7 ms·
>Somewhere between 438,000 and 720,000 people were killed by the parasite in 2015. Seventy-two percent of those were kids younger than 5, Sub Saharan Africa ha
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 8y ago
>Somewhere between 438,000 and 720,000 people were killed by the parasite in 2015. Seventy-two percent of those were kids younger than 5,
Sub Saharan Africa has a population of roughly 1 billion people. So this is about 1/2000 of the population that die every year from malaria. If this was happening in the US, say 150,000 people a year were dying from malaria every year, including 100,000 children, do you really think there would be this huge debate about wiping out these malaria species using CRISPR?
Wiping out disease carrying mosquitoes would be one of the best things that could be done for global health. It would disproportionately benefit poor countries in general and children in particular. It is a shame that we as humanity are not making an all out push to eliminate these disease carrying mosquitoes.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- scarmig 8y agoMoral thought experiment: Most scientists are attempting to build a public consensus around using gene drives as a public health measure. It might be possible, though, for a single rogue scientist to introduce a self sustaining gene drive that could eliminate malaria, without seeking permission from any people, governments, or organizations. If you could do it, would you?
- delbel 8y agoSome psychopath or group of psychopaths have already done this. If you try to research the disease, it goes into conspiracy land full of junk information so much that you won't be able to determine if the disease exists or not, by modifying the signal to noise ratio of useful information vs junk. Google Morgellions disease, you can't tell if its real or not. (I can't tell either) This is a purposeful psy-op campaign used by intelligence agencies called "poisoning the well". so this is a double-tap campaign: introduce a crazy disease, and increase fear/doubt/uncertainty about the science around it so people can't figure out if it is real or not.
- maxerickson 8y agoI think it's difficult to weigh that sort of question without actually being the scientist in possession of the technology, believing it is safe and will be effective. History probably gets written based more on whether it works out than on whether the decision was really morally sound based on what they knew about the safety.
- ALittleLight 8y agoWould you need to believe it's effective, or just safe? I think as long as you have justifiable high confidence in safety then you should take a shot even if it may not be perfectly effective, or might fail entirely.
- craftyguy 8y agoIf you don't believe it's effective, then why bother wasting any time on it? Water is safe, but not effective at treating malaria, so why aren't scientists spraying water on people with malaria? Exactly.
- ALittleLight 8y agoIf you think it's 30% likely to work and 99.9% likely safe, you're in the case where you believe it's safe and you don't believe it will be effective (different from believing it will not be effective). I'd suggest this may be a good risk, depending on how unsafe it would be in the worst case.
- jpalomaki 8y agoA bit like computer worm that disinfects routers taken over by malicious botnets.
- posterboy 8y agoThe question is paradox, if wanting to do so is prerequisite to becoming able to do so. Secondly, the knowledge required to do so is prerequisite to determine some of the consequences. Third: other details outside of the specific field can only be understood by a larger group, so acting rogue would be flying blind. Specifically, I'm implying effects on the ecosystem, about which I at least have little idea.
- maxerickson 8y agoThe malaria that infects humans is only transmitted among humans so the ecosystem effects are fairly predictable and limited to the change in environmental impact attributable to the human populations currently impacted by malaria. Prosperity tends to lead to both environmentalism and consumption, so the impacts will likely be a mix of positive and negative.
- posterboy 8y agoThis doesn't target the pathogen, but the mosquitoes transmitting it. So the ecosystem effects are fairly different from those you implied. Although, I wouldn't know what those effects might be either way. To answer the GP more concretely: It is far easier for me to ignore the crisis far away than to risk the tiniest chance of problems close by. Yes, that's deplorable.
- petters 8y ago> If you could do it, would you? I think so. If I were really rich, I would seriously look into this and try to recruit scientists. Hard to say if I would actually do it since I would need to gather information first.
- Roritharr 8y agoWhat laws would you break, if any?
- kpil 8y agoI would. There are thousands of other species of mosquitos. I don't think there would be any noticeable consequences at all after a while.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- petre 8y agoYou bet I would. I can't believe there is even a debate about this. I even have a friend who's father died of malaria.
- strictnein 8y agoThere was a radio play (from ~20-25 years ago), where this is more or less the plot. Scientists find a cure to violence and unleash it on the world. It was a chemical that makes everyone friendly. But what they didn't figure out was that it also makes you really stupid. So the scientists avoid the rain (because that's what transmits it), but after a while they all give into being stupid.
- TangoTrotFox 8y agoThe content of the article and the title of the article are in contradiction. Like the article mentions this likely would not eliminate malaria. You'd need a reproductive release and at that point nature kicks in with all the unforeseen consequences that entails, including resistance ultimately creating a 'super malaria.' And that really is the fundamental problem. We have a pretty bad track record with genetic engineering stuff. For instance one of the early selling point of genetically engineered crops is that it would mean we could reduce usage of herbicides. Glyphosate in particular is a very powerful herbicide that killed everything except what was engineered to be resistant to it. So get your glyphosate resistant crops, spray just a little bit, and you're set. And it worked great. Until it didn't. Of course nature kicked in and invasive weeds started evolving natural resistance to the compound leading farmers to pour more and more of the stuff on their crops to try to kill them off - a cycle that continues to this day [1] with no end in sight. Needless to say, our total herbicide usage has skyrocketed from something that was supposed to dramatically reduce it. Citronella, bed nets, and if you're feeling real frisky - the introduction of natural predators seems perhaps more reasonable. [1] - https://enveurope.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/s12302-016-0070-0 https://enveurope.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/s12302-0...