2 ms·
You seem to be hung up on utilitarianism implying a particular one dimensional utility metric. I don't see why that is necessary, to call something "utilitarian
by perl4ever 8y ago
You seem to be hung up on utilitarianism implying a particular one dimensional utility metric. I don't see why that is necessary, to call something "utilitarianism". Why can't utilitarianism be conceived of as parameterizable? Without arguing for any particular ethical system, I think the world as it exists operates largely on a utilitarian basis, just with a less simplistic utility metric, similar to what I mentioned twice. Is acting according to this "ethical"? I have no interest in debating that. Your examples are starting to sound like things I believe have happened frequently in history, unethical or not.
Edit/post script: I am not so sure that rules like "don't murder" are in conflict with utilitarianism as I think of it existing. Maybe if you look at moral choices as an optimization process, simple rules function as heuristics to deal with uncertainty, bias and lack of information on utility.
- emodendroket 8y agoI don't follow. The world may often operate on intuitive, inchoate, proto-utilitarian principles, but I don't think most of us accept a just-world principle, so that observation doesn't take us very far. Utilitarianism is an ethical framework used to evaluate ethical claims. Why do you even care about it if you're not interested in talking about ethics?