3 ms·
Here's a classic problem for utilitarianism: You are a doctor. You have four patients. Three are young men in otherwise good health who need an organ or they w
by emodendroket 8y ago
Here's a classic problem for utilitarianism:
You are a doctor. You have four patients. Three are young men in otherwise good health who need an organ or they will die very soon -- two of them need kidneys and one of them needs a heart. Your fourth patient is a homeless person who's broken his leg but is otherwise well. You know for a fact he has no friends or family who will notice he is gone, and that nobody will know it if you kill him. Under a strict utilitarian framework, it is not only permissible but actually mandatory that you kill this man and harvest his organs to maximize utility.
Another popular one is a variant on the trolley problem. Most people feel it is morally permissible to change the switch on the train tracks to go toward the side with fewer people, even though it will lead to some people dying. Most people do not feel it is permissible to push someone (say in a car) in front of the train in order that they may stop the train while being killed in the process.
There are others of this genre but you probably get the basic idea. Utilitarianism can lead to plainly monstrous conclusions. I'm suspicious of any "formula" to solve all ethical problems.
- perl4ever 8y agoI don't think "utilitarianism" incorporates any principle that homeless people are worthless. Really, depending on how you define utility, it can be molded into anything. Note that harvesting organs means he will definitely die, but the organ transplants may fail, or may only work for a limited time. It could be rather than assuming "two lives saved minus one life lost" you should use "probability/quality adjusted years of life gained". And incorporate uncertainty. Also, in your example of pushing someone in front of the train, wouldn't your moral intuition depend on the stakes? Suppose that the train not being stopped was going to set off a chain reaction that would kill all life on earth?
- emodendroket 8y agoWho said it did? The point is that saving multiple lives produces greater utility than allowing one person to live, so if utility is your only consideration it is fine to murder people to save lives. The point of making the donor homeless and a loner is just to remove objections about how eventually someone is going to notice nobody is paying the rent, or you'll make other people sad by killing him, or you'll reduce their trust in the medical system, or various other answers that sidestep the problem.
- davidivadavid 8y ago"The point is that saving multiple lives produces greater utility than allowing one person to live, so if utility is your only consideration it is fine to murder people to save lives." That depends on what utility function you're using.
- emodendroket 8y agoI can't think of one that avoids this problem. Can you?
- perl4ever 8y agoI did throw out "probability/quality adjusted years of life gained" to address the obviously grossly inadequate metric of counting "lives gained/lost".
- emodendroket 8y agoThat can't really be it, can it? Then we just add patients who need a blood transfusion, two who need corneas, someone who needs a liver, and so on, until we're positive that the expected value of life is higher.
- perl4ever 8y agoThis seems to me kind of like saying if you pick an arbitrary number k, and an infinite sum from 1..n, there must be a point at which the sum is greater than k. But if the sum is finite, it may be less than k for any n. And if you're talking about real life, the total benefit is uncertain too. So I am not at all convinced that this kind of utilitarianism easily leads to decisions that we don't see in real life. I kind of think that society does use something like the measure of utility I described - we just don't talk about it a lot. For instance, doctors will refuse to do an operation on someone who is sufficiently old and frail. Courts will award less to an elderly victim of medical error. And so on. Edit/post script: Also, I think you implicitly are assuming that utility is one dimensional, and that you can add up quality of life changes and balance them against lives ended. That does not necessarily seem valid or essential to some form of utilitarianism.
- Vinnl 8y ago> I'm suspicious of any "formula" to solve all ethical problems. Right, I think that's what I'm mostly interested in - what if you treat utilitarianism as a guideline? If you only apply it in cases where you think most people would agree on what is "most useful", would that not lead to better decisions on average, without influencing potential hypothetical edge cases? (I also happen to think that the most useful thing in your situations is to respect the law, and have the law say that you're not allowed to exploit the homeless person, since that also influences the amount of trust we have in other people and hence the quality of life, but that's probably less relevant for what I'm interested in now.)
- emodendroket 8y agoIf utility is simply one factor of many then we're not doing utilitarianism. I don't think the law thing works at all. Laws can be and often are unjust. Imagine I live in a twisted society where the doctor killing patients to harvest organs is legal. Is it now ethical? This is not purely theoretical -- the people operating concentration camps in Germany weren't violating German law.