12 ms·
Wage Theft is a Bigger Problem Than Other Forms of Theft (2014)
- 49531 8y agoOrganized labor is the only way to combat this kind of abuse. Workers cannot rely on policy makers or corporations to do it for them. Organizing doesn't mean forming an official legal union, or joining an already established union (in some cases this might make sense but not always). You can organize mutual aid networks that do things like share salary data and talk about their problems.
- iagovar 8y agoI am affiliated to a trade union in Spain and I find it mostly positive. Most trade unions seem lazy, like just structures of bureaucrats, but this one runs very well. I pay a monthly fee of 15€/month, have access to a labor lawyer and a "resistance box" in case I have to go on strike or something, they match a % of your salary (not remember how much, but in my case it was like 80% of it). They also have a sensible approach on collective agreements. I also have access to more stuff I can't remember now. Sadly this trade union is small, and sectorial, but it very refreshing seen this, because most trade unions in Spain have bad rep.
- 49531 8y agoOlder unions in the US has a bad rap as well, but I think a lot of that is corporate propaganda to be honest. Like, the idea of having a labor lawyer at your disposal is an incredible benefit to you. I am sure wage theft is a little harder when your employees are armed with legal aid.
- mgkimsal 8y agohad never even thought of that as a feature of unions. i know a couple people selling 'legalshield', and a few people that have bought it. having the ability to contact an attorney for 'now and then' questions, to clear stuff up, or write letters.... $30/month or something like that. Seems similar, and potentially valuable, to have that in a corporate setting, depending on how much $ it would actually run you.
- tdeck 8y agoIt seems like a reasonable idea, but personally I wouldn't trust any company that operates as an MLM as Legal Shield apparently does. It's hard to even find good information about such companies given the prevalence of astroturfing by their members.
- mgkimsal 8y agoagree on mlm in general. conceptually, having some basic access to legal specific to workplace law would be a reasonable benefit for union members though.
- enraged_camel 8y agoAlso keep in mind HN tends to lean anti-union because techies in general are treated and paid very well, and tend to feel like they don’t need unions.
- knuththetruth 8y agoTechies are highly-paid relative to many other workers, but they're being exploited by they're being employers in many of the same ways as their low-wage counterparts, including collusive depression and theft of wages. Death march culture and the Google-Apple wage-fixing scandal should've demonstrated this to everyone.
- walterbell 8y agoLinkedIn paid $6M for unpaid overtime, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8137958 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8137958 > LinkedIn failed to record, account and pay for all hours worked in a workweek, investigators found ... "Off the clock' hours are all too common for the American worker. This practice harms workers, denies them the wages they have rightfully earned and takes away time with families," said Susana Blanco, district director for the division in San Francisco. "We urge all employers, large and small, to review their pay practices to ensure employees know their basic workplace rights and that the commitment to compliance works through all levels of the organization. The department is committed to protecting the rights of workers and leveling the playing field for all law-abiding employers."
- uiri 8y agoI think HN tends to lean anti-union because it is centered around a community of seed investors and entrepreneurs. Unions would work against their interests.
- crankylinuxuser 8y agoThe answer seems obvious to me, and that is to have the workers be the investors themselves. In that way, the workers are also the bosses and can collectively decide their future and path forward. Other ways separates the money from the labor. There will always be strife in that organization. Having a worker owned co-op also means that the profits don't go elsewhere - they go back to the people doing the labor.
- EpicEng 8y ago>but I think a lot of that is corporate propaganda to be honest I think it's both. My best friend makes $31 / hour installing plastic car door clips on an assembly line. That's a ridiculous wage for what he does (literally anyone could do his job.) I'm happy for him and his family, but there's also a negative aspect to labor costing 3-4x what would be competitive in an open market.
- nickpsecurity 8y ago"I'm happy for him and his family, but there's also a negative aspect to labor costing 3-4x what would be competitive in an open market." Id consider such arguments if they applied to CEO's or similarly were reducing corporate expenses on things of questionable value. I find most of the companies that aay they can't pay workers overpay upper management and have a lot of frivilous spending.
- yomly 8y agoThis. The levels of expenses paid for senior people in big organizations is insane. A friend recently rented out an apartment in central London to people working for a nonprofit org at £10k per month and this is only scratching the surface of ludicrous corporate expense culture. Meanwhile these upper management say they can't pay their staff a living wage...
