3 ms·
> I think the main problem is the single-winner election system itself, and even the best voting mathematics can do only very little to help that. They all will
by airstrike 8y ago
> I think the main problem is the single-winner election system itself, and even the best voting mathematics can do only very little to help that. They all will still lead to a two-party system.
Two-round elections in which a candidate that doesn't get 50%+1 in the first round must run against the runner-up (and no one else) in the second round is a significant improvement over the single-round First Past The Post structure in the U.S.
- pfranz 8y agoYou'd still need to combine that with getting rid of FPTP, you can look at California this election cycle for an example. The multiple Democratic candidates running against 2 Republican candidates might lead to 2 Republicans in the runoff even if way more Democrats turn out to vote. For the Democrats running dropping out is a prisoner's dilemma situation. It's giving people a bad opinion of that system.
- dragonwriter 8y agoThe California “jungle primary”effectively creates a new system—top-two/runoff—distinct from either form of FPTP, especially as usually practiced in the US where those follow a partisan primary.
- pfranz 8y agoI know I've seen some California elections have a 51% primary. I believe the Los Angeles Mayoral race was one. I wasn't sure if that applied to these jungle primaries or not since it's very doubtful anyone will get 51%. Either jungle or runoff system, with FPTP in place, seems to leave a bad taste in people's mouth when they see the top two in the same party. I think it's getting a lot more bad attention because the likely minority party has a good chance of getting the top two spots.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Two-round elections in which a candidate that doesn't get 50%+1 in the first round must run against the runner-up (and no one else) in the second round is a significant improvement over the single-round First Past The Post structure in the U.S. No, it's not. It's one of the two systems in the US that are both referred to a FPTP (the two are more specifically known as plurality and majority/runoff, and both forms are widely used in the US.)