5 ms·
I got a different reading of the whole situation in 2015 from the book by Mr. Varoufakis himself, "Adults in the Room". TL;DR: the EU was never going to budge.
by netsharc 8y ago
I got a different reading of the whole situation in 2015 from the book by Mr. Varoufakis himself, "Adults in the Room". TL;DR: the EU was never going to budge. They knew what he wanted was right, but they couldn't give Greece any political wins. And the Eurocrats were expert in shaping the story in the media, that you (yes you) got the impression the Greeks were stupid clowns.
Look at Brexit, I now get the impression the Brits are clowns, but if someone wrote an inside story book, it's probably deliberate run-around and media manipulation. Not that I'm saying the Brits aren't clowns...
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> they couldn't give Greece any political wins Varoufakis would write that. He failed to negotiate anything for Greece. My reading of the situation was European politicians wanted to help Greece, but had to accommodate their own citizens. Varoufakis’ hardball strategy assumed Europe would (a) see his threats as credible and (b) feel more pain from Grexit than capitulaing on all points. He was wrong on both counts, most significantly (b). His strategy thus failed before he took his first breath. He should have taken a conciliatory approach. Let French and German politicians sell good-natured Greeks in need of help, not a people mindlessly throwing a tantrum. The former would have allowed for ridiculously extending maturities (such that inflation pays for much of it) and delaying interest payments for a few years, along with lenience on budget deficits.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago>> He should have taken a conciliatory approach. Let French and German politicians sell good-natured Greeks in need of help, not a people mindlessly throwing a tantrum. Yes, absolutely that. There always was -and still there is- a lot of goodwill towards the Greeks in Europe, for historical reasons, some nostalgia, some guilt, some genuine Philhellenism; this was the primary reason we were allowed to join in the first place, much more so than Simitis' bare-faced fraud. And so even at the height of the crisis, the EU did not push for a Grexit, even though that was the constant adage in the media- Greece must now exit the Euro, Greece is about to exit the Euro, it's going to happen in two weeks now, they're exiting tomorrow etc etc. Merkel and Sarkozy and most everyone else kept saying "we don't want the Greeks to leave, but, of course, if they insist... ". I'd contrast this with the Europeans' reaction to the Brexit: most member states have reacted with something very close to relief; there is a general sense of "good riddance" to the problem child of Europe. With Greeks, instead, I got the feeling they just didn't want us to hurt ourselves any further.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago>> much more so than Simitis' bare-faced fraud. Ah, oops, sorry- Simitis cooking the books was when we joined the Eurozone. My bad.
- crdoconnor 8y ago>Varoufakis would write that. He failed to negotiate anything for Greece. My reading of the situation was European politicians wanted to help Greece They absolutely did not. They were not planning on granting any kind of debt relief or letting Greece escape from the Eurozone and they still don't. >He should have taken a conciliatory approach. That's called Pasok. It's what Pasok did. If the voters wanted Pasok again they would have elected Pasok again. Pasok was defeated in a landslide because the approach you just advocated was an unmitigated failure. Syriza won because Syriza promised not to be Pasok. Syriza's approach didn't work either of course, because realistically nothing is going to help them short of the dissolution of the Eurozone or something equally unlikely like a communist takeover of the European Commission. Pretending that conciliation was going to get them anywhere given that 7 years of it had done nothing of the sort is disingenuous in the extreme.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago>> That's called Pasok. It's what Pasok did. If the voters wanted Pasok again they would have elected Pasok again. Pasok was defeated in a landslide because the approach you just advocated was an unmitigated failure. Syriza won because Syriza promised not to be Pasok. Actually, it's obvious that a large part of Syriza's majority in the 2015 elections came from former PASOK voters, still in complete denial about the realities of the financial crisis, latching on to Tsipras as the champion of the status quo, with his promises of debt relief and protection of pensions and public sector jobs; promises that were, of course, empty. In a sense, voters very much did elect PASOK again. As to PASOK's conciliatory approach- both the two "big parties" (PASOK before the fall and New Democracy) are middle-of-the-road moderates with the political courage of a wet noodle. Giorgaki's Papandreou PASOK and Antonis Samaras' ND both simply bent over and accepted the Troica's memorandum without so much as a squeak. Syriza simply made a lot more noise- but then followed the same route and all the thrashing and flailing only helped to make the situation worse. You say Syriza had no chance. Sure- because they are incompetent. A skilled negotiator would have at the very least stood a chance to minimise the damage. The Europeans were at the table- they weren't there to fool around. They crushed us because we were fooling around. In 2015, Greece was already deep in the shit, then Syriza came along and they managed to fuck up the fuckup even worse.
- petre 8y agoDavid Cameron also tried to negotiate with the EU and failed. The, after barely winning the elections, he called for brexit referendum, thinking UK voters would vote to stay with the votes being split at around 50/50. He would then have used this result for a new round of negotiations. But things worked out quite a bit differently. How is this any different than what Varoufakis tried to pull off?
- jimnotgym 8y ago> media manipulation This is intruiging to me. From where I am sitting in the beautiful English sunshine, the media seems very bullish and pro-brexit! The Daily Mail, Express and Telegrapgh are openly pro-brexit, branding those trying to stop it as 'traitors'. The Murdoch press (Times and Sun) is less overt, but Murdoch is well known to be pro-brexit. This leaves The Guardian, which is well read on the internet because it is free but less so on paper. Also the Mirror is apparently more balanced, but lightweight. The BBC seem very sheepish after open threats from Ian Duncan Smith. I think the domestic press have been very, very easy on the government and the official opposition who are not opposing Brexit. I wonder if the international press are behaving differently? Disclosure: I do believe the Brexit team are clowns. I believe that most people in Britain had no interest in the EU either way until the popular press handed them an opinion. Remember the Google.co.uk trending searches for the day after the referendum included 'what is the EU'
- mhneu 8y agoThis is exactly my read of the UK press. Without the BBC playing a strong independent role (after the tory campaign to affect it), there is very little independent press able to drive a fair discussion. The Guardian has only a small impact on the overall public debate. (ps does the Economist have much influence in your view?)
- jimnotgym 8y agoRe: Economist. Certainly a fine read, and very popular amongst us finance folks. It's national impact is lost in the roundings compared to the Daily Mail with their 'crush the saboteurs' theme IMHO.
- mhneu 8y agoExploitation of media (and thus public opinion) by the wealthy is going to be the major issue we in the West have to deal with in the next decade, I believe. (for-profit news, and social media, and the Piketty wealthy-desire-to-influence politics have led us to a unique and dangerous place in 2018.)
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago>> I got a different reading of the whole situation in 2015 from the book by Mr. Varoufakis himself, "Adults in the Room". Well, he would say (all) that, wouldn't he?