- briandear 8y agoA non-profit? Lol. Quick way to fix that is to let donors know about those ridiculous expenses. A private for profit company should be able to do whatever it wants because they are competing in a free market. Those high expenses might be justified as part of their strategy to recruit top management talent. Basically, those expenses are paid back by the output of those incurring them. A non-profit on the other hand — they are tax exempt, so taxpayers get to subsidize that 10k apartment.
- s73v3r_ 8y ago"Those high expenses might be justified as part of their strategy to recruit top management talent. " I really don't buy the argument that normal workers deserve to be paid crap because of "free market", but for some reason executive compensation needs to be amazingly outlandish.
- closeparen 8y agoEngineers like efficiency. We think of ourselves as handy generalists who can dive into any task. This necessarily puts us on the side of management regarding rules designed to ensure there is enough work to go around and limit the tasks that workers in specific roles are allowed to do. I’d genuinely take a pay cut to work in a high-functioning environment where workflows and systems are well orchestrated, rather than one where everything is an uphill slog due to arcane make-work rules. This is a character trait particular to tech industry folk, and may explain why we dislike old-school unions so much, even when they may be in our financial best interests.
- 0x445442 8y ago>> I’d genuinely take a pay cut to work in a high-functioning environment where workflows and systems are well orchestrated, rather than one where everything is an uphill slog due to arcane make-work rules. This is a very interesting take and I'm exactly the same way. In fact, I just gave notice last week at my current position so that I could pursue a position with a company that was leaner and where more of my time would be spent on relevant work versus meta work. Fortunately, the complete compensation packages, benefits, insurance, et al. at both places came out to about a wash. My current employer is more secure from an employment perspective but I'm willing to give that up in exchange for "staying in the game" technically and for seeing the fruits of my labor have a more direct impact in the marketplace.
- late2part 8y agoPlease do. Many companies pay well and do not have make-work rules. You really really can work at a better place.
- union_throwaway 8y agoI have had many friends who work in fields which required them to join unions in the US (engineering, law enforcement, education, entertainment, etc), and I have never heard anyone say anything positive about them. At best, they suck a few dollars per month from your paycheck. Most commonly, they prevent the bad apples from ever being fired, no matter how blatant their behavior. Or a non-union person is not allowed to do a trivial task (like move a chair) because it's "union work". At worst, if union management decides to make you the target of a witch hunt, they can make it hell to try to find work in that field at any workplace in their jurisdiction. Who protects workers from the union itself? I accept that unions have had a valuable place in society, and they're definitely still good for some things, but I don't believe their poor reputation today is "corporate propaganda". They seem to be one of those types of organizations that have outlived their original purpose, mostly, and now exist to propagate themselves. Ultimately, it's just another power structure. The structure is neither good nor bad. What matters is the people. ("The machinery of government is always subordinate to the will of those who administer that machinery.") Like every organization, over time they tend to collect the type of people who take advantage of that power structure.
- briandear 8y agoFor less than the cost of a union, you can get legal insurance/pre-paid legal services. It’s possible for people to take care of themselves.
- walterbell 8y agoIs there a difference in power between individual and collective bargaining?
- briandear 8y agoCollective bargaining devalues me as an individual contributor. If my pay is fixed to whatever level the union negotiated for me and those with equal seniority, I can’t get past that wage. My upward mobility is traded for a reduction in downward mobility. I would have less incentive to work harder or go the extra mile. I would have the passion and motivation of a clerk at the department of motor vehicles. You can’t fire me unless I do something really bad and I can’t get a raise unless everyone else also gets a raise. I can’t move employers to seek better wages because I’d lose seniority. Collective bargaining is a life sentence of mediocrity for both a company and individuals. However, for 19th and 20th style assembly line type work where workers are literally interchangeable, then I can understand the appeal of collective bargaining. Some guy turning the same screw all day on an assembly line — there is not much room for “excelling” — you either turn the screw when the next part gets to you, or you don’t. Screw-turning doesn’t really have much opportunity for innovation or extra-mile at the individual level. But for a restaurant worker who might be extra nice to a customer or stay a few minutes late to help make the place extra clean or the kitchen worker who reduces food waste by being more efficient — even those “low” level jobs would be harmed by collective bargaining. Jobs that benefit from collective bargaining are ones with extremely minimal autonomy or require an extremely low skill set: just turn a screw. For jobs that actually require intelligence (emotional or intellectual,) collective bargaining is an insult. Unless of course you are poorly motivated in which case it’s a gift.
- knuththetruth 8y ago>Collective bargaining is a life sentence of mediocrity for both a company and individuals. How do you reconcile this opinion with the high-levels of pay and celebrity in the entertainment industry and professional sports? They're all unionized and their bosses make money hand over fist as well.
