8 ms·
Forget about the main focus of the article... (I would prefer liability to lie with the manufacturer, no store online or offline is equipped to expertly and ind
by crazygringo 8y ago
Forget about the main focus of the article... (I would prefer liability to lie with the manufacturer, no store online or offline is equipped to expertly and independently analyze and judge the safety of all the things they sell, but whatever.)
But how on earth can Amazon sell something and then lose track of the merchant, especially a foreign one? There seem to be so many necessary guarantees this breaks, not just product liability but obeying import/export laws, handling taxes, financial regulations preventing money laundering, and so on.
How is it legal for an American company to sell, or even list foreign products to American consumers where the "manufacturer is unknown"? Is there some kind of loophole in the laws?
- awat 8y agoThat was my first takeaway too. It’s one of the biggie no-no’s in banking to not know the customer. I’m at a loss on why that would be ok here. I’m also fine with the manufacturer taking the liability but for the retailer to say we don’t know, is at best incompetence and at worst a middle finger to the US consumer.
- dd36 8y agoThe manufacturer should have to be required to maintain liability insurance with a claims process. If Amazon doesn’t enforce that standard, it should have to stand in.
- awat 8y agoThat would make sense to me. Not to over simplify the issue but I would settle with Amazon having skin in the game period. They seem to be extremely good at engineering ways to deflect responsibility (financially or ethically).
- baybal2 8y agoThat applies to domestic manufacturers and ones having legal representation on US soil. An "Uncle Liu garage factory co." obviously does not qualify as such.
- CamelCaseName 8y agoThey do require it: https://sellercentral.amazon.com/gp/help/help.html?itemID=200386300 https://sellercentral.amazon.com/gp/help/help.html?itemID=20... However, they do not enforce it (IME) until you break $10K/mo
- teraflop 8y agoThe article doesn't say that Amazon lost track of the manufacturer; it says that the customer wasn't able to get that information from Amazon.
- crazygringo 8y ago> ...Judge William Campbell dismissed it on Wednesday. He ruled that even though it's undisputed that "the manufacturer of the hoverboard at issue is unknown"... Would this not mean it's unknown to both sides?
- wtvanhest 8y agoIMNAL, My guess is that they can establish records of transactions they do with sellers and adhere to all transaction laws... but once they take possession of the good, they comingle it and can no longer tell where it came from.
- rasz 8y agoThat would be illegal. Imagine Pawn shop explaining to the cops they dont know which one of cameras/guns/rolex watches sold turned out to be stolen.
- acct1771 8y agoThey regularly do this.
- astura 8y agoThey fully admit to doing this: https://sellercentral.amazon.com/gp/help/help.html?itemID=200141480&language=en-US&ref=mpbc_200243180_cont_200141480 https://sellercentral.amazon.com/gp/help/help.html?itemID=20...
- andrewaylett 8y agoLike what happened to this guy, for example? https://startupnation.com/start-your-business/plan-your-business/amazon-fba-program/ https://startupnation.com/start-your-business/plan-your-busi...
- ubernostrum 8y agoPeople have been complaining for a long time now that Amazon is hard to trust because of how many counterfeit/knockoff items get mixed in among genuine ones in their warehouses. There was even a guy who lost his Global Entry status (trusted traveler program run by US Customs) because, unknown to him, he'd been thrown under the bus when a suitcase he ordered from Amazon was seized at the border for being a counterfeit: https://lifehacker.com/your-amazon-order-might-lock-you-out-of-trusted-travele-1821964978 https://lifehacker.com/your-amazon-order-might-lock-you-out-... Amazon itself tends to keep quiet about this, but consensus in the various stories is that their system's set up to make it hard to know the origin of particular items, or to keep third-party (and potentially counterfeit) items separate from ones sourced direct from the manufacturer.
- dd36 8y agoIf you’re a foreign company selling on Amazon, even through a shell, you should be bonded and insured or whatever the equivalent that home contractors are required to have. If an electrical contractor can burn down my home and so can your shoddy product, they should require the same minimum insurance. Edit: all companies, forget foreign.
- baybal2 8y ago>If an electrical contractor can burn down my home and so can your shoddy product, they should require the same minimum insurance. You think companies like Google and Amazon don't buy from the same cheapest deal manufacturers? At the very beginning of my career in 2008, I worked in a trade agency in Singapore, where I was an exchange student. Once, we came upon a client who was bragging to be the sourcing company working for all big named Co's around, Amazon and Google included. We were doing a very simple thing for them - getting USB ac/dc converters. At first, we were truly surprised why such a "serious company" is not up to the task to do this trivial thing by themselves. The catch was they were demanding price just below $1 for a unit, packaged.... We found one miserable factory in SZ that was ready to do it for 87 cents, sans packaging. On our request if they do get an idea what this involves, the client said yes. Not only they went forward with that, they continued to fight for the price, and turned to thing as ridiculous as demanding use of cardboard PCB, shaving microns of plastic from the casing there and there, and, the most ridiculous, demanding "use two cheap diodes instead of this beefy one." Two years later, I heard people were reporting that half of people buying Google Nexus were the lucky receivers of this usb charger batch.