10 ms·
I"m not really a fan of the GDPR. I don't think it really protects privacy. I think it just uses the power of the EU, a fairly big and strong organization, to i
by DoreenMichele 8y ago
I"m not really a fan of the GDPR. I don't think it really protects privacy. I think it just uses the power of the EU, a fairly big and strong organization, to intimidate the rest of the world to comply with laws that it really shouldn't have legal jurisdiction to enforce globally. I think this is a scary precedent to set that the biggest bully on the block can de facto enforce such standards because the rest of the world is terrified of the consequences of standing up to them.
Isn't this the sort of thing people accuse the US of? The rest of the world makes ugly jokes about "Be careful what you say about the US or they might come liberate you too." The EU is now in the protection racket. When the mob says you should give us a few bucks because it would be a shame if something happened to your business, people recognize that is not nice behavior. But the EU can do the same on the web and some people laud it is a good thing for individuals in the name of personal privacy.
If you want none of your personal info on the web, I have a suggestion: Don't participate in forums, social media, etc.
(Yes, I am guilty of having this opinion without having actually read it. I blogged previously about my opinion this would do bad things to forums. I am shocked to see negative fallout happening so very soon.)
- ak47-1984 8y agoThey aren’t attempting to enforce legislation globally. If a company operates in the EU, it has to comply. For companies that don’t operate in the EU and have no EU customers or traffic, they don’t. Simple
- etatoby 8y agoEven if said foreign companies have EU customers, what can the EU do about it? If I were a foreign company, I would completely ignore GDPR requests. Like > /dev/null, not even bother reading them. This law will only make things (even) more expensive and cumbersome for EU companies wrt. the rest of the world. This is going to be the asinine Cookie Warning all over again, times a hundred.
- M2Ys4U 8y ago> Even if said foreign companies have EU customers, what can the EU do about it? If I were a foreign company, I would completely ignore GDPR requests. Like > /dev/null, not even bother reading them. EU regulators could domesticate their judgments in the jurisdictions where these companies are based. It's entirely possible to do this in most states in the US, for example. Failing that, they could target assets held in the EU or take action whenever corporate officers travel to the EU.
- dbuder 8y agoI read the other day that it applies to EU citizens that are not in the EU at the time.
- minikites 8y ago>If you want none of your personal info on the web, I have a suggestion: Don't participate in forums, social media, etc. Facebook and other data aggregators build profiles of you even if you don't participate directly in those services. The web is different now than it was in 1996.
- djrogers 8y agoAnd GDPR doesnt help with that. I cannot send Facebook a request for my shadow profile, nor demand they delete all such data, as I have no way to ‘identify myself’ to them unless I have a Facebook account.
- FooBarWidget 8y agoYeah I don’t think the data protection authority will agree with that. You should file a complaint at your data protection authority.
- blub 8y agoThey seem to have no problem identifying you without an account and then linking your shadow profile to your real profile, should you create one. I suggest using the identifier you received at birth to make the request plus your e-mail.
- bigbugbag 8y agoYes there is. If your email address is in the contact list harvested by facebook when people register on the website, it is linked to your shadow profile and can be used to show the lack of explicit consent and existence of your shadow profile. It's the path currently explored in a class action against facebook for forced consent and we'll see what happens.
- etatoby 8y agoDoes Facebook have EU offices? If they do, this law will simply make it close them. If they don't, what is the class action even being based on?
- watwut 8y agoThere are multiple professions where not participating online is quite disadvantage.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- foepys 8y agoWhat you are saying is: don't use the internet. Google, Facebook, Twitter, etc. got websites to implement their like buttons everywhere. The information gathered by them is collected and everybody is being tracked wherever they go.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoIf a few mega corporations like google, fb, and twitter are The Problem, why are we making a law that generally applies to everyone and will disproportionately impact smaller organizations instead of dealing with these mega corporations per se? If we aren't as a world terrified of what is being done by small groups like the open source organization announcing it is shutting down in the very post under discussion, why are you defending the GDPR on the idea that it somehow reins in the abuses of FB, Google, etc? Do you have evidence that it is, in fact, reining them in? Or are they just getting with their lawyers, finding cute ways around the problem and carrying on while entire organizations smaller than them suddenly shut down and die because the EU wrote words somewhere that these mega corps likely care relatively little about?