- wpietri 8y agoI'm sure some of it is propaganda, but I think it's also an artifact of very adversarial management/labor splits that were more common in the past. If management is full of exploitative dicks, it's not surprising that the unions would also think in a zero-sum fashion. There's a fantastic This American Life that I've recommended here before: https://www.thisamericanlife.org/561/nummi-2015 https://www.thisamericanlife.org/561/nummi-2015 It's on the NUMMI plant. GM's worst plant was shut down; Toyota took it over as part of a joint venture to show GM how to make cars in the Toyota way. The story of the workers and how they change as they work for an employer that treats them with respect is amazing. It definitely made me believe that unions indeed could be shitty. But also, that it's not a one-sided thing, and that other relationships are not just possible, but necessary if we're going to make things that are more useful and reliable than a '79 Chevette.
- chrisseaton 8y agoWhat is in your "resistance box"? Sounds a bit sinister.
- klez 8y agoSounds just like a collective rainy-day fund to afford losing your wage during a strike.
- chrisseaton 8y agoSounded like a weapons cache to me! But I was sure it was actually something more reasonable.
- switch007 8y agoI think it was a literal translation of "caja de resistencia". From what I can gather it's a fund, usually managed by the union, to help alleviate financial hardship as a result of workers striking.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- evgen 8y agoIn the US it is called a 'strike fund.'
- tigershark 8y agoJust to put things in perspective, what is your annual salary in a job with a strong trade union? From what I know from Italy I would bet much than 50k euros... And honestly I prefer to have much less job security for much more money in my pocket..
- briandear 8y agoExactly why I oppose unions. They are bastions of average. I want the opportunity to not be average.
- detcader 8y agoUnions and organized labor will always occur. The incentives for it are inevitable under capitalism. I accept this and would like to see a working economy that is more nuanced than the one implied by "opposing unions".
- s73v3r_ 8y agoUnions have absolutely nothing to do with that, and you know it. Stop with the propaganda.
- blub 8y agoWell that's the point: you are probably young enough, healthy enough and without many obligations, so it's easy for you to accept the lack of job security. But add a chronic health issue or having to take care of a dependant and you'll quickly find out why that job security + decent instead of maximum wage is not such a bad idea.
- matchagaucho 8y agoAgreed... but with the Supreme Court overturning Workers rights to file class action claims to recover lost wages, the ability to organize is under attack.
- briandear 8y agoThey didn’t overturn that right. They affirmed that when an employee signs something, they are bound by the agreement they signed. Potential employees are free to not sign those agreements. Employees who have signed agreements can’t change their mind and suddenly complain about an agreement they willingly signed. If we eliminated those agreements and exposed companies to increased litigation risk, what would you expect to happen to wages? They’d go down naturally. Let’s pretend companies were bound by French style agreements — wages would quickly drop to French-style wages. American workers have more disposable income that almost every other country. If you want to reduce that disposable income, start allowing class actions. Mind you, employees DO have protection against wage “theft” — that’s already a crime. A simple google search will return dozens of law firms ready to represent a worker who thinks they’ve been wronged. Even arbitration agreements can’t protect against illegal activity. The only people getting paid for class actions are attorneys. The worker doesn’t win anything but maybe a $25 check. Meanwhile their employer has to incur extraordinary expenses. Who pays for that? The workers through lower salaries and customers through higher prices.
- matchagaucho 8y ago4 of the 9 Justices disagree. Minimum wage Workers do not have the time or resources to hire a Lawyer to chase down $100 in withheld overtime. When theft has occurred at a mass scale, such as Amazon Warehouse Workers or UPS Employees... it is far less expensive for the Employer to settle the matter with one collective unit, rather than thousands of individuals. Yes, the Lawyers reap the majority of the benefits, but the judgement takes that penalty into account.
- Shivetya 8y agoArbitration clauses which the Supremes upheld favor those who cannot afford a lawyer because it guarantees their grievance must be acknowledged and addressed. Now while an outcome favorable to the employee is not always guaranteed nor is one for the employer. Class Action with regards to wage suits is very rare and this was mainly a push by plaintiff attorneys who stood to rake in millions while offering no guarantee of providing a substantive reward for the plaintive. In the end as stated by some the reasoning, the two laws are written as such that binding agreements are truly that, binding. If that needs to change then Congress needs to act.
