3 ms·
Since you don’t give verifiable links to examples so we can judge for ourselves, and your reported experiences don’t match the majority’s, the rest of us are mo
by teddyh 8y ago
Since you don’t give verifiable links to examples so we can judge for ourselves, and your reported experiences don’t match the majority’s, the rest of us are more or less forced to believe the simplest explanation:
There’s a known principle that goes “If you think that everyone around you is an asshole, they’re not the assholes, you are.”. This would be the simplest explanation in this case, since we don’t know anything else about you.
Of course, you could easily remedy this by posting enough examples to change our minds, but until you do, Occam’s razor must reign supreme.
- detaro 8y agoOr they were just unlucky in their in their interactions (I doubt many people would claim that all interactions in Open Source are good), or perceive some things differently than others, or ... there's more than enough Open-Source maintainers complaining about bad interactions. Indeed many of the parents complaints are also reflected in the study as things people experienced as barriers to contributing. Luckily for many of them the good outweighs the bad, but that doesn't mean those for which it doesn't are automatically assholes. It's especially bad to justify this broad brush with "minority experience".
- teddyh 8y agoSure, there are many possible explanations, but what I wrote was the most likely one.
- KirinDave 8y agoNothing I can do can change the outcome either way, teddyh. I suspect you've already decided how you feel about me. People are seeing a candid discussion of subjective experience as an indictment of theirs. This is another action I regret. I thought perhaps a related but dissenting viewpoint would have value to the conversation, but I guess not. This conversation itself is an example of the kind of negative experience I'm talking about. I'm sorry my post offended you. It wasn't my intent.
- teddyh 8y ago> Nothing I can do can change the outcome either way, teddyh. On the contrary, I told you exactly how to change my mind (and that of others): Point to examples that we can read for ourselves and decide that yes, you really were treated badly in all these cases. That really would change minds. > I suspect you've already decided how you feel about me. Again, you are mistaken. You are just some random anonymous person on the internet; you could very well be an asshole; what do I know? But if that is the most likely explanation of your reported experience, then sure, why not. I can easily use that as a working hypotheses, because I have no vested interest in having a good opinion about you; I don’t care about you at all; I don’t even know you, so I have no strong opinion about you. I do care about people reading your description and (even though you were careful enough to not do so yourself) generalizing your experiences to the whole of the community, and being discouraged thereby. You must understand that when you write something along the lines of “I had only bad experiences doing X, and I wish I could travel back in time to tell myself to not ever do X.”, it will be taken as a generalized advice to everyone, and be more or less rightly criticized as if it were such. If you instead had written about the same experiences using words like “People can have bad experiences too; I only had bad experiences doing X, and therefore I gave it up. Was I just unlucky?”, I believe that people would be much more open to either agree or disagree. But that is not how you presented it. > I'm sorry my post offended you. It wasn't my intent. Not offended. Just worried that people might draw unlikely conclusions from your limited sample of experiences (especially when the submitted article is an actual scientific paper about this very issue).
- KirinDave 8y ago> On the contrary, I told you exactly how to change my mind (and that of others): Point to examples that we can read for ourselves and decide that yes, you really were treated badly in all these cases. That really would change minds. Consider for a moment what you're asking me to do: name names. In several cases, for events over 5 years old. You're asking me to expose myself to more contention and argument to convince you that my feelings are not dirty lies that slander the OSS community. The most respectful thing I can do for all parties is relate my experiences. If you find them to be so outrageously implausible that you feel the need to call me an asshole, there's not much I am willing to do that will change that. You're right, I could link to examples of people behaving badly (and inevitably, cases where I have behaved badly because those exist). But there is very little upside in that for me. Like I said, this demand predetermines the outcome. It asks me to shoulder more commentary like this for the dubious promise of your personal approval. That's not a very compelling value proposition. Add to that that your tone disinclines me to believe you're actually asking in good faith, and I have absolutely no reason at all to reopen these topics.
- hobs 8y agoIf you find yourself feeling the need to call someone an asshole and require evidence of someone else's personal experiences, consider that leaving well enough alone is the right approach. Especially when that person is politely reporting experiences with behavior that from my eyes, resembles yours exactly.