I was NOT prepared to see someone reference Ethics as a rebuttal because that's precisely what I was preparing to do. You have to wade through quite a bit of se

I was NOT prepared to see someone reference Ethics as a rebuttal because that's precisely what I was preparing to do. You have to wade through quite a bit of setup, especially as Aristotle ponders questions of the origins of virtue in book two in order to appreciate the quote from GP. Contextomy and Aristolean philosophy are like oil and water.