- jdietrich 8y ago>Workers cannot rely on policy makers The fact that they can't represents a major political failure. Good policies can make a huge difference. Here in the UK, the HMRC (our tax authority) is responsible for enforcing the National Minimum Wage. This makes a great deal of sense. Employers are legally required to report wage payments to HMRC for payroll tax purposes and the HMRC have tremendous institutional capacity for conducting financial investigations. For HMRC, a minimum wage complaint is a twofer - underpaid wages mean less revenue from payroll taxes and is usually a sign of tax evasion. HMRC operate a confidential hotline for reporting violations of the minimum wage law. Where workers need to resolve a complaint, they can access mediation or binding arbitration completely free of charge. There is inevitably the risk of retaliatory action by an employer, but at least employees have the ability to enforce their rights without having to pay for legal representation.
- 49531 8y agoThe UK also has an explicit party for labor. The US has nothing of the sort. The Democratic party used to be the labor party but as since joined the Republicans as a corporate funded organization. Hard to pass labor laws when your big donors are employers.
- Thlom 8y agoNot knowing the UK very well, but you have had and still have strong unions with political representation through the Labour party. If labour isn't organised you will not get good (for the working class) policy. Politics is the formal battle of interests and if labour doesn't show up to the fight, the capital owners wins on walkover.
- jdietrich 8y agoOur trade unions were kneecapped by Thatcher back in the 80s. A Labour government introduced the minimum wage, but the current Conservative government is progressively increasing it from £6.50 in 2015 to £9 by 2020. Employment tribunals were introduced in 1996 by a Conservative government; a Conservative government introduced relatively high fees in 2013, but this was overturned by the Supreme Court last year. Unions are part of the picture, but they're a reflection of a broader political culture. Trade unions can't turn the electorate socialist, but a socialist electorate can build strong trade unions.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoHow about we treat so-called white collar crimes the same as regular crimes? In this case, theft is theft. If you can't pay a fine as pinishment for robbing a bank, why can you do it for something like wage theft? Fines are a slap on the wrist. But take away freedom from the guilty and things will change. Quickly.
- the8472 8y agoGame-theoretic concerns. You don't want to collapse the hierarchy of deterrance, otherwise you'll have "might as well murder them to hide the evidence of my previous crimes" situation. Additionally the difference in visibility and number of people who are in a theoretical position to commit theft vs. those who are in a position to withhold wages might have an impact since it's probably easier to go after the latter after the fact while you have to rely more on deterrence for the former.
- Kuiper 8y agoIf you can't pay a fine as pinishment for robbing a bank, why can you do it for something like wage theft? Robbery is a violent crime (robbery, by definition, consists of using force or threat of force/intimidation) that places members of the public in danger. For example, last month there was a Nigerian bank robbery last month where bank robbers armed with assault rifles and got into a gun battle with police officers that left 16 people dead. [1] Now, you could make the argument that running around with an assault rifle and firing at people is its own crime, but when you walk into a bank and hand the teller a note that says "Give me all the money in the vault," you are stating by implication that you intend to do [very very bad thing] to them if they don't -- you are using the implied threat of violence. (By the same token, if you confront people in an alleyway and say "Hey buddy, give me your wallet," you can't defend yourself in court saying, "But I never threatened people with violence!" The threat of violence is implied by your demand.) So, in your question, you ask why bank robbery (a violent crime) is a jailable offense, while wage theft (a white collar crime) isn't. I think there's a lot of support for the idea that "non-violent offenders don't belong in prison (but violent offenders do)." It's the same reason that burglarizing your neighbor's house while they're on vacation is considered by most jurisdictions to be a less serious crime than mugging someone: robbers don't just victimize people by taking their money; they also threaten the victim's physical safety. I personally would feel much more rattled if I had $200 in cash taken from me at gunpoint than if I had a client stiff me for $500. [1] https://www.cnn.com/2018/04/06/africa/nigeria-bank-robbery/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2018/04/06/africa/nigeria-bank-robbery/i...
- ebikelaw 8y agoDon't you think there's also a place for law enforcement? In California many public works projects are delayed because inspectors regularly come to the work site, stop all work for the day, and interview the laborers on the site to make sure they are getting paid. This is disruptive and the only reason they need to do it is because when they find wage theft they don't really prosecute it. There are small fines and then everything continues. What the inspectors should do is give the contractors in question the figurative death penalty: permanently revoked contractor license, revocation of work orders, clawback of money already paid, jail time and serious fines for the individuals responsible. We for some reason have a high tolerance for white-collar crimes when we really should be prosecuting them vigorously.
- knuththetruth 8y agoGiven the scale of wage-theft in the US, as documented by this study, your emphasis on a narrow and specific concern related to inspections seems disproportionate. I'm not saying this isn't a difficult burden for those who deal with the inspections, but in terms of priorities, huge numbers of people getting robbed by their employers would seem to deserve more attention?
