3 ms·
Biology is absurdly sophisticated. Cancer just seems to reveal more edge cases that are 'supported' by the system but not typically expressed. I just learned
by jcims 8y ago
Biology is absurdly sophisticated. Cancer just seems to reveal more edge cases that are 'supported' by the system but not typically expressed. I just learned about exosomes not too long ago. This seems to be an even more advanced intercellular messaging system.
It's also another example of why I'm in the panspermia camp. I don't think all this crazy shit could evolve in the amount of time that Earth has been hospitable to life. It just feels too complex.
- agumonkey 8y agoI understand but this disease is almost a best of of every hack there can be in our cells.
- drunkenmonkey 8y agoMaybe cancer is a waste product that is only solved by... well, I can’t put it into words. If I could, I would call it “attrachion”, and reference the anime Tower of God.
- trevyn 8y ago>I don't think all this crazy shit could evolve in the amount of time that Earth has been hospitable to life. It just feels too complex. You may wish to compute an estimate of the parallelism available over said amount of time and compare it to the rate of individual contemporary examples of simple evolutionary steps instead of relying on a “feel”ing. :-)
- jcims 8y agoI have. It’s so absurdly lopsided against pure chance that it’s obvious I’m missing something (or more likely, many things) Here’s a summary: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17125348 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17125348
- nonbel 8y ago>"8.7*10^349236 possible configurations" Are you thinking there is only ~1/8.7e349236 viable solutions? There is no reason to expect you need to exhaust even a tiny fraction of the space to get something reasonable.
- jcims 8y agoOf course not, but if single ionization events can kill a cell’s ability to reproduce (or worse), there must be some constraints. So where do the numbers land? I’m obviously missing wide swaths of useful information and understanding. But I’ve looked at this for a little bit and haven’t had the epiphany I need for this to click.
- nonbel 8y agoJust try a problem like this: https://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/302891/hyper-parameters-tuning-random-search-vs-bayesian-optimization https://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/302891/hyper-param... The space of possible configurations can be simply huge, but still you can usually find a reasonable (not optimal) one after only a dozen or hundred attempts. >"single ionization events can kill a cell’s ability to reproduce (or worse)" Maybe I don't know what you mean by single ionization event, if it is mutating a single basepair then I doubt it.
- jcims 8y agoRe: ionization i meant a single 'bit flip'. I've since found this article, the effect seems to depend heavily on where it happens: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Point_mutation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Point_mutation I think your other point is probably related to sparsity of viable vs. non-viable configurations and the steps needed to get between them. Of course that's complicated by the contextual interdependecies (are you in a mammal's womb or a submerged egg sac) but to your point you don't need to climb mount everest in a single step. Just get from one solution to another and the viable ones will tend to outweigh the less viable. Appreciate the help reframing it a bit. I'm still thinking it's too complex but at least there's light at the end of the tunnel. :P
- resource0x 8y agoThe alternative is to think of each cell as an individual conscious intelligent being which knows what it is doing. It knows how to modify its own DNA, and does it creatively, similar to a programmer, just a very smart one. Our sense of "I" that encompasses all cells in the body is an illusion - this "I" is really the consciousness of a single specialized (and appropriately zombified) cell. Every organism is a symbiosis of conscious beings. This doesn't explain where the "very first cell" comes from, but I find the theory fascinating anyway. Unfortunately those who share this view are not very vocal about it (who wants to be called a crackpot? :)
- jcims 8y agoYeah that's not far from the other idea I'm entertaining, lol. Not necessarily that each cell is conscious or intelligent, but that there are creative mechanisms at play that we don't perceive. Ones that guide or 'program' evolution of DNA constructively rather than randomly. To your point, the idea of a monolithic 'I' that represents the ~50 trillion cells in my body is kind of ridiculous, particularly when roughly half of them don't even share my DNA. In that same vein, it has always weirded me out that we don't intuitively know how our bodies work...to the point that I even began thinking of the human consciousness as kind of virus that infected the germ line of primates with this extra meat in the noggin that intercepts the senses and controls the body. Anyway I just need to learn more about all of this stuff before I put any real stock into my harebrained ideas.
- resource0x 8y agoI think every cell (and every bacteria) has this capacity, but higher intelligence can be disabled by some molecular switch (other senses cannot be disabled, they are the property of life) . The one that carries the illusion of human "I" is not particularly "advanced", but again, it's just a matter of some extra axon or something :). I'm pretty sure humans were designed by bacteria (or their descendants), but our species plays very modest role in the overall scheme of things. We are certainly not the ones calling the shots :) You can start here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gBGt5OeAQFk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gBGt5OeAQFk
- daughart 8y agoMaybe something you're missing is the concept of "evolvability". You can see the book "Resolving Darwin's Dilemma" (review here: https://academic.oup.com/bioscience/article/56/9/772/263015 https://academic.oup.com/bioscience/article/56/9/772/263015). An important concept in the evolution of novelty (creating new, advanced functions out of "random" mutations) is that all the living systems we observe today are highly evolvable. Evolvability is an emergent property of some evolving systems, and it enables surprising leaps in functionality.
- jcims 8y agoWill check it out, thank you!