7 ms·
To be fair they haven't screwed up LinkedIn. I think they will let GitHub grow with their resources.
by giancarlostoro 8y ago
To be fair they haven't screwed up LinkedIn. I think they will let GitHub grow with their resources.
- amag 8y agoLast I looked, Minecraft seemed to be quite in order as well.
- cm2187 8y agoShall we talk Nokia...
- jdgoesmarching 8y agoPre-Nadella tbf, who was opposed to the acquisition when Ballmer was CEO.
- KyeRussell 8y agoAgreed. Buying Nokia of all things stinks of Ballmer. I was listening to an interview where he seemingly took responsibility for the whole stuff up. Not sure how much weight that holds
- philliphaydon 8y agoBuying Nokia wasn’t the issue. Microsoft’s handling of Nokia was the issue. Microsoft is not good at making a physical product and releasing it to the world like Apple and Samsung. The fact many countries had to wait > 12 months to get the latest phone was retarded. Windows phone was awesome, but Microsoft screwed themselves by not doing minimum what it’s competitors were doing.
- bbatha 8y agoHuh? Microsoft has several very successful hardware product lines: peripherals (the Microsoft ergo keyboard is the gold standard in many circles), Xbox, the surface line. Maybe they can’t generate Apple hype but they do know how to make consumer hardware.
- philliphaydon 8y agoThe surface line isn’t avaliable world wide on release. Windows phones were released in like 3 markets. Less than surface line. Xbox gets world wide releases. Phones, people generally want what’s new. A 12-18 month old phone is not new.
- cm2187 8y agoI don’t think surface qualifies as good consumer hardware. It has been pleagued with driver problems and weird behaviour. But agree on periphericals and Xbox.
- chiph 8y agoI had the top-of-the-line Nokia Lumia 920 (designed just before the acquisition), and the plastic case was too soft and collected dents & scratches like crazy. The matte finish was also too slippery to hold onto (I ended up putting some skateboard tape on it). OTOH, I found the Windows Phone operating system to be highly responsive and I was able to navigate screens more quickly than the previous iPhone or the current Android I have. The problem was that as third-place in the market, few apps were available for it, and those that were weren't being maintained.
- trumped 8y agoIt got more bloated... My kids still use an old version to avoid that (they only play with each other so they don't need the latest version that is required to play on most servers online)
- sker 8y agoPlus I'm sure under Microsoft they will have some sort of free private repos like GitLab, Bitbucket and Visual Studio Team Services already do. Lack of free private repos is the main (only) reason why I don't use GitHub.
- scjr 8y agoWhat do you base this on?
- sker 8y ago1. They already have such offering (VS Team Services). 2. Their competitors (GitLab, Bitbucket) already have that offering. 3. I don't think they're interested in GitHub for its revenue, but for its strategic value. GitHub has to protect its revenue model by disallowing free private repos, Microsoft can afford to be more flexible. 4. They've already made similar moves. They acquired Xamarin, which was expensive, and made it free.
- Alupis 8y agoWhen did you last look at GitHub? They've had free private repos for well over a year (maybe longer). I have ~50 private on my account... Embarrassingly bad half-completed side projects mostly.
- TAForObvReasons 8y agoGitHub private repos are still $7/month, but available for free as part of the education discount
- scarface74 8y agoVSTS, Microsoft's hosted TFS solution, gives you unlimited private git repos for up to 5 users, 40 hours worth of hosted builds per month, complete project management, a private markdown based Wiki, and free orchestration of local build and deployment agents.
- 8y ago
- tomtheelder 8y agoIMO that's because LinkedIn wasn't a great product to begin with. It's just the stickiest app of all time. Something something network effects.
- throwaway5752 8y agoHow many projects are there out there that repositories hosted in GH, run in GH, and have package manifests that directly reference other GH repos. I'm sure there are a lot.
- notamy 8y agoMost of the golang ecosystem, I think. Not to mention any other language-specific package managers that support pulling from GitHub...
- throwaway5752 8y agoAnd I was thinking JS/npm, not even golang.
- giancarlostoro 8y agoGolang can be the biggest offender in this regard because you import by typing the URL to a github repository... Better hope someone mirrors those projects if they ever go poof. It's not even a generic import to a package[0]. Gotta be fun to have to update all those imports later if a project moves to another host to avoid Microsoft. [0]: https://godoc.org/github.com/lib/pq https://godoc.org/github.com/lib/pq
- spacenick88 8y agoWell that's the beauty of git, as long as anyone anywhere has a checkout of the Repository nothing will be lost. If tags are GPG signed you don't even have to put any trust in the surviveing source. That said for mantained code 99.9% of the time you would just use one of the core develops local copies.
- ballenf 8y agoI'd argue LinkedIn is much worse than it was pre-acquisition, but it was already on that trajectory. The "news feed" and discussions around current events, etc. They've locked down more and more of it without a $30/mo subscription. Privacy controls are a nightmare to decipher. I think it's significantly worse albeit probably short of totally "screwed up". Just marginally worse in a lot of small ways that add up to a less useful, less efficient experience for me.
- oculusthrift 8y agojust so you know, i know quite a few people at both linkedin and microsoft and for the most part they are still very seperate entities. linkedin is still using google docs and slack for instance. most of the influence microsoft has had on linkedin in smaller isolated integrations. so anything youve seen go downhill in linkedn consumer app is very much due to independent choices/acts by linkedin itself.
- jsjohnst 8y agoAs someone with lots of friends at LinkedIn (I used to work there), I can agree somewhat. But I also know that things can be screwed up in non-obvious ways to rank and file employees (Tumblr/Yahoo and Flickr/Yahoo as examples, which I sadly was there for both).
- nkkollaw 8y agoHow about Skype, though? People loved Skype so much, it was really a feat to make people hate it.
- brodock 8y agoThey had a decent Android app, then someone saw that it was too fast/responsive and was using too little memory and took that as a challenge, how can I make skype worst? React Native! Obviously that didn't pleased people (see rating in Play Store), and they had to provide something for low/mid range phones, and skype lite was born (which is really good one).
- flamemyst 8y agoHey, thanks for mentioning skype lite. That a mile better than skype .
- KyeRussell 8y agoThey undoubtedly did a bad job, but I think that Skype has a lot going against it from external factors anyway. Everyone I know is using FaceTime or Facebook Messenger. The only time I hear Skype anymore is people using it for podcasts. Obvious anecdata but it seems reasonable that services with better device integration (FaceTime) or social graph access (Facebook) would do better in the long run.
- sandov 8y agoOr google hangouts. It's skype but in the web and with an interface that actually works.
- discordance 8y agoMinus a few gigs of ram
- rapind 8y agoHangouts is a great example of another horrible UI. The whole tie in to Chrome made it unusable for anyone non technical (where did it go? What did you want me to click? I am in the call, but you're not there... oh you're in another call? How do you hangup? I don't see the window anymore, etc.) A standalone app would fix this, but there seems to be some strange internal agenda tying it to Chrome... Chromebooks I guess?
- katpas 8y agoLinkedIn was so screwed up I don't know what they could have done to make it worse.
- Chaebixi 8y ago> To be fair they haven't screwed up LinkedIn. I think they will let GitHub grow with their resources. I'm not sure if LinkedIn could be any less "screwed up" than it was when Microsoft bought it.
- 0xFFC 8y agoCan somebody explain to me why LinkedIn is screwed up? I am genuinely asking ;)
- mping 8y agoIt doesn't provide any value to the regular user; most people I know receive lots of emails mostly from body shops but rarely get a job from LinkedIn. The UI is designed to make it hard to configure privacy, and to make you casually spill your contact list. They are always trying to sell premium accounts. To be fair it should provide some value to a junior dev who doesnt have a Network yet but LinkedIn doesn't even try to hide the fact that you are the product (unlike say fb).
- rjtrickett 8y agoShameless plug here but I'm also so sick of LinkedIn that I've started building an alternative for developers by myself - https://able.bio/ https://able.bio/ Still very much alpha but the idea is to have a clean UI and allow developers to write their own insightful articles for the community to read and reward the author with reputation. Like Medium but with more specific language, library, framework topics etc. Then use that to help recruiters who can't code advertise and source candidates for technical interviews. No inbox spamming free for all, they can only contact you when you've applied for a position. I'd be interested to know what people think of this and if they have any feedback.
- sargun 8y agoSo, previously Microsoft used to have a program to integrate new companies, called “venture integrations”. I wonder if LinkedIn is going through VI, or not.
- sbr464 8y ago100% to the guy that said LinkedIn wasn’t a great product to begin with. X10
- bad_user 8y agoTo be fair, they did screw Skype.
- ori_b 8y agoThey didn't need to screw up linkedin -- they bought it that way.