3 ms·
Many of the fruits of positivism are accepted by scientists and engineers, but I think Maudlin is correct in saying that the analytic school has (rightfully) sh
by woodruffw 8y ago
Many of the fruits of positivism are accepted by scientists and engineers, but I think Maudlin is correct in saying that the analytic school has (rightfully) shied away from the central positivist claim (i.e., that "any two observably equivalent theories are one and the same theory"/"a theory says no more than its observable consequences"). We've carried Popper and a few other positivists into the 21st century, but in a form that most would probably be unhappy with.
I agree about the wave/particle description, though. I've read Maudlin before in the context of the philosophy of time, and he is frequently critiqued in that domain for giving inadequate consideration to quantum-theoretic discoveries.
- akvadrako 8y ago> We've carried Popper and a few other positivists Popper was not a positivist. From https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Positivism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Positivism: However, the claim that Popper was a positivist is a common misunderstanding that Popper himself termed the "Popper legend."[57] In fact, he developed his beliefs in stark opposition to and as a criticism of positivism and held that scientific theories talk about how the world really is, not, as positivists claim, about phenomena or observations experienced by scientists.
- woodruffw 8y agoPopper might not have considered himself a capital-P positivist for metaphysical reasons (and because of his skepticism towards logical positivism in particular), but his general approach to the philosophy of science is both compatible with and is taught as an example of the school. There are all kinds of disagreements between Popper and the capital-P positivists (verification vs. falsification being the biggest one), but they don't preclude the inclusion of Popper in the broader positivist movement in the philosophy of science.
- akvadrako 8y agoPopper was very concerned with explaining the actual underlying reality and what criteria contribute to better explanations - things like being more rigid. To me that seems quite against the main idea of _p_ositivism. Popper even takes that stance that theory is prior to evidence - you start with the best explanation and even without new evidence or predictions, you move on to better explanations as they are discovered. Since you are making this claim against his own words and without being backed up by respected sources, in what sense is he a _p_ositivist?
- catawbasam 8y ago"Science must begin with myths, and with the criticism of myths; neither with the collection of observations, nor with the invention of experiments, but with the critical discussion of myths, and of magical techniques and practices. The scientific tradition is distinguished from the pre-scientific tradition in having two layers. Like the latter, it passes on its theories; but it also passes on a critical attitude towards them. The theories are passed on, not as dogmas, but rather with the challenge to discuss them and improve upon them." Karl Popper, 'Conjectures and Refutations'
- mmirate 8y agoLayman's hopefully-dumb question here: if a theory has no observable consequences, then what is it even saying? (or doing, or etc)
- slowmovintarget 8y agoIf it isn't falsifiable, then it isn't scientific. I'm cribbing that from reading the Wikipedia page on Logical Positivism, specifically the criticism of positivism by Popper.