- wpietri 8y agoI would love to see law enforcement take this more seriously. But we should be honest with ourselves that in this moment in America, government is much more responsive to the needs of the rich. One only need look at the newspaper to suspect that, but studies agree: http://www.princeton.edu/~mgilens/Gilens%20homepage%20materials/Gilens%20and%20Page/Gilens%20and%20Page%202014-Testing%20Theories%203-7-14.pdf http://www.princeton.edu/~mgilens/Gilens%20homepage%20materi... One of the fundamental problems with employer/employee relations is that employers usually have more workers than employees have jobs. Losing your job is worse than having an employee quit. This fundamental imbalance of power means that we'll always need ways to even things out if we want reasonably fair situations for employees. Labor laws and law enforcement can cover part of that. And we should certainly pursue it. But I think people should also pursue collective action, be that as formal as a union or as casual as Google's workers all pressuring their employers to stop doing military work. Resilient systems always have multiple ways to keep a problem from getting out of control.
- platz 8y agoCo-determination / worker co-ops is a better route, since labor power has been blighted by pestilence.
- conanbatt 8y agoLabor organizations survive on the employees that pay them, they are the formality of wage theft.
- conanbatt 8y agoLabor organizations survive on the employees that pay them, they are the formality of wage theft. Unions suck, they really do. These things happen and people have to leave and find a new place, staying and litigating is not going to make any difference, and a union cannot spring money out of nowhere, they ould have the exact same issues.
- s73v3r_ 8y ago"Labor organizations survive on the employees that pay them, they are the formality of wage theft." No, absolutely not. There is nothing in that statement that is true. "These things happen and people have to leave and find a new place, staying and litigating is not going to make any difference" That is the most wishy washy way to wave away theft that I've ever heard. It basically sounds like you're saying, "It's going to happen, so just accept it, and don't try to change it." "and a union cannot spring money out of nowhere, they ould have the exact same issues." Except the companies doing this are benefitting from it, at the expense of their employees.
- conanbatt 8y ago> No, absolutely not. There is nothing in that statement that is true. A union where joining is a costly-optionality will have no members. Thus any union that has any strength whatsoever will be able to restrict work one way or another. > That is the most wishy washy way to wave away theft that I've ever heard. It basically sounds like you're saying, "It's going to happen, so just accept it, and don't try to change it." More like suing the cow for spilt milk. If a company is going brankrupt in a disorderly manner (fast and in a short period of time) there is no justice. > Except the companies doing this are benefitting from it, at the expense of their employees. Yes but now the unions will join in on the pillage!
- paultopia 8y agoAs someone who used to practice law in a legal aid office, can confirm the scope and difficulty of the problem. Employees, especially lower income employees, have really limited access to the legal system; it's even worse with more vulnerable populations (immigrants, lower educated workers, etc.). Even basic stuff like employee stuff keeping their own independent hours records often doesn't happen. It's really a problem in places like farm labor.
- ed_balls 8y agoI guess the problem is US doesn't have an employment like most European countries.
- ed_balls 8y agoI meant employment tribunal.
- Eridrus 8y agoIs there a way tech can help in this space? Many people complain about the fact that Google has a record of where you go if you opt in to location tracking, but people should be able to extract this record to get an automated working time estimate without needing to do do anything to prepare ahead of time, if they have an Android phone and haven't disabled the tracking. I'm not sure about the completeness/time accuracy of the logged data, but maybe you could weigh in on the presumed legal validity of such an approach?
- zitterbewegung 8y agoLocation tracking on phones is not nearly as a clean data source as it may seem. For example when you use GPS in a large city tour location can get confused . So your tracking data is rather rough.
- Eridrus 8y agoWhen I look at the Location History Google has on me for my time at work it's pretty accurate, which is unsurprising since it is in a single fixed location and involves a fusion of not just GPS, but also Accelerometer and WiFi data. It's entirely possible that is less accurate for others, but it's a source of data that many people in this situation should already have, so you can use it for those for whom it is more accurate, and ignore it for others.
- jrs95 8y agoMore regulation around wage theft & mandatory overtime or limits on hours worked could really benefit tech workers as well. I for one would really like overtime over 50 hours to be mandatory, at the very least. It's just not sustainable or healthy to be working 60+ hour weeks and not taking any vacation because that would result in critical work not being done quickly enough for management to be satisfied. Clearly, what I'm describing is a pretty shitty job as far as tech goes, but I have a feeling I am far from alone in being in this situation.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoRun for office, and failing that, get involved with your representatives and vote for those that support strengthening labor’s position.
- 49531 8y agoThere are ways to strengthen labor outside of running of office. If you work in a corporation you can begin to organize your co workers. If you can't do that, you can get involved with local organizations and help others organize their workplaces. It takes a lot of effort to organize and there's a lot of room for volunteers.
- 49531 8y agoHonestly over 40 hours should be OT. I feel like a lot of tech workers feel like they have cush jobs which will become less liberal if they start drawing lines in the sand. Our labor is early in its commodification though. As we become less unique we will be easier to exploit. Organizing now isn't a bad idea.
- namibj 8y agoIn Germany, there is criminal liability if your subordinates (if you are making their schedules, or would be the one to tell them to go home) work over an average of 8h/workday (only those in the contract count, if none specified, courts said to assume 5 work days), or a top of 10h/shift. Except for a very few select industries, you also need at least iirc 11h off between two shifts, but there are some ways/loopholes around this one. Any overage over the 8h average has to be evened out within usually 3 months, unless something else is in the contract (and as with German law, if the contract is evil, i.e. "sittenwiedrig", it, or at least the relevant portions, is/are void). This does mean that you might not get another job if you speak up, as always, but it does mean that if you are willing to change industries, your superior faces criminal charges. Combined with the neglegible risk of not being able to feed your family, due to the vast social support net, you are actually able to stand by your principles, if you do care.
- roenxi 8y agoWe'd rather that companies were honest, and yes the law should be enforced fairly and as on the books to keep the playing field for corporations level. But no, wage theft isn't a bigger problem than other theft. Yes, wage theft is bigger numerically. But a reduction in wage theft is going to be mirrored by a drop in the amount of wealth available. By definition, the same or less work is being done for a higher cost; so by examining the net situation, someone is going to have less actual stuff (and I can say with confidence, it is not going to be the rich who do without). Increasing the cost of labour will put people out of work. Wage theft is one of those victimless crimes where both parties have agreed that a situation is the best alternative and the government is declaring that they are wrong. It is a lot more delicate than, say, gay marriage, because all workers would prefer to have more money, and by far most workers would be happier if they didn't have to work. But, end of the day, just because the government says a worker is entitled doesn't mean the worker is truly unhappy with what they get. In an extreme case, I've worked in situations where I have been subject to wage theft (~10% lower compensation than I should have legally been getting), and I tried to keep that off anyone's radar because I wouldn't have had a job otherwise and I was being paid plenty. Workers take the best option they have; possibly making that option uneconomic is not a good idea. This is not how, eg, China, is lifting people out of poverty.
- 49531 8y ago> reduction in wage theft is going to be mirrored by a drop in the amount of wealth available. In a situation where wage theft is happening and then it stops happening, the money doesn't get thrown in a garbage bin. The stolen money goes to the worker rather than the employer. If I got paid my average hourly rate for 10 unpaid hours per week, I'd make roughly $12,000 more per year than I do now. $12,000 which would go towards my student loans, or a down payment for a house, or just buying random shit. Instead that $12,000 goes to the corporation I work for. You might argue that they can do that to 10 people and afford to hire another engineer, which is great, except now we have a corporation who is subsidized by unpaid labor, not by being an effective corporation.
- pbecotte 8y agoSo your employer pays 48k for 50 hours a week of labor. Yes, if they suddenly paid you 60k instead you'd be doing better. But that doesn't mean they benefit from unpaid labor, just that the current rate is less than you think it is.
- greatamerican 8y agoThis is a movement I can get behind. Income taxes were unconstitutional for a reason.
- sykh 8y agoOne can not credibly equate income taxes to theft. We live in a society and it costs money for the society to function. Police, courts, roads, sewers, military, etc. require funds and everyone with the means to do so ought to contribute. I doubt anything I say can possibly change your mind but if you really think paying taxes is a form of theft then leave the country. You are not forced to stay (unless you are in a place like North Korea). You lose any credibility you have when you equate taxation to theft.
- samatman 8y agoYou switched mid paragraph from accurately discussing income tax to inaccurately generalizing to all tax. Please don’t do this.
- sykh 8y agoThe argument and points still stand. It’s hard to imagine that one can reasonably describe income taxes as theft but not other forms of taxation. I suppose one can call other sorts of taxes as pernicious or akin to theft but in the United States, at the federal level, I don’t think any of those sorts of taxes exist.
- kolbe 8y agoWage theft results in more money stolen each year than robberies. Wage theft is most definitely not a bigger problem. The deaths, bodily harm, trauma &c from robberies are many many times bigger problems than the money stolen in robberies. Edit: TIL only irate labor union trolls who have no ability to structure an argument, but will downvote/upvote brigade are in this comment section.
- Karishma1234 8y agoA lot of those "right to receive" exist because of government regulations and not because it is something employees or employers negotiated. What matters is whether someone out there is willing to replace you for lower price or not. Everything else is mostly virtue signalling.
- ve55 8y agoYou might be able to make a solid case that wage theft results in greater nominal amounts of theft than violent theft, but that doesn't mean it's a bigger problem as the title assumes. The reason we are so hard on violent criminals isn't because they stole a small amount of money or property, it's because of the violence part. We place a lot of value on human life and safety, and when there's a notable probability of someone being stabbed or shot, things get significantly worse. Wage theft may result in some bad problems as well, but I can't imagine it leads to more people being stabbed or shot.
- 49531 8y agoTheft isn't inherently tied to violence. It's easy to think of someone breaking into your home with a ski mask on, instead of embezzlement or pirating software. I would argue that wage theft is a bigger problem in the sense that the scope is so much larger. This article brings up wage theft amounts in _recovered_ wages and it still trumps regular theft. I'd guess a lot of people on this thread have experienced wage theft, I know I have. Would I rather a corporation steal $12,000 from me every year, or a burglar break into my home and steal my shit? I know I wouldn't pay $12,000 for a security system for my house.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dlp211 8y agoMore importantly, you can insure yourself against burglary, you can't insure yourself against wage theft.
- awat 8y agoOne of my favorite quotes I’ve mentioned on HN a few times applies here. It’s only a crime if it occurs on the street level anything above that and it’s called politics.
- ddingus 8y agoNice. Lucid too.
- jeffdavis 8y agoThey are very different concepts. The IRS is legally entitled to your money, but it's not "theft" if you don't pay it.
- jacob019 8y agoAs a small business owner I was expecting to read about employees padding hours, like clocking in during breaks or having a friend clock them in early. It's shocking that people would abuse their employees and that people put up with it.
- 49531 8y agoIn my experience small business owners commit wage theft the most. I've worked +80hrs/week for some small companies while only billing 40hrs because I was unskilled in an area with high unemployment. When your back is against the wall you compromise.
- astura 8y agoFYI, the term "wage theft" has a standard definition: employers stealing from employees. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wage_theft https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wage_theft
- detcader 8y ago> that people put up with it. This implies everyone has a choice, no? When employees changing jobs or getting legal assistance isn't easy is exactly when owners do these sorts of things -- it is understood and incentivized
- s73v3r_ 8y ago"Choice" implies that they are just fine with doing it. More often than not, the victims think that they don't have any recourse, that they can't afford a lawyer or the time away from the new job to take care of it.
- MisterBastahrd 8y agoShocking that they would abuse their employees? Most employees who work paycheck to paycheck are happy to just have a job most of the time and really can't afford to lose one. The most vulnerable people are always the easiest to abuse. There are various considerations here beyond actual pay. What happens when a person making low wages finds a steady job with regular hours? It means they probably don't have to figure out how to shuttle their kids between multiple daycares / babysitters. These go on and on. I know a person who made 9 an hour at a convenience store. Bad hours. Variable shifts. She got an offer to work for a non-profit hospital. Makes 13 an hour now with a set schedule (sorta), but lost her $500 a month SNAP benefits AND about $300 a month in daycare costs. If she gets a raise, she'll lose healthcare benefits for her kids, so her healthcare will essentially double (before any rate increases). She's proud to be making more money even though it's a net negative for her, and her employer has asked her regularly to cover other positions that get out later without getting extra pay. She would rather pick up the free hour here and there than have to deal with the hassle of going back to shift work. It's not like you can walk into the police office and tell the officer that your boss isn't paying you to work extra hours, and even if you did, other businesses would quickly decide that it wasn't worth hiring an employee who wanted to make what they agreed to work for.
- bmmayer1 8y agoRepeating a point that keeps getting downvoted for unclear reasons: "Wage theft" is an effective euphemism that misses the nuance of what's happening here. Not paying wages according to the letter of the law is not the same as stealing money from people, and employers, like most people who cheat on regulations, often can't or won't shoulder the extra cost if those regulations are suddenly enforced, and will cut hours or people instead. Workers are certainly being shafted but probably not anywhere near to the extent in reality as is being presented here in theory. In any event, it's very different problem than property theft and shouldn't be compared as such.
- tomtimtall 8y agoSo a bank robber should not be compared with other property theft if he declares that he would have burned down the entire bank if he hadn’t been able to steel the money? Theft is theft, even if you have other relationships with the thief that might be endangered by enforcing the letter of the law.
- 49531 8y agoJust because the act of theft happens under the veneer of corporate bureaucracy doesn't mean it isn't theft. The money goes somewhere, and if it isn't to the workers then it is to the employer. You're right that corporations won't follow regulations that aren't enforced, which is why workers need to be informed of their rights, given legal counsel, educated and enabled to organize.
- crdoconnor 8y ago>will cut hours or people instead. This is the exact same fallacious "threat" used against minimum wage hikes. I'm reality the employees don't get fired or have their hours cut (c.f. dube, Lester, Reich). Profit margins take the vast majority of the hit instead (c.f. draca, Machin, reenen).
- pharrington 8y agoYou're talking about violation of contract. A potential employee often can't, or won't take a job if the compensation suddenly wasn't that which was agreed to when accepting the job. If you have figures that contradict those presented in the linked page, please present them.
- Kloe_Devan 8y agoTODAY LOAN @ 2% INTEREST RATE with victoriafinancier@outlook.com I search for how to get loan online because my bank could not offer me the amount i need to start my business, get a home and have a better life. So, i found VICTORIA FINANCIER FIRM who help so many family and individuals with loan without delay. I contact her immediately and she helped me with loan @ 2% Interest Rate without any collateral. To get your loan without stress or delay, I will advice you to contact Victoria Financier Firm today Via Email ( Victoriafinancier@outlook.com) or quick massage to 774-214-9663
- stcredzero 8y agoIt's easy for any employer to steal several thousand dollars from an employee they are letting go. It will cost several thousand dollars to sue the employer, and no lawyer wants to work hard for so little to gain. So employers cheat employees of their last paycheck all the time, and almost never get sued for it.
- VHRanger 8y ago... you don't need a lawyer for that. In most cases it's a small claims and the company defending itself will not be worthwhile in legal and PR costs. You literally just need to shoot an email saying you're taking them to court and often enough you're getting your money
- astura 8y agoIn most cases you can just file a wage claim: https://www.dir.ca.gov/dlse/HowToFileWageClaim.htm https://www.dir.ca.gov/dlse/HowToFileWageClaim.htm (For California)
- gremlinsinc 8y agoThis doesn't just happen for low-wage jobs. I joined a dev team on March 8th. By March 21st, I learned that nobody has been paid in 2 months. Around that same day, the CEO went to jail for writing bad checks. All other employees quit that same day. I stayed on after CEO got out-- hoping the client who has been supposed to pay would pay. I was also offered 20k raise + moved to President of Software Development. I was hoping I could temper the CEO's risk factors and keep the business going and maybe get a paycheck, and help get the people who quit paid as well for their previous work. I worked feverishly 100+hours per week to deliver updates... (keeping some of the IP on my own box --it only modified data, I'd run it locally then just export the data to mysql.) I've still not been paid, I've filed wage claims, and still nothing. I've since told the CEO and client, until I get paid nothing else happens. Has any other developer experienced anything like this? It's so frustrating especially since I'm about to be homeless as a result... I'm owed like nearly 20k in back pay.
- fourneau 8y agoI'm... curious. What motivated you to stay?
- gremlinsinc 8y agoI've been hovering in intermediate/mid-level jobs, around 60-70k/year, the chance at 90k + 10% of the company and to be a manager of other devs, was tempting to at least take a chance. -- Time's run out though. I've told my boss if I'm not paid this week, I'm going public and running sending his name/company name to the state attorney general (Utah), I'm contacting the FTC, as well as cc processor, and attorney general on behalf of the client as well (it's MLM so already somewhat shady in my book.). I used to do SEO before becoming a dev full-time in 2012, I can make it so no other developer ever works for this guy again. My hope while it'll feel good to get revenge, is that I truly save other devs from going through this...it's one of the most horrible things I've ever experienced professionally.
- perhapsolt 8y agoYup stories like this get reported on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17202338 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17202338
- nimish 8y agoMan if only there was a mechanism where workers could bind together to increase their bargaining power. Except Americans have been indoctrinated for decades that unions=bad. This is the result. And guess what? Mandatory arbitration robs you of any judicial remedies.
- firefoxd 8y agoOne thing that was common when i worked in retail was if you worked overtime without pre-approval from your manager, you won't get paid for those hours. The one guy that complained was fired publicly for being lazy. No one else took the risk.