- foepys 8y agoIf you make special laws for a few companies, you are fighting the hydra. There will come something after you fined Google or Facebook long enough for being too big. Defining a size for "mega corporations" is also quite arbitrary and I'd quite worse because it doesn't fight the underlying problem: every human should have the right of privacy. > Do you have evidence that it is, in fact, reining them in? We will see what happens. The first complaints against Facebook and Google have already been filed.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI said dealing with these mega corporations per se. This in no way suggests making special laws for a few companies. If the entire world currently agrees that a handful of companies are The Problem, then there should be some means to go after said handful of companies and get them to stop being The Problem without creating blanket laws negatively impacting the entire world, especially smaller organizations. Dealing directly with a problem company usually involves charging them under existing laws (anti-monopoly laws?) and things like that. It usually does not mean making unenforceable laws that name them by name or define things in a Jim Crow style that clearly targets them in specific and that is unlikely to stand up in court.
- danShumway 8y agoI feel like when people talk about right to privacy they're often using a catch-all for several different concepts. There's a big difference between a right to anonymity and a right to be forgotten. If you have a very strong right to anonymity, a right to be forgotten is less important because it's easier to separate yourself from your online identity. In fact, forgetting information is pretty harmful because anonymous systems need better tools for building and validating reputation. If you have a strong right to be forgotten, anonymity is less important because you can just delete information you regret sharing. And similarly, anonymity is kind of harmful because you now need ways to validate who owns information and ways to control how it's spread. EU seems to be less concerned with anonymity, and more concerned with managing and regulating information after it's already been created and shared. This also kind of rubs the anonymity crowd the wrong way because they've advocated for a while that information isn't necessarily something that you can own like property, and that the Internet should actually be far more immutable than it already is.
- zerostar07 8y ago> There's a big difference between a right to anonymity and a right to be forgotten. Exactly. Privacy also doesnt mean being invisble when interacting with people or machines. It's not a well-defined right, and the limits can often be fuzzy (e.g. a problem that kids often have with parents). Pseudonymity / anonymity can also be subject to gradation.
- zerostar07 8y ago> If you want none of your personal info on the web, I have a suggestion: Don't participate in forums, social media, etc. sensible regulation that defines workable limits of what personal information can be collected, combined with requirements for anonymization when needed is a better solution.
- djrogers 8y agoSome of the early results we are seeing from GDPR make one question how ‘sensible’ it really is.
- sverige 8y agoThis is exactly what happens when you look to lawyers to solve social problems.
- zerostar07 8y ago.. or tecnnological
- bigbugbag 8y agoLet's not forget that GDPR has been introduced to enforce a law that already existed but worked on voluntary self-regulation basis and as such was fully ignored but pretty much every actor. GDPR is also quite weak in this regard as it has few new additions: explicit consent (thanks to snowden exposing prism and despite the largest lobbying campaign against it orchestrated by silicon valley[1]), max possible fine increased so actor like google and facebook would stop paying 150,000€ fines right and left while laughing in the face of European laws, and class actions. Again it's only thanks to snowden revelations that the GDPR weakening personal data protection was overturned. The real change that matters is that now the law can and will apply. [1]: https://lobbyplag.eu/influence https://lobbyplag.eu/influence
- dasil003 8y agoSite operators who shut down their site preemptively because they don't have time to even consider their GDPR stance are not really a strong signal on how sensible the law is. In this case the operator's usage of the word troll to describe what happened is telling. Anyone can send any kind of threatening letter they want, and they are free to report you for non-compliance, but that doesn't mean any action will be taken against you, let alone actual fines. IANAL, but IMHO the chances of any solo forum operator being sanctioned by EU regulators is effectively nil—the purpose of the law is specifically to address usage of personal data, not old-school off-the-shelf forums and other one-off websites where the scope of the data is essentially the core of the service itself. You can argue the only thing that matters is the end result, but I'm not sure there's any way to write meaningful privacy regulation that will not generate a huge wave of FUD, especially with the traditional SV stance that we ought by default to have carte blanche to monetize user data in any way that's effective.
- detaro 8y ago> If you want none of your personal info on the web, I have a suggestion: Don't participate in forums, social media, etc. There are tons of companies processing my personal data that are not web companies. GDPR isn't about "data being on the web", it's about all handling of personal data.
