4 ms·
Let’s take one vertical that people clearly need: food. Sure there’s non perishable food. But a lot of the food people eat is perishable. They have to keep buy
by EGreg 8y ago
Let’s take one vertical that people clearly need: food.
Sure there’s non perishable food. But a lot of the food people eat is perishable. They have to keep buying it.
Who is going to source the food if no one pays money to buy it? How will they pay for the operations to get the food?
Now apply this reasoning to other verticals. In many fields, the investments lead to actual improvements in technology, and increasing automation and productivity.
If everyone sits at home that only works if nothing ever breaks and no one needs improvements and technology. We’d still be using gas lamps if no one built electric stations etc.
About debt you can watch this: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=PHe0bXAIuk0 https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=PHe0bXAIuk0
- roma1n 8y agoYes except that it is not black and white, working or not working. There could be a real case made for working less and directing efforts towards technology improvements that result in less environmental damage. To me, it does not make any sense to think in absolutes.
- ACow_Adonis 8y agoExcept, I'm sure grace DID spend money on food. Additionally, grace's savings, not spending money on things she did not need, increases net savings and decreases the cost of debt for those wishing to access her capital to invest in things they desire. If grace went further still and didn't just passively SAVE her money, but actively invested it in things that made a positive contribution or spent that money only on things which made her desired world happen while discriminating against goods and businesses that made the world worse, either to fulfill her own desires for a better world or investing in such for others, she'd actively be choosing to use that money to build up capital in areas of the economy and reward sectors that supplied those things, lowering the cost of supply, and potentially creating employment in those sectors. Either way, there are generally better things to do than consuming for the sake of consuming. And its primarily not about spending or not spending, but choosing where to spend and choosing where to invest, for an economy that keeps everyone employed but produces nothing of value (or actively produces harmful things) is not an economy anyone should be aiming for. If we are so far down the path that we are advocating spending and consumption merely for the sake of spending and consumption to keep the economy turning over, then surely it would be better by far to advocate conscious directed spending and investment, rather than consumption.