3 ms·
We'd rather that companies were honest, and yes the law should be enforced fairly and as on the books to keep the playing field for corporations level. But no,
by roenxi 8y ago
We'd rather that companies were honest, and yes the law should be enforced fairly and as on the books to keep the playing field for corporations level. But no, wage theft isn't a bigger problem than other theft.
Yes, wage theft is bigger numerically. But a reduction in wage theft is going to be mirrored by a drop in the amount of wealth available. By definition, the same or less work is being done for a higher cost; so by examining the net situation, someone is going to have less actual stuff (and I can say with confidence, it is not going to be the rich who do without). Increasing the cost of labour will put people out of work.
Wage theft is one of those victimless crimes where both parties have agreed that a situation is the best alternative and the government is declaring that they are wrong. It is a lot more delicate than, say, gay marriage, because all workers would prefer to have more money, and by far most workers would be happier if they didn't have to work. But, end of the day, just because the government says a worker is entitled doesn't mean the worker is truly unhappy with what they get. In an extreme case, I've worked in situations where I have been subject to wage theft (~10% lower compensation than I should have legally been getting), and I tried to keep that off anyone's radar because I wouldn't have had a job otherwise and I was being paid plenty.
Workers take the best option they have; possibly making that option uneconomic is not a good idea. This is not how, eg, China, is lifting people out of poverty.
- 49531 8y ago> reduction in wage theft is going to be mirrored by a drop in the amount of wealth available. In a situation where wage theft is happening and then it stops happening, the money doesn't get thrown in a garbage bin. The stolen money goes to the worker rather than the employer. If I got paid my average hourly rate for 10 unpaid hours per week, I'd make roughly $12,000 more per year than I do now. $12,000 which would go towards my student loans, or a down payment for a house, or just buying random shit. Instead that $12,000 goes to the corporation I work for. You might argue that they can do that to 10 people and afford to hire another engineer, which is great, except now we have a corporation who is subsidized by unpaid labor, not by being an effective corporation.
- pbecotte 8y agoSo your employer pays 48k for 50 hours a week of labor. Yes, if they suddenly paid you 60k instead you'd be doing better. But that doesn't mean they benefit from unpaid labor, just that the current rate is less than you think it is.
- DFHippie 8y agoSomewhere there is a contract specifying the amount the corporation will pay and the worker will receive for an hour of work. It is the violation of this contract which makes it theft. This is also what makes driving someone else's car away, taking their wallet, or moving into their house theft. If someone walks off with your wallet, it isn't that you've misunderstood the legal conditions of your ownership of that wallet. The problem, in other words, is not in your understanding.
- roenxi 8y agoThe money is only useful for the goods and services it can purchase. Labour conditions is a classic case of the government is mandating allocations of resources that a free market would not make; it isn't going to result in more goods and services being produced. The same workers are not going to produce more because of labour law enforcement. The three outcomes are: 1) Workers get a bigger proportion of a smaller total 2) Workers get the same proportion of a smaller total 3) Workers get a smaller proportion of a smaller total The pro-labour-laws types have to be very certain that they can force outcome 1, but there are 2 ways in 3 that the outcome is bad, on net, for workers. Especially if the job they were working in was the best option they had. Workers might even be getting less overall (through reduced job availability) when individual workers get more due to reductions in the number of jobs created.
- xapata 8y agoIt's always possible that a policy will have a bad outcome. In this case, I'd like to run the experiment. My guess is that the dynamics will be good for the economy: more cash in the pockets of workers means more cash flow through the economy, more activity, more growth, everyone wins.
- s73v3r_ 8y ago"Wage theft is one of those victimless crimes" Wage theft is most definitely not victimless. There is a very, very clear victim in that instance. "and I tried to keep that off anyone's radar because I wouldn't have had a job otherwise and I was being paid plenty." That's not true in the least. Any employer that is telling you that is flat out lying to you. "Workers take the best option they have; possibly making that option uneconomic is not a good idea." No. Just no. Why do you feel that employers are entitled to cheap labor?
- roenxi 8y agoYour victims will have very clear memories of their wages and conditions from what happened to them last month when they went to work. They are making a proactive choice to get out of bed, go to work, and do it again. They aren't being forced to work for their employer. > That's not true in the least. It is perfectly true, just not a very normal case. I'd put it to you that I was a bit more involved in the negotiating than you were. > No. Just no. Why do you feel that employers are entitled to cheap labor? I don't think that. The argument is that employers and employees are entitled to sort out wages between each other and are entitled on whatever they agree to. I don't think the government has a role tilting the power balance in favour of employees. I'm in favour of things work hours being explicit in any contract and being enforced. Being expected to work unpaid overtime is obscene; the contract hours should be longer an the wages lower so people know what is expected of them.
- s73v3r_ 8y ago"They are making a proactive choice to get out of bed, go to work, and do it again. They aren't being forced to work for their employer." Because the alternative is homelessness. "It is perfectly true, just not a very normal case. I'd put it to you that I was a bit more involved in the negotiating than you were." No, it's not true. Just because they told you that, and you fell for it, doesn't make it true. "Being expected to work unpaid overtime is obscene" And yet, here you are defending the practice of wage theft.
- detcader 8y ago> They aren't being forced to work for their employer. So true... Every weekend I go for interviews and get job offers, and I have 6 months of rent and bill money saved up in case of an act of God. The last time I lost my employment I just called up one of the employers and accepted the job. It's very weird that people act like they don't do this as well.
- throwaway2048 8y agowage theft is a victimless crime? Do you not understand what coercion is? Just because somebody "agreed" by not immediately quitting does not mean its not horrible and abusive.
- jotm 8y agoMight as well steal someone's identity and get a few credit cards, it's a victimless crime.
- sykh 8y agoI suppose we need to relive the days of Upton Sinclair's The Jungle before labor rights isn’t viewed as a negative. We really are regressing in this area. If you haven’t already done so please read the book.