- briandear 8y agoIf you walk into a store and buy something, does the owner not have a right to record relevant personal information as it pertains to the sale, such as when buying a car? This idea that those vendors ought to be required to delete records seems backwards — you aren’t required to interact with entities that do things you don’t like — unless it’s the government, no escaping that. Public records are potentially more harmful than anything Facebook has. For example, I just shipped a 20 foot container of household goods to the US from France — that manifest, including my personal information is public record — I have to explicitly send a letter and request privacy for that shipment — and then remember to renew that request each year or else details of my entire shipment, including my address and contact information are available publicly. Thanks government. I can’t simply use another shipping company — it’s a government rule. When GDPR applies to governments, then I might become a fan, but as it is now, I am being “protected” from my Facebook likes or web history but what protections do I have from governments who traffic in my information. There is zero reason my shipment manifest needs to be known beyond Customs or the shipping company moving the goods, yet, here we are. Facebook never committed mass murder — but governments certainly have. Google Analytics data doesn’t have a realistic chance of causing harm — but someone with my address and a manifest of a shipment of expensive stuff results in a potential for real harm — that stuff is literally public record with absolutely no controls over who can buy that information.
- FooBarWidget 8y agoThe owner of the store does have the right to record the sales transaction data. But that was never under dispute even with GDPR. GDPR specifically says that you do not have the right to be forgotten in the information is important for legal compliance (e.g. tax records), free speech, and a couple of other things. https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-the-general-data-protection-regulation-gdpr/individual-rights/right-to-erasure/ https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-the-general-da... See “when does [it] not apply?” GDPR already applies to governments. What makes you think it is not? https://www2.deloitte.com/nl/nl/pages/risk/articles/gdpr-in-the-public-sector.html# https://www2.deloitte.com/nl/nl/pages/risk/articles/gdpr-in-... > Starting May 25th 2018, all organisations, including those in the public sector, need to comply with the GDPR. Government agencies have been working their asses off to become GDPR compliant. If you have a problem with the way your shipping info is handled, file a complaint against that government agency at the French data protection authority. Please stop the FUD. The right to be forgotten has never been absolute and applies to both companies and government.
- bigbugbag 8y agoYou want a scary precedent ? look at DMCA and it's been used to intimidate and bully all over the world and outside US jurisdiction (the pirate bay case showed that US government outreach went to threat of economic sanctions to a foreign government). The GDPR is probably not what you think is, because it barely introduces new stuff, it only enforces what already existed but was ignored because it was based on self-regulation. There are a number a publications about RGPD explaining that there really nothing to panic about (unless you're a giant conglomerate), it's not going to kill your business unless your business is based on violating privacy and things you should not be doing in the first place because it's been illegal for a while and you had 2 years since the announcement to respect the law. > If you want none of your personal info on the web, I have a suggestion: Don't participate in forums, social media, etc. Does not work that way, actually thanks to RGPD it's now: if you don't want to deal with RGPD requests don't collect or process personal data.
- zerostar07 8y agoby comparison, you literally don't need to do anything to implement DMCA, except perhaps respond to emails. (I wonder why this is contestable? DMCA is an afterthought, GDPR requires a lot of actual work to implement even if you process minimal data like IPs)
- garmaine 8y agoAnd if you respond to those emails you’re not still in danger of a business-closing fine.
- simion314 8y agoSame for GDPR, you just respond to the users with "I don't collect anything on my website". Now if you collect and track you may want to inform the users and let them opt-out. GDPR is similar in a way with the Don't spam me laws, I assume you had to write code to respect this law and I did not see people complaining that they need to write code to respect that law. Or you can not do business with EU citizens.
- 8y ago
- simion314 8y ago>If you want none of your personal info on the web, I have a suggestion: Don't participate in forums, social media, etc. I can visit site A and B, not put any of my data intentionally on them but still my data get be funneled to 25 third parties that know what I visited. So your point is don't use internet or turn of javascript and open each link in private windows and maybe use some proxyes or Tor
- etatoby 8y agoAs a side note, using Brave browser with all protections turned on by default, including Javascript disabled, and re-enabling Javascript (2 clicks) only on the websites you care and trust enough to, has made my Web browsing experience incredibly better, especially on mobile. Now everything loads in an instant, no more shenanigans that jump around the screen as I scroll, no Facebook/Twitter/Google buttons (that nobody even uses), no pop-up/in/out/over adverts, and even those asinine cookie warnings are gone by default! I cannot recommend it well enough.
- gcthomas 8y agoI do the same on Firefox with Privacy Badger and Noscript extensions, supplemented with a PiHole on the network to disappear all those intrusive ads. On my phone, I use Naked Browser Pro, which lets you allow Javascript per site, along with Adaway.
- zaroth 8y ago> 25 third parties that know what you visited Ever try running traceroute?
- simion314 8y agoHow is that relevant here? You mean that when I connect to A there will be some intermediate points, that is true but those points are not setup there to track me, some points will differ, there are protocols to work around tracking at that level(using proxies and VPNs). But if I don't block the tracking scripts and cookies and I have 2 tabs with 2 different sites and both have FB code in it, FB will know I am the same person, they will search in the shadow profiles, find me, add this extra data to the profile. Then 24 more trackers will do the same,
- blub 8y agoYou forgot to mention how this law hits your income quite hard, as you mentioned yourself a while ago: you're using internet advertising as supplemental income. And you're very likely using the services of one of the big players, like Google, the very ones you're suggesting should be explicitly targeted in another message below. Like I said before, including to you: the EU does not owe companies a business model, especially when the costs of that business are externalized to citizens of the EU and of the world. Your so-called alternative at the end is just more of the arrogant snubbing typical of the advertising industry.
- foota 8y agoThe costs are externalized yes but in many of these cases the person losing some privacy also benefits.
- setquk 8y agoSmoking might cure anxiety but that doesn’t mean it doesn’t give you lung cancer...
- Micrococonut 8y agoSo people shouldn't be allowed to smoke if they want to?
- setquk 8y agoIf they want that’s fine but it’s damaging behaviour for society so it will be taxed and/or regulated.
- merinowool 8y agoThe reason it is taxed is because they can get away with it.
- 8y ago
- codedokode 8y ago> If you want none of your personal info on the web, I have a suggestion: Don't participate in forums, social media, etc. If you don't want to get robbed, don't leave your home.
- setquk 8y agoThe GDPR exists because everyone has been a dick because they know they can get away with it. By default the mentality is take take take. Now the business models built on that are being trashed. If someone keeps burgling your house they need to go to prison. Simple as. Time is up for this way of thinking. It is not difficult to be compliant. Most people don’t bother because they are drama queens or hiding what their business is really based on and the latter is usually not ethical by any manor and deserve to be shoved off a cliff. People will have to do some real innovation instead of selling off data and working out how to attract people into a product that exists only to do that really.
- fiter 8y agoSaying that people need to be shoved off a cliff is not elevating your position. In fact, these kind of statements are exactly what make me concerned about regulations and laws. One has already made your mind up about a group of people and now it's time to execute.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoSuch is the result of tech industry overreach. Had they adopted a more moderate stance, people would not be calling for them to be pushed off the proverbial cliff.
- setquk 8y agoYes the data gathering side of the tech industry is sounding like they’re selling menthol cigarettes to sick people at this point.
- setquk 8y agoIt’s a metaphor. You’re already teetering. All it takes is a little push and you’re hurtling to your demise.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoIf it is a metaphor, presumably you mean more like "your business is hurtling to its demise."
- derReineke 8y agoI'm not really sure why you think this. So, the EU should just let companies steal and sell their citizen's information? I mean, IIRC companies can have separate privacy policies for non-EU users. Also, you have a very narrow view of how information is "given" and collected. Literally using the internet is "giving away" your data. Should I go live in a cabin in a remote location surrounded by a Faraday Cage/Lead walls/magic invisible shield?
- EliRivers 8y agoI think this is a scary precedent to set that the biggest bully on the block can de facto enforce such standards because the rest of the world is terrified of the consequences of standing up to them Precedent? It's hardly the first time one powerful body politic has enforced its own standards on others. A very, very, very long way from the first time.
- nkkollaw 8y ago> I think it just uses the power of the EU, a fairly big and strong organization, to intimidate the rest of the world to comply with laws that it really shouldn't have legal jurisdiction to enforce globally. They do have jurisdiction, because the laws apply to companies that want to reach Europeans. It's up to companies whether they think it's worth the effort to reach this market. Companies do some crazy stuff on the other end of the spectrum to have a presence in China, right..?
- merinowool 8y agodelete
- DoreenMichele 8y agoThat sounds like an excellent source of corruption and conflict of interest.
- DanBC 8y agoDo you have any sources please?