4 ms·
>People are gullible. Humans can be duped by liars and conned by frauds; manipulated by rhetoric and beguiled by self-regard; browbeaten, cajoled, seduced, inti
by DyslexicAtheist 8y ago
>People are gullible. Humans can be duped by liars and conned by frauds; manipulated by rhetoric and beguiled by self-regard; browbeaten, cajoled, seduced, intimidated, flattered, wheedled, inveigled, and ensnared. In this respect, humans are unique in the animal kingdom.
a lot of this could be mitigated through better awareness and early education. Unfortunately "how to think" or "how to reason" about logic is not something most of us learn from their parents or from the education system (even though it would be trivial to do so).
If you know your Kahneman, Tversky (and others) and learn and understand Cognitive Biases the advantage is huge. It's like Neo in the Matrix when he picks the bullets from the air :-)
But it needs to be applied continuously using practical applications (not just by reading 2 papers). People don't have to be an expert on psychology, game theory & risk but at least should expose themselves to the basics (preferably at an early age).
If you want to get beyond the basics then read also D Hofstaedter, D Dennet, K Popper, B Russell, NNTaleb. I wish I would have come across this when I was 10 yro not in my 30ies.
- wirrbel 8y ago> If you know your Kahneman, Tversky (and others) and learn and understand Cognitive Biases the advantage is huge. It's like Neo in the Matrix when he picks the bullets from the air :-) I don't doubt that this helps you, but given the replication crisis in Psychology take these sources with a grain of salt and not as absolute truths, but rather context-bound.
- tunap 8y agoI read "The Dragons of Eden" by Dr Sagan in my early teens. Frankly, that + further studies into logic, consciousness & human nature has led to my feeling like a Martian living in the US.
- leoc 8y agoThat has not been my experience, I'm afraid. The impression I keep getting is that (with due respect to "the power of the context" http://www.vpri.org/pdf/m2004001_power.pdf http://www.vpri.org/pdf/m2004001_power.pdf) teaching someone about fallacies automatically makes them about 15 IQ stupider. In general there's a lot to be said for this oversimplified mental model: "exposing a human being to moral or logical education just leads him to spin out more alluring and more effectively deceptive rationalisations for the stupid and despicable things he was going to do anyway".
- cornholio 8y agoThat's a great way to put it. That's not to say that reason cannot be learned, but that it isn't a subject in itself, there is no such thing as a 'critical thinking' curriculum. You learn critical thinking by thinking.
- pas 8y agoThere are courses that try to teach applied rationality. I don't know how successful they are.
- repolfx 8y agoThe point of learning about fallacies, logic and reason is not to stop people doing something they were already committed to doing and have incorporated into their identity. The point is to stop them from picking up new ideas that don't hold logical water, before they've created any emotional commitment to them.
- mercer 8y agohttps://existentialcomics.com/comic/9 https://existentialcomics.com/comic/9
- pron 8y agoIf this were so simple then we wouldn't have had a problem in the first place. It is not enough to recognize your own biases. For example, one problem is that science has become so specialized, broad and expensive that believing in science means trusting scientists. If a physicist tells you something about the properties of a neutrino, how can you know if she's telling you the truth? You don't have the equipment to do an experiment, and when she claims she's done the experiment at the particle accelerator where she works, you have no way to know if she's lying to you about the results. But it's not just a matter of equipment, but the breadth of modern systems of facts. Even mathematics has become broad enough that no one person can know all of mathematics, and trusting that all theorems of mathematics are, indeed, theorems, requires trusting mathematicians. Ultimately, believing in facts today requires trusting a certain social system. If trust in social systems is eroded (as it is especially among some Americans) then so is acceptance of facts. Conversely, acceptance of facts requires trust in the social system that claims to discover them.
- karmelapple 8y agoThis erosion is anecdotally real to me among some friends and family. A pattern I’ve noticed: when people are physically far removed from the people doing this scientific research, they trust the science less. Think of it as Scientists Without Borders, but for places in the USA / pick your developed nation. What if more people employed in scientific research lived in places where little scientific research traditionally happened? I’m talking towns without big research universities, and without companies doing much scientific work. Encourage scientists whose work can be done remotely to move there. One massive upside: cost of living is much lower. An NIH grant goes a lot further to house, clothe, and feed a researcher anywhere in Iowa - whether in the same city as a large university or a small rural town - than it does in most populated parts of California. By getting employed scientists living in communities that typically do not have many scientists, they become neighbors and have the spontaneous conversations with people in the community - at cookouts, at town events - which can help restore trust and understanding of science by having direct knowledge of someone doing that work every day. Someone typically trusts their neighbor they’ve lived beside for 15 years more than the new neighbor who just moved in, and there’s likely no easy shortcut to rebuilding that trust, although it can be broken by institutions with a vested interest in breaking trust. Get fast internet everywhere and encourage people who can move to get jobs there, and two parts of the challenges of making this a reality are gone. The ease of meeting and networking with new people when living in a place that’s more densely populated with scientists still wouldn’t quite be solved, though...