11 ms·
Some of the discussion is reasonable, but I really dislike the reliance on "Figure 4: Expected Lifetime Earnings by Educational Attainment". Certainly there is
by nkurz 16y ago
Some of the discussion is reasonable, but I really dislike the reliance on "Figure 4: Expected Lifetime Earnings by Educational Attainment". Certainly there is a correlation here, but is there causation?
"But as you can see from the chart above, $1 million is close to the lifetime value of a college degree (it's actually about $1.4 million), and colleges are getting better at extracting quite a lot of that value for themselves."
To prove the point, you could make a parallel chart of "Lifetime Earnings by Car Driven", and I'm sure that the BMW owners would on average earn more over their lifetime than the Honda Civic drivers (like me). But this wouldn't imply this is a good pricing model for cars.
Obviously, the actual chart used is better than this hypothetical. But shouldn't one at least try to distinguish the value of the degree from the skills that the person already had going in?
- argv_empty 16y agoSome of the discussion is reasonable, but I really dislike the reliance on "Figure 4: Expected Lifetime Earnings by Educational Attainment". Certainly there is a correlation here, but is there causation? Not demonstrated, but certainly plausible, since the different education levels seem to point towards different career paths.
- pessimizer 16y agoI think you'd see quite different figures if Figure 4 had been controlled by parental income (or even by total blue book value of parental household automobiles.) I always find it troubling when people find two events co-occurring and assume it's a causal relationship, particularly when both things are clearly possibly related to class.