3 ms·
> "20 percent of US children live in families with incomes below 50 percent of the national median income" This is a bizarre metric. If richer families started
by closeparen 8y ago
> "20 percent of US children live in families with incomes below 50 percent of the national median income"
This is a bizarre metric. If richer families started having children at a higher rate, or poorer families slowed down, the problem would be fixed?
What if we simply cut the pay of the upper 50%, not even redistributing the income? That would lower median income, and therefore shrink the "less than 50% of median income" demographic, "solving" child poverty.
- golergka 8y ago> If richer families started having children at a higher rate, or poorer families slowed down, the problem would be fixed? This does sound like a great idea.
- taeric 8y agoWell, yes, if richer families started having children at a higher rate, this would almost fix itself. Two major problems, though. a) By and large, rich people don't have more children and b) having a child is a good way to destroy your wealth. That is, many that are just barely in the "rich" category won't be once they have children. More, most wealth in the US does not survive generations. (And this is generally agreed to be a good thing, I believe.) For the second, ok. Cut the pay. How? That sort of suggestion is literally "wishful thinking." If everyone could get by with less money, everyone would. Folks do grab for the advantages they can get, though, and most rise in costs and pay are ascribable to scarcity. Only wishful thinking will make housing and energy costs flat across the board. Same for social mobility. Or physical mobility.
- anonymouskimmer 8y ago"b) having a child is a good way to destroy your wealth." I'd like to see a comparison between childless families and families with children, economic starting point held constant. There is the fatherhood bonus and motherhood penalty after all.
- taeric 8y agoWould census data be a good place to mine for this? I confess I was basing my assertion pretty much purely on seeing how much child births cost. I do not condemn the rise in hospital births. I am worried at seeing how much it costs. And that is for births that presented no complications.
- closeparen 8y agoNeither of the things I mentioned are a genuine improvement to anyone’s situation, yet they would fix this metric. It’s great that the lowest end of the income distribution still has enough resources to have children. It would help no one to reduce productivity. The metric is probably not the right way of thinking about this problem.
- taeric 8y agoThey wouldn't, was my point. One actively works against it through feedback systems. Having kids typically lowers your income. The other isn't actually doable. Is the metric perfect? No. But neither is attacking it in ways that it can't be attacked. Do you have alternatives? What are they?
- closeparen 8y agoFood security, nutrition, housing stability, rent burden, medical and dental care, K12 institutions that meet standards, college affordability, etc. Essentially anything focused on objective conditions instead of relative positioning. The upper half of a country’s income distribution can absolutely be more or less productive compared to another time or another place. How would you go about it? Defunding education and research and starting a trade war would be great first steps.
- taeric 8y agoI would wager that all of those correlate so heavily to wealth bracket that it would be a wash. And a surprise for you. That is, wealth is a proxy for all of those measures. And every attempt at fixing those measures has ended poorly. At best.
- closeparen 8y agoIt looks like 8% of children are food insecure, for example. That’s awful but we’re also a lot further along than the 20% figure in TFA.
- anonymouskimmer 8y agoIt's bizarre because it's not parent age adjusted and number of parents adjusted. If only 20% of children are members of age-adjusted & number of parents adjusted families with income in the bottom half then that means that the bottom half of families are being slowly genocided through the cost to have and raise a child. But we have no way of knowing that from the national median income statistic.
- walshemj 8y agoI thought poor families had more kids
- Simon_says 8y agoPoor individuals are less likely to get married or have any kids.