3 ms·
There are similar issues in every large currency area with different economies. However, US and Australia are countries where people are mostly fine with the id
by alkonaut 8y ago
There are similar issues in every large currency area with different economies. However, US and Australia are countries where people are mostly fine with the idea that having a single currency and interest rate also means big transfers have to take place within the country. This isn’t the case in the EU. Although Greece (And others) receive EU support, there just isn’t popular support for the kind of transfers required to keep a single (German) interest rate. Taxing people in one country to transfer to another isn’t possible on that scale in the EU.
What needs to happen for the Euro to survive is that Germans have to accept a pretty substantial and long term inflation in order to keep growth elsewhere. But they had some bad luck with inflation in the past when it led to “economic anxiety” so it’s a bit of a red flag for them...
The other solution is to kill (or split) the Euro to save the EU. It seems more and more sensible.
- DogPawHat 8y agoI always read German attitudes to the Eurozone with some disbelief. They always seem to insist the burden of changing policy to make the Euro work fall on other countries and not there own.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ajmurmann 8y agoI think that's in large part because Germany had the Agenda 2010 which heavily cut welfare and hit many people super hard. The common narrative is that it's because of those sacrifices the German economy is in a better position than most other European countries. On top of that in the very least the perception is that the lower classes didn't benefit from that at all. So I understand that there is a lot of "I did my part and sucked it up while others didn't and now I am supposed to suffer again to help people who failed to do the right thing in the first place." Not saying that that's the correct attitude, just offering a explanation.
- 21 8y agoI'm not an expert on this, but my understanding is that there are big transfers taking place from Germany to the rest. They can be seen in Target 2 balances. Technically they are supposed to be more like loans, but in practice economists accept that they will not be paid back (as Greece proved): https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/da/TARGET2_balances.png https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/da/TARGET2_...