers held.
- paulmd 8y ago>The Colorado Court of Appeals ruled that Mr. Phillips’s free speech rights had not been violated, noting that the couple had not discussed the cake’s design before Mr. Phillips turned them down. That's indeed exactly what the article says. >They were buying a wedding cake, and were denied before any design was discussed.
- djcapelis 8y agoThat analogy isn't really what's happened in this case, no one is saying a baker would be forced to make a specific type of cake they otherwise wouldn't offer. The better analogy to your situation is a baker (gay or otherwise) who refused to bake cakes for women. Which, by the way, under current law would in fact be illegal.
- gempir 8y agoThen you could go all the way: Employers: I won't hire you because your black Doctors: I won't treat you because you're gay. It can't work that way or we have a lot of discrimination.
- lancepioch 8y agoRace is constitutionally protected, sexuality is not.
- craftyguy 8y agoNo, you've got it wrong. They make cakes, the couple asked them to make one, and were refused service based on their sexual preference. The baker would presumably make that exact same cake design for another same-sex couple. Design of the cake had nothing to do with it.
- fzeroracer 8y agoYou are massively misrepresenting the case. There is a world of difference between someone refusing to design or bake a cake on the basis of the contents requested and someone refusing to do the same on the basis of the person(s) requesting the cake. The baker refused to bake a cake because the couple was gay, not because of what was on it.
- dijit 8y ago>refused to make a cake in support of gay marriage Sounds awfully like the content of the cake was what the bakers in question objected to, now necessarily the people requesting it.
- fzeroracer 8y agoSo let's say then it was a black couple instead of a gay couple. Would it be OK for the baker to refuse service because he's against black people getting married?
- wang_li 8y agoWould it be OK for a gay baker to refuse to make a cake with the inscription "Celebrating the third anniversary of the Pulse Night Club shooting" if the cake was being requested by someone whose religious teachings preach that homosexuality is a sin and those who engage in the practice should be killed? Or how about for a gay coffee shop owner to kick Christians out of his shop because he disagrees with their belief system. See Bedlam Coffee in Seattle.
- fzeroracer 8y agoYou're making an incredibly false analogy in the first scenario and misreading the case in the second. In the first case there is no discrimination on the basis of religion, skin color or sex. In the second you are being disengenous because it was clear that they were not in fact kicked out because they were christian, but kicked out because of both what they were actively doing near and in his coffee shop. If they were kicked out solely on the basis of being Christian then yes, that would be a clear problem.