2 ms·
The blanket example reminds me of all the handwringing about people "misusing" LLINs as a fishing aid, as though fighting malaria is more important than not sta
by gowld 8y ago
The blanket example reminds me of all the handwringing about people "misusing" LLINs as a fishing aid, as though fighting malaria is more important than not starving.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2532690/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2532690/
- DoreenMichele 8y agoThis study investigated the extent of bed net misuse in fishing villages. Wow. There is something incredibly fucked up about funding a study into bed net misuse rather than a study on the dire need for more help with meeting basic necessities like adequate nourishment as evidenced by so-called bed net misuse. Or, you know, the sarcastic reply: If you die of starvation, I guess you no longer need to worry about details like malaria.
- emodendroket 8y agoNo kidding. It's an illustration of a charity out of touch with the people it serves that you would call too overwrought if it appeared in a novel.
- samatman 8y agoThis seems like a good study that will save lives. Using malarial nets to dry fish means not using them to prevent malaria. Ok, good chance the answer is "give more nets". How are you supposed to know that without this study? The insecticides might also be fish poison, this could lead to a collapse of an important food source. A study like this could help surface that before it becomes a disaster.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoMy problem is not with them trying to determine what is being done with bed nets and why. My problem is with the framing. It is incredibly judgy and it is the kind of language that goes along with policies that boil down to "the beatings shall continue until morale improves." Such language tends to point to an agenda and to an underlying hostile attitude towards the population supposedly being served. I was homeless for a few years. A lot of homeless programs are actively hostile to homeless individuals. This helped sharpen my existing tendency to be critical of such details. If you think how it is framed doesn't matter, perhaps we can discuss some choice words for you or your profession or your demographic and see if you still think details of that ilk don't matter. Hint: When you say it matters if it is done to you, but it is irrelevant when done to some downtrodden group receiving "assistance" (often of the "Please stop helping me!" variety), then you are prejudiced and the existence of this prejudice out in the world is likely one of the root causes of the group in question being downtrodden and unable to make their lives work.