2 ms·
Neither of the things I mentioned are a genuine improvement to anyone’s situation, yet they would fix this metric. It’s great that the lowest end of the income
by closeparen 8y ago
Neither of the things I mentioned are a genuine improvement to anyone’s situation, yet they would fix this metric.
It’s great that the lowest end of the income distribution still has enough resources to have children. It would help no one to reduce productivity.
The metric is probably not the right way of thinking about this problem.
- taeric 8y agoThey wouldn't, was my point. One actively works against it through feedback systems. Having kids typically lowers your income. The other isn't actually doable. Is the metric perfect? No. But neither is attacking it in ways that it can't be attacked. Do you have alternatives? What are they?
- closeparen 8y agoFood security, nutrition, housing stability, rent burden, medical and dental care, K12 institutions that meet standards, college affordability, etc. Essentially anything focused on objective conditions instead of relative positioning. The upper half of a country’s income distribution can absolutely be more or less productive compared to another time or another place. How would you go about it? Defunding education and research and starting a trade war would be great first steps.
- taeric 8y agoI would wager that all of those correlate so heavily to wealth bracket that it would be a wash. And a surprise for you. That is, wealth is a proxy for all of those measures. And every attempt at fixing those measures has ended poorly. At best.
- closeparen 8y agoIt looks like 8% of children are food insecure, for example. That’s awful but we’re also a lot further along than the 20% figure in TFA.
- taeric 8y agoIs this just a contest to look good? Yes, we have made great progress. I actually think we should celebrate more of it. Some metrics do give pause for concern, though. Long before they give pause for alarm.