2 ms·
Krugman, who's also talked about how the Euro is a mistake, has talked about this. The difference between the EU and the US is, pensions and social security are
by netsharc 8y ago
Krugman, who's also talked about how the Euro is a mistake, has talked about this. The difference between the EU and the US is, pensions and social security are federally managed, so even if Appalachia is bankrupt, the pensioners still get their pensions, and state legislative bodies would not have to agree to bail out other states. Meanwhile in the EU, German politicians were fighting each other asking why they should bail out Greece yet again.
I would imagine if the US had a similar union like the EU, the blue states would've long told the red states to go to hell. Although interestingly states with money would have the influence (like Germany in the EU) and would've probably pushed the smaller states around and gotten more liberal politics.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> The difference between the EU and the US is, pensions and social security are federally managed No, they aren't, as two separate things. “Social Security” per se is federally managed, most pensions (except for federal and railroad employees) are not, neither are the bulk of social safety net programs (other than Social Security and Medicare, most of the rest are either fully state run or state adninistered within federal guidelines with partial federal reimbursement.) > if Appalachia is bankrupt, the pensioners still get their pensions “Appalachia” isn't an entity that can be bankrupt. But, no, in the case of a municipal bankruptcy, pensioners of that municipality lose out just like any other creditors (for states or territories, there are no general bankruptcy provisions and those would be handled ad hoc by Congress—as in Puerto Rico—but, again, pensioners would be at risk.)
- mhneu 8y agoGet ready for a huge upheaval, however. Urban areas in the US have typically been ok subsidizing rural areas (via healthcare and the social safety net more generally.) But since US Republicans, with their recent tax cut bill, have directly targeted urban areas with higher taxes, I'm detecting a rising current of dislike for the urban-to-rural subsidy. We could easily end up, in the US, with the urban areas fed up with the rural areas, and once we move back to a Democratic government, the urban areas trying to punish the rural areas. That would be really, really, really bad for the US. Really bad. (It could end up with a Greece-Germany situation happening with say Oklahoma and Kansas vs. New York and California, with crushing economic effects in red states while the blue states continue to prosper. I don't want to be alarmist but that could possibly even lead to a fracturing of the US or its currency. So yes. Really bad.)