2 ms·
I'm not convinced of your conclusion as even though you started by presenting data you leap to a conclusion without a process inbetween. The assumptions in your
by zamadatix 8y ago
I'm not convinced of your conclusion as even though you started by presenting data you leap to a conclusion without a process inbetween. The assumptions in your final statements are:
- More than 50% of the energy source in EVs being renewable is irrelevant towards being environmentally friendly when being compared to 0% in conventional
- Renewable energy as a fraction of overall energy in California is not projected to rise in the next 5 years
- An EV using electrically from a powerplant has the same overall fuel efficiency as a conventional vehicle using fuel locally.
The first two are most assuredly false assumptions at a glance, the final one I'm not aware of. I'm not saying your conclusion is right or wrong just that I don't buy we need 100% renewable electricity for EVs to make environmental sense.
- Brakenshire 8y agoHe also doesn't mention that vehicles will tend to charge overnight, and at that point the amount of electricity from fossil fuels is a lot lower. https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=16851#tabs_S.. https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=16851#tabs_S.... As wind generation expands with falling costs, particularly offshore, that's likely to fall significantly within the lifetime of a vehicle bought today. Also even if the carbon emissions are the same, there is a large benefit in shifting particulate matter and NOx pollution out of cities.