12 ms·
The thing I think everyone needs to remember for the future is that Google is only backing off on Maven because of the bad PR. They aren't suddenly growing a co
by ocdtrekkie 8y ago
The thing I think everyone needs to remember for the future is that Google is only backing off on Maven because of the bad PR. They aren't suddenly growing a conscience, and you can be sure that given the chance to secretly get involved in a horribly unethical program for hundreds of millions of dollars is still definitely an option for them.
- hammock 8y agoCompanies don't have consciences. "Bad PR," talent drain and other happenings led to this and for PEOPLE (who do have consciences), these can continue to be considered as valid tactics for achieving a desired end.
- it_learnses 8y agothis is so stupid. Meanwhile Chinese govt is going full steam head with AI. This will come back to bite Americans.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoI suspect China will eventually regret creating it's own dystopian society. (Some would argue it is already there.) And anyways, please explain the bogeyman: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17210194 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17210194
- cromwellian 8y agoThat may be a component, but IMHO, pronouncements and explanations haven't diminished employee objections to say the least.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoCorporations have no ethics or morals, though. Google has no conscience of it's own. Employees can perhaps keep it in check, for a while. But the notion that people have held that Google is good for society is a myth, and people are increasingly realizing it. Sure, employees may continue to protest actions like this in the future... if they find out about them. Bear in mind, a significant component of this incident involved Google lying and downplaying the importance of this project. Shortly after yesterday's article containing leaked emails, a Googler expressed public shame of having promoted articles by one of the people in said emails, which explicitly talked about concealing Google's involvement with the military implementing AI, and shortly thereafter, announced intention to leave. This person had blocked me a mere couple months ago for saying that "Google is not worth saving", and today, perhaps they'd agree with me. Eventually, Google will cross a line that everyone considers too far. For me, it was several years ago. For this individual, it was yesterday. How long will Google have people there who still object to the behavior the company engages in? Where's your line?
- cromwellian 8y agoThis is bigger than Google. Microsoft, Amazon, Facebook, Oracle, Palantir, et al, will take this contract next. Google isn't the only company that can run DNNs to do image classification, it's commodified now. The DoD is going to pay money to get this software, it's inevitable, just like they got the Hydrogen bomb, and ICBMs, and biological weapons. Enough people exist out there who are smart and willing to work on it for money, only it won't leak, and won't be public. The public needs to take this event as a canary in the coal mine. Congress needs to limit AI use in the military. If it took Google to scare everyone into finally regulating this, than so be it, but there needs to be transparency and oversight and limits imposed by democracies on this, just like regulations on chemical and biological weapons. Perhaps we need an "AI Weapons Proliferation treaty" or something. But the future of war is automated drone killing machines, they're just way cheaper to built and deploy and less risky. You can build hundreds of automated drones for the cost of one B-2 bomber, and mount a saturation offense against any defender. People need to widen their gaze from fixation on Silicon Valley. The problem is in Washington, the problem is a $700 billion defense budget, a war on terror, and extrajudicial drone assassinations. Everyday people on HackerNews are complaining about ad tracking, navel gazing their industry, meanwhile, they silently accept their own governments tracking people and killing them with hellfire missiles. (I get that people feel helpless with respect to resisting the military industrial complex and feel they can have some say over an industry they're more closing associated with, but I'm pretty sure there's plenty of HN readers who actually favor the US military empire)
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoPresumably, a talented software engineer has literally hundreds of other options besides Google, Microsoft, Amazon, Facebook, Oracle, and Palantir though, right? I agree we need strict regulations on the use of AI in the military. It carries the same risks as nuclear weapons and chemical and biological weapons for disproportionate harm, but without the extreme cost. "I'm pretty sure there's plenty of HN readers who actually favor the US military empire" From the comments of many of the people defending Google's involvement in Project Maven, I am quite confident, unfortunately, that you are correct there as well.
- jacksmith21006 8y agoThink if we look at actual actions of Google we can see they already had a conscious. I assume what "conscience" was intended? Perfect example is China. The government was trying to hack in Gmail account and Google decided to leave China even though a ton of money to be made. Versus Apple handed over all their user data to the government with a complete disregard for privacy to make a buck. "Campaign targets Apple over privacy betrayal for Chinese iCloud users" https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2018/03/apple-privacy-betrayal-for-chinese-icloud-users/ https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2018/03/apple-privacy... But I am not surprised by your post having half truths. I tend to be a super curious person by nature and I see almost every post of yours consistently doing this specifically around Google. I would love to hear the back story? Why? Do you work for a competitor of Google? Why do you make up stuff around Google and always something negative? BTW, I have ZERO problem with posts that are truthful on companies. Nothing wrong with that. But in an age of the Internet it is so easy to look up something posted and see that what is posted is not true. I also understand mistakes are made. But basically every post? Now there must be more to it. Why?
- cmroanirgo 8y agoI think there's a large difference between Google leaving china due to hacking vs working as a U.S. defense contractor. A lot of people look at Google as something more than just a U.S based company and is considered as more of an international company in this regard. So, when Google's parent company decides to align heavily with U.S military, then of course people working in Google, who come from all parts of the globe and cultures, will have a problem. It would be interesting to see the demographics (age, culture & religious views) of those who openly protested. I am sure I'd rather distance myself from Google if it continues to support U.S military contracts and the perfection of killing others.
- jacksmith21006 8y agoAll comes down to doing what is right or what makes you more money. Google staying in China would have made them a ton more money but giving up user data to the government was not acceptable for them. It was for Apple and making a buck.