3 ms·
It is important to understand that a negotiation is not the same as a trade. You don't always have to give something tangible to get something back. Very often,
by YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago
It is important to understand that a negotiation is not the same as a trade. You don't always have to give something tangible to get something back. Very often, negotiations proceed on points of emotion, or morality, alone. An appeal to justice, mercy, friendship etc, is often just as effective as a promise of a big material reward.
For example, the EU did not want to be seen as ruthlessly crushing the Greeks for no reason at all and would have probably taken any reasonable demand seriously. Unfortunately, Varoufakis' grandstanding gave them a jolly good reason to antagonise us without guilt, or at the very least removed any possibility that any demands of ours could be presented to the other member states' electorates as reasoned, or just.
In any case, one does not go to the negotiating table after having systematically disparaged the other side as villains, like Syriza did, and expect a positive result. See where Brexit negotiations are now, after years of British politicians blaming the EU for everything.
Like I say above, there was (and is) goodwill in the EU about Greece. Many people have expressed their dismay at the treatment of the country by the Troika. What's more important, as others have said, the IMF was very strongly for debt relief. And like you say yourself, we had already suffered under austerity for a few years and it was clear it was not doing anything for growth or our prospects to repay our debt. There was a case to be made in our favour.
For sure, there was not a whole lot to go on. But that's why I say "a skilled negotiator" was needed. Tsipras and Varoufakis were nothing of the sort.
- crdoconnor 8y ago>It is important to understand that a negotiation is not the same as a trade. You don't always have to give something tangible to get something back. Very often, negotiations proceed on points of emotion, or morality, alone. An appeal to justice, mercy, friendship etc, is often just as effective. No. It was not effective in the past and it would not be effective in the future. In fact the last 7 years of Greece's relationship to the Troika served as ample example of just how ineffective it was. >In any case, one does not go to the negotiating table after having systematically disparaged the other side as villains Well, when 7 years of treating them as friends achieves nothing... why not try something new, right? PASOK got annihilated in the polls for a reason and that reason is that they tried it your way and failed.