5 ms·

GitHub clearly needs change of management. I havent seen much inmovation from them compared to GitLab. Microsoft is very strong on innovation since change of ma

by yani 8y ago

GitHub clearly needs change of management. I havent seen much inmovation from them compared to GitLab. Microsoft is very strong on innovation since change of management.

mwj 8y ago
Depends what you like. I prefer my Git hosting suppliers to have better than 50% uptime.
- pritambaral 8y ago
  User of both GitLab and GitHub here. GitHub also goes down.
spacenick88 8y ago
I'm not super familiar with GitLab besides self hosted instances. Even then I prefer the simplicity of gogs. So what do you feel are still be innovations GitLab has but GitHub lacks?
- matteeyah 8y ago
  We have a comparison page for GitLab Premium and GHE - https://about.gitlab.com/comparison/gitlab-eep-vs-github-enterprise.html#dropdown https://about.gitlab.com/comparison/gitlab-eep-vs-github-ent... Most features have a link to their respective documentation for more information.
jaredklewis 8y ago
GitHub is easy to use, and I’ve found the important features work really well. I’m all for improvements, but I’m not even sure what I would want. At this point, I’m more worried any attempt at innovation would break the things I like about GitHub now, than I am excited for something new. I use gitlab for all my private projects and don’t find it to be remarkably better in any way, and the UI always confuses me.
- matteeyah 8y ago
  Any way we can improve the UI? We'd love to make it more enjoyable. You can also open an issue directly in https://gitlab.com/gitlab-org/gitlab-ce/issues https://gitlab.com/gitlab-org/gitlab-ce/issues
  - jaredklewis 8y ago
    Well, my only request would be that it be more like GitHub. The only reason for this is familiarity. GitHub is the market leader now and I use it every day at work. It's a lot easier to get used to a new UI if it is similar to the one you are used to. I'm sure if everyone used GitLab at work everyday, it would be fine. The UI doesn't strike me as bad, just very different.
h1d 8y ago
Otoh, GitLanpb seems to have a messy code that is slow and taking much memory by slapping new stuff in frequently. (My impression from reading several comments on HN.)
- dsumenkovic 8y ago
  Our team is actively working on improving the performance of GitLab.com. If you are referring to the merge requests, we're close to converting the merge request view to Vue, this should speed it up considerably.

by yani 8y ago

GitHub clearly needs change of management. I havent seen much inmovation from them compared to GitLab. Microsoft is very strong on innovation since change of management.

mwj 8y ago

Depends what you like. I prefer my Git hosting suppliers to have better than 50% uptime.

pritambaral 8y ago
User of both GitLab and GitHub here. GitHub also goes down.

spacenick88 8y ago

I'm not super familiar with GitLab besides self hosted instances. Even then I prefer the simplicity of gogs. So what do you feel are still be innovations GitLab has but GitHub lacks?

matteeyah 8y ago
We have a comparison page for GitLab Premium and GHE - https://about.gitlab.com/comparison/gitlab-eep-vs-github-enterprise.html#dropdown https://about.gitlab.com/comparison/gitlab-eep-vs-github-ent... Most features have a link to their respective documentation for more information.

jaredklewis 8y ago

GitHub is easy to use, and I’ve found the important features work really well. I’m all for improvements, but I’m not even sure what I would want. At this point, I’m more worried any attempt at innovation would break the things I like about GitHub now, than I am excited for something new. I use gitlab for all my private projects and don’t find it to be remarkably better in any way, and the UI always confuses me.

matteeyah 8y ago
Any way we can improve the UI? We'd love to make it more enjoyable. You can also open an issue directly in https://gitlab.com/gitlab-org/gitlab-ce/issues https://gitlab.com/gitlab-org/gitlab-ce/issues
- jaredklewis 8y ago
  Well, my only request would be that it be more like GitHub. The only reason for this is familiarity. GitHub is the market leader now and I use it every day at work. It's a lot easier to get used to a new UI if it is similar to the one you are used to. I'm sure if everyone used GitLab at work everyday, it would be fine. The UI doesn't strike me as bad, just very different.

h1d 8y ago

Otoh, GitLanpb seems to have a messy code that is slow and taking much memory by slapping new stuff in frequently. (My impression from reading several comments on HN.)

dsumenkovic 8y ago
Our team is actively working on improving the performance of GitLab.com. If you are referring to the merge requests, we're close to converting the merge request view to Vue, this should speed it up considerably.