4 ms·
How about we treat so-called white collar crimes the same as regular crimes? In this case, theft is theft. If you can't pay a fine as pinishment for robbing a b
by chiefalchemist 8y ago
How about we treat so-called white collar crimes the same as regular crimes? In this case, theft is theft. If you can't pay a fine as pinishment for robbing a bank, why can you do it for something like wage theft?
Fines are a slap on the wrist. But take away freedom from the guilty and things will change. Quickly.
- the8472 8y agoGame-theoretic concerns. You don't want to collapse the hierarchy of deterrance, otherwise you'll have "might as well murder them to hide the evidence of my previous crimes" situation. Additionally the difference in visibility and number of people who are in a theoretical position to commit theft vs. those who are in a position to withhold wages might have an impact since it's probably easier to go after the latter after the fact while you have to rely more on deterrence for the former.
- Kuiper 8y agoIf you can't pay a fine as pinishment for robbing a bank, why can you do it for something like wage theft? Robbery is a violent crime (robbery, by definition, consists of using force or threat of force/intimidation) that places members of the public in danger. For example, last month there was a Nigerian bank robbery last month where bank robbers armed with assault rifles and got into a gun battle with police officers that left 16 people dead. [1] Now, you could make the argument that running around with an assault rifle and firing at people is its own crime, but when you walk into a bank and hand the teller a note that says "Give me all the money in the vault," you are stating by implication that you intend to do [very very bad thing] to them if they don't -- you are using the implied threat of violence. (By the same token, if you confront people in an alleyway and say "Hey buddy, give me your wallet," you can't defend yourself in court saying, "But I never threatened people with violence!" The threat of violence is implied by your demand.) So, in your question, you ask why bank robbery (a violent crime) is a jailable offense, while wage theft (a white collar crime) isn't. I think there's a lot of support for the idea that "non-violent offenders don't belong in prison (but violent offenders do)." It's the same reason that burglarizing your neighbor's house while they're on vacation is considered by most jurisdictions to be a less serious crime than mugging someone: robbers don't just victimize people by taking their money; they also threaten the victim's physical safety. I personally would feel much more rattled if I had $200 in cash taken from me at gunpoint than if I had a client stiff me for $500. [1] https://www.cnn.com/2018/04/06/africa/nigeria-bank-robbery/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2018/04/06/africa/nigeria-bank-robbery/i...
- ubernostrum 8y agoIt's the same reason that burglarizing your neighbor's house while they're on vacation is considered by most jurisdictions to be a less serious crime And yet you'd still go to jail for doing that. Potentially for several years depending on the value of what you stole. Wage theft orders of magnitude larger than that burglary would still typically only get a slap-on-the-wrist (relative to the ill-gotten gains) fine. To turn your attempt on its head: why is robbing one person an offense that gets incarceration, but robbing a hundred people may not even get you prosecuted?
- Kuiper 8y agowhy is robbing one person an offense that gets incarceration, but robbing a hundred people may not even get you prosecuted? In the latter case (where you describe "robbing a hundred people"), are you referring to wage theft? Because if the employer is not using violence or threat of violence, then by definition they are not "robbing" people. That was the entire point of my post: theft and robbery are not the same; robbery is theft + use/threat of violence.
- ubernostrum 8y agoThat was the entire point of my post: theft and robbery are not the same; robbery is theft + use/threat of violence. And then you used the analogy of breaking into a house when nobody's home. And I pointed out that carries stiffer penalties than wage theft, despite not involving the use or threat of violence against a person. Your attempt to split hairs to justify the near complete lack of punishment for wage theft is not succeeding.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoFraud. You forgot fraud. We're not simply talking theft. It's fraud as well. Fraud - like the implied violence in robbery - is a violation of the social fabric. To think that it (i.e., fraud) is less damaging naive. As I said earlier, put people in jail for theft and fraud and you'll see those things decrease. As it is now, too often (white collar) crime __does__ pay.