2 ms·
It's simpler than this: If you can obtain a nutrient from the environment, then the machinery to make it yourself breaking won't kill you. Same way mammals kee
by samatman 8y ago
It's simpler than this: If you can obtain a nutrient from the environment, then the machinery to make it yourself breaking won't kill you.
Same way mammals keep losing vitamin C synthesis when they settle on a diet that's rich in it.
This isn't "use it or lose it" this is just "lose it and don't die". Having the synth path is better, dying is worse.
- thaumasiotes 8y ago> Same way mammals keep losing vitamin C synthesis when they settle on a diet that's rich in it. This is a terrible example; all mammals eat a diet rich in vitamin C, but loss of the ability to synthesize it is quite rare, being restricted to some primates, some rodents, and most bats. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vitamin_C#Biosynthesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vitamin_C#Biosynthesis It was a breakthrough when scurvy was observed in guinea pigs in 1907. Before that time, it had never been observed outside of humans, though it is known in humans for most of recorded history.
- Retric 8y agoMost animal diets are not rich in vitamin C. Meat and leaves have minimal vitamin C for example. Humans evolved to conserve vitamin C and eat a much wider diet than most mammals. Without that deer for example might occasionally get enough Vitamin C, but would quickly get scurry at various times of the year.
- thaumasiotes 8y ago> Meat and leaves have minimal vitamin C for example. A human can eat nothing but fresh meat without suffering from scurvy. And in fact, a diet of fresh meat is sufficient to cure scurvy in a human already suffering from it. You could argue that humans conserve vitamin C better than lions do, but you can't argue that lions are eating a diet that is not rich enough in vitamin C to support an animal that can't synthesize its own. It's not an issue of the amount in the diet.