6 ms·
>> The reality, as the author describes, is that Syriza’s call for debt relief should have been granted. But that is 100% the failure of Syriza, not the Europe
by YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago
>> The reality, as the author describes, is that Syriza’s call for debt relief
should have been granted.
But that is 100% the failure of Syriza, not the Europeans. Syriza took this
perfectly sensible, perfectly legitimate demand and turned it into a circus
act, backed by a farcical Referendum [1] and fronted by the clownish antics of
Yanis Varoufakis.
A unique opportunity to reason with our European partners was squandered, just
so that Varoufakis could burnish his personna of the maverick economics
professor. And because Tsipras, who was in way over his head, an inexperienced
young prime minister trying to negotiate with the heavy-weights of European
politics, did not have the courage or the honesty to accept reality for what
it was: that no, we didn't hold all the aces, no, the EU would not shed a tear
if we jumped off the Grexit cliff no matter how loudly Varoufakis proclaimed
it to be the divine truth; that, no, you cannot play chicken with frau Merkel,
you silly little boy.
And that the Europeans were not even out to get us. They needed something they
could present to their own citizens as a viable option. We gave them an
Aristophanean comedy instead, a shadow play of Karagiozis with all the bells
and whistles. And we paid the price, for the populism of our leaders, their
lack of seriousness and their incompetence.
And we still do.
_________
[1] The referendum question regarded an offer by the EU that had already been
withdrawn before the referendum was called. The text of the question itself
was so vague and complex that on the one hand it immediately became a running
joke with various memes, and on the other, allowed all sides in the debate to
claim victory and only served to muddle the waters even further on what "The
Will of the People" really was.
- netsharc 8y agoI got a different reading of the whole situation in 2015 from the book by Mr. Varoufakis himself, "Adults in the Room". TL;DR: the EU was never going to budge. They knew what he wanted was right, but they couldn't give Greece any political wins. And the Eurocrats were expert in shaping the story in the media, that you (yes you) got the impression the Greeks were stupid clowns. Look at Brexit, I now get the impression the Brits are clowns, but if someone wrote an inside story book, it's probably deliberate run-around and media manipulation. Not that I'm saying the Brits aren't clowns...
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> they couldn't give Greece any political wins Varoufakis would write that. He failed to negotiate anything for Greece. My reading of the situation was European politicians wanted to help Greece, but had to accommodate their own citizens. Varoufakis’ hardball strategy assumed Europe would (a) see his threats as credible and (b) feel more pain from Grexit than capitulaing on all points. He was wrong on both counts, most significantly (b). His strategy thus failed before he took his first breath. He should have taken a conciliatory approach. Let French and German politicians sell good-natured Greeks in need of help, not a people mindlessly throwing a tantrum. The former would have allowed for ridiculously extending maturities (such that inflation pays for much of it) and delaying interest payments for a few years, along with lenience on budget deficits.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago>> He should have taken a conciliatory approach. Let French and German politicians sell good-natured Greeks in need of help, not a people mindlessly throwing a tantrum. Yes, absolutely that. There always was -and still there is- a lot of goodwill towards the Greeks in Europe, for historical reasons, some nostalgia, some guilt, some genuine Philhellenism; this was the primary reason we were allowed to join in the first place, much more so than Simitis' bare-faced fraud. And so even at the height of the crisis, the EU did not push for a Grexit, even though that was the constant adage in the media- Greece must now exit the Euro, Greece is about to exit the Euro, it's going to happen in two weeks now, they're exiting tomorrow etc etc. Merkel and Sarkozy and most everyone else kept saying "we don't want the Greeks to leave, but, of course, if they insist... ". I'd contrast this with the Europeans' reaction to the Brexit: most member states have reacted with something very close to relief; there is a general sense of "good riddance" to the problem child of Europe. With Greeks, instead, I got the feeling they just didn't want us to hurt ourselves any further.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago>> much more so than Simitis' bare-faced fraud. Ah, oops, sorry- Simitis cooking the books was when we joined the Eurozone